To continue reading this article, subscribe to the Stray Ferret for as little as £1 a week
Already a subscriber? Log in here.
19
Nov

Since North Yorkshire County Council’s 2019 Harrogate congestion study I have held the opinion that the subsequent proposal for a gateway project is the wrong solution to an urban design issue – it doesn’t deal with congestion and is a vanity project blinkered and contrived through the dominant input of highway engineers.
North Yorkshire Council, which succeeded the county council, cannot successfully design three-dimensional spaces in an existing urban setting that sits at the heart of a cohesive conservation area. It can only cope with a totally cleared ‘site area’ hence their proposals for the gateway are two-dimensional in concept. It requires an experienced urban design team capable of delivering an appropriate solution.
So how can good urban design contribute to a positive future for Harrogate? It defines the nature of buildings and the spaces between them. It is a skill that brings together ideas from developers, local businesses and communities, architects, town planners, conservationists, landscape architects, traffic engineers, transport planners and many others to resolve problems and conflicts to create better places for everyone to work in, live in and be attractive to visit. Will the gateway achieve these principles? In my opinion — no.
To understand the council’s thinking, I submitted a list of questions to Cllr Malcolm Taylor, who has oversight of the scheme, including one which specifically asked: "Why is a perfectly healthy small-leaf lime tree in Station Square being felled as part of the station gateway project?” It forms part of a group of mature trees adjacent to Station Parade.

Station Square in Harrogate.
The council's arboricultural officer confirmed the tree to be a perfectly healthy specimen worthy of preservation. In their usual wisdom, the council ignored this advice and granted itself approval in record time to fell the tree. Government guidelines make it clear that where an application relates to trees in conservation areas the authority must pay special attention to the ‘desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of the area’.
Harrogate Civic Society’s letter of objection to the felling of this tree mysteriously disappeared into the council’s ether. The felling was approved on November 25, 2024 — corporate vandalism in my opinion. It proves highway engineers are ignorant and totally incapable of taking on board government guidelines in such instances.
After chasing Cllr Taylor for an update, he eventually informed me my questions were being treated as a freedom of information request. I recently received this response from North Yorkshire. It is a plethora of words and waffle, to put it politely. Is it that they are hiding behind a meaningless excess of words or perhaps they are trying to convince me they have put a lot of thought into it.
A summary of their response to the question specifically on the tree was:
What a pathetic response, which proves North Yorkshire's lack of understanding of Harrogate. Here are some thoughts:
It clearly demonstrates North Yorkshire Council highways’ total ignorance and lack of respect for the built environment the gateway project sits in. Any good urban designer would acknowledge site restrictions, mitigate them with lateral thinking and accept it as a design challenge.
The primary reason for the tired appearance of the whole of this area is the lack of ongoing maintenance over time by subsequent councils. This applies to the town in general. Will this trend continue in the future?
Barry Adams, Harrogate
Barry Adams is an award-winning architect who is passionate about design, particularly in relation to the historic built environment and how this can be integrated into modern development.
1