Ripon Conservatives president acquitted of causing death by careless driving

A hotel boss and Tory constituency president has been found not guilty of causing the death of a grandmother by careless driving.

Nicholas Ayrton Bannister, 64, president of Skipton and Ripon Conservatives, was driving his Range Rover in his hotel and spa complex when it collided with 66-year-old Judith Wadsworth who was crossing a pedestrian walkway.

Mrs Wadsworth, who was a guest at the hotel and was there to see her daughter get married, is believed to have died at the scene of the accident at the Coniston Hotel Country Estate & Spa in Skipton.

Mr Bannister, the hotel’s managing director, was charged with causing death by careless driving but denied the allegation and, following a trial at Bradford Crown Court which lasted over a week, the prosecution today decided to offer no further evidence.

Judge Jonathan Gibson directed the jury to return a formal not-guilty verdict and Mr Bannister was allowed to walk free from court. 

Prosecuting barrister Michael Smith said that the “evidential test” had not been met and that there was no longer a “realistic prospect of conviction”.

He said the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) would therefore be offering no further evidence against Mr Bannister.

He added: 

“In light of all the evidence this jury have heard…the CPS take the view there is no longer a realistic prospect of conviction in this case.”

Read more:

Defence barrister Lisa Judge said there had been “flagrant failings” by the CPS in its prosecution of the case, both evidentially and in terms of disclosure. 

She said the defence would be seeking costs for Mr Bannister following the prosecution’s decision to drop the case and the not-guilty verdict. 

Judge Mr Gibson said he thought the prosecution’s decision to drop the case was “entirely appropriate”.   

During the trial, the jury heard that Mr Bannister had turned right out of a junction near the hotel reception and didn’t see Mrs Wadsworth.

The prosecution said that Mrs Wadsworth, who was walking from the car park back to the reception after collecting items from her vehicle, fell under the vehicle but it was not until Mr Bannister got out of his vehicle 20 metres down the road that he realised he had struck someone.

Mrs Wadsworth, who was staying at the country hotel in Coniston Cold to see her daughter Rebecca Blacka get married, suffered fatal injuries. 

Ms Blacka was in the hotel reception at the time of the fatal collision at about 5.20pm on Feb 7, 2020.

Mr Bannister, of Mark House Lane, Bell Busk, near Skipton, had driven the vehicle around a turning circle outside reception and turned right when the Range Rover ran over Mrs Wadsworth on the walkway between the car park and reception area. 

A family statement following Mrs Wadsworth’s death described her as “a devoted wife, mother and grandmother”.

“Judith was a beautiful, selfless person and no words can express our sense of loss and devastation right now,” the statement said.

Ripon Conservatives president denies causing death of woman by careless driving

A hotel boss ran over and killed a woman in the grounds of his spa complex, a court heard. 

Nicholas Ayrton Bannister, 64, was driving his Range Rover out of a junction onto an access road near the hotel reception and car park when the vehicle struck 66-year-old Judith Wadsworth, who was a guest at the Coniston Hotel Country Estate & Spa in Skipton.

Mr Bannister, the hotel’s managing director and president of Skipton and Ripon Conservatives, turned right out of the junction and didn’t see Ms Wadsworth, a jury at Bradford Crown Court was told.

Prosecutor Michael Smith said Ms Wadsworth fell under the vehicle but it was not until Mr Bannister got out of his vehicle 20 metres down the road that he realised he had struck someone.

Ms Wadsworth, who was staying at the country hotel in Coniston Cold to see her daughter Rebecca Blacka get married, suffered fatal injuries. It’s believed she died at the scene.

Ms Blacka was in the hotel reception at the time of the fatal collision at about 5.20pm on Feb 7, 2020.

Mr Smith said: 

“Judith Wadsworth was attending the Coniston Hotel…to attend her daughter’s wedding.

“The party was in reception and people were bringing things into reception, and Mrs Wadsworth was bringing in items for her daughter from the car park into the reception.”

The trial was heard at Bradford Crown Court.

The trial was heard at Bradford Crown Court.

Mr Bannister, who runs the family business, was also in reception chatting to staff. CCTV showed Ms Wadsworth, who is also a grandmother, drop off a box and then go back out to the car park, ostensibly to collect more items from her car.

Mr Bannister then left the reception to get into his vehicle parked outside the hotel to drive to the spa complex. 

He drove the vehicle around a turning circle outside reception and turned right when the Range Rover ran over Ms Wadsworth on a walkway between the car park and the reception area. 

Mr Smith said:

“It’s the prosecution case that in the immediate aftermath of the collision, the defendant repeatedly said (to a witness), ‘I didn’t see her’.

“What’s at the heart of this case is whether the defendant was driving with due care and attention as he drove his Range Rover around his hotel complex.”

He said the fact that Mr Bannister didn’t see Ms Wadsworth “at all, even as he collided with her”, was “evidence that he was driving carelessly”.

Mr Smith added:

“The defence case is that…what happened was an unfortunate accident.

“At the heart of this case is…why the defendant didn’t see Mrs Wadsworth.”

Denies causing death by careless driving

Mr Bannister, of Mark House Lane, Bell Busk, near Skipton, denies causing death by careless driving. The prosecution must prove he was driving carelessly at the time of the collision.

He appeared yesterday for the first day of his trial which is expected to last four days.

Mr Smith said that at the junction of the turning circle and the access road, visibility to the left was obscured by a hotel building and Mr Bannister would also have had to pay attention to vehicles coming from the other direction.

But he said that motorists would also have to pay attention to pedestrians to the right, where he was turning and where Ms Wadsworth, from Baildon near Bradford, was crossing the road on her way back to reception. 

He said that after the Range Rover hit Mrs Wadsworth, Mr Bannister drove on for another 20 metres, only realising he had struck someone when he heard a “noise under the car”.

Natasha Hobson-Shaw, a hotel employee who was the only eye-witness to the collision, was driving out of the complex when she saw the fatal accident.

She said she was driving towards the Range Rover in the opposite direction and stopped her car to allow Mr Bannister to manoeuvre out of the junction.

Mr Smith said:

“As she stopped, she saw Mrs Wadsworth…cross the road and saw the defendant drive into her.

“It may be that Mrs Wadsworth assumed that the defendant was stopping for her as he approached that junction that he was turning out of.”

Read more:

He said that, according to Ms Hobson-Shaw, it was clear that after stopping his vehicle following the collision, Mr Bannister “simply had no clue what had happened”. 

Ms Hobson-Shaw got out of her vehicle to help Ms Wadsworth and Mr Bannister said to her: “I didn’t see her.”

Mr Smith said the Range Rover was travelling at about 9-to-12mph at the point of collision.

He said there was “some debris and a bag” at the scene of the collision which Mrs Wadsworth had been carrying.

The prosecuting barrister added:

“We say that the only reason (Mr Bannister) didn’t see her was because he wasn’t driving with due care and attention.”

A family statement following Mrs Wadsworth’s death described her as “a devoted wife, mother and grandmother”.

The statement said:

“Judith was a beautiful, selfless person and no words can express our sense of loss and devastation right now.”

The trial continues.