Fears for rural bus services post-pandemic

Concerns are mounting for traditional bus services in rural areas as passenger numbers remain well below pre-pandemic rates.

While numerous services were kept afloat across North Yorkshire with £1.5m of subsidies from the county council before covid, the county’s transport boss has stated many are now facing “great pressure” due to a lack of passengers.

Bus demand in Great Britain maintained its downward trend in the quarter before the pandemic, falling by 2.7 per cent, according to statistics published by the Department for Transport, but since covid the number of passengers using North Yorkshire services has dropped by about 30 per cent.

North Yorkshire County Council’s older people’s champion Councillor Caroline Dickinson questioned whether the pandemic had led to a long-term shift in behaviour away from public to private transport.

The member for Northallerton said bus user groups were wanting more bus services in rural areas.

North Yorkshire County Council’s executive member for access, Councillor Don Mackenzie responded by issuing reassurances that the authority had launched initiatives to counter the drop in passengers.

He said alongside the Yorbus initiative, which the authority hopes to roll out elsewhere to improve access to public transport, the council was looking to develop services that were better value for money and more effective as part of its bus services improvement plan, valued at £116m over eight years.

Read more:

Cllr Mackenzie warned the council would always focus its available funds on where it would achieve the strongest outcomes.

He said:

“Clearly bus services, like rail services, have suffered as a result of covid. I understand passenger numbers are still well below where they were before covid came along.

“We’re looking at something like 70 per cent patronage on bus services and because of that the commercial viability of especially rural services remains under great pressure.”

Ripon service

The executive also heard the first three months of Yorbus, its demand responsive travel pilot in the rural area surrounding Bedale, Ripon and Masham, had “exceeded expectations” and achieved the majority of its targets expected at six to 12 months in the first three months of service.

An officers’ report to the meeting stated:

“Feedback from customers has, on the whole, been extremely positive, and the high levels of customer satisfaction are reflected in the number of repeat passengers using the service.

“During the quarter, 98.5 per cent of all completed bookings were made via the customer app and 1,541 accounts were created in the first three months, against a target of 171.”

Cllr Mackenzie added:

“At the moment we invest £1.5m a year subsidising rural bus services and in addition to that £7m a year on bus passes under the national concessionary travel scheme.

“We are doing plenty for it, but inevitably value for money will come into this. Our ultimate aim is to make rural bus services much more viable by improving patronage.”

Harrogate district MPs silent on Downing Steet Xmas party allegations

All three MPs representing the Harrogate district have declined to answer questions from the Stray Ferret about the alleged parties held at 10 Downing Street and in Whitehall last year.

We asked Andrew Jones, who represents Harrogate and Knaresborough, Julian Smith, who represents Skipton and Ripon, and Nigel Adams, who represents Selby and Ainsty, what they knew about the parties and what reaction they had received on the matter from constituents.

As usual, the three Conservative MPs did not respond.

However, Lord Newby, the Liberal Democrat leader in the House of Lords, who lives in Ripon, did speak out today.

He tweeted:

“Ministers now looking foolish defending PM.

“Why did Allegra Stratton feel she had to go if nothing happened at No 10?

“Setting up narrow enquiry into Downing Street party purely designed to buy time, fools no-one.”

Read more:

It was revealed today that civil servants will launch an official investigation into the alleged parties.

There has been considerable coverage of the issue since the Daily Mirror claimed on November 30 that the Prime Minister and his staff broke coronavirus rules by attending parties at Number 10 in the run-up to last Christmas.

That report said 40 to 50 people attended a party on December 18, when London was in tier three lockdown restrictions.

Under those restrictions indoor mixing was banned and thousands has to spend Christmas away from their families.

Commissioner candidates questioned: Tackling inequality

In the third of a series of articles on crime issues in the Harrogate district, candidates standing to be North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner are questioned on equality.

Candidates hoping to succeed controversy-hit Philip Allott as North Yorkshire’s Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner have pledged to increase efforts to tackle equality issues facing North Yorkshire’s police and fire services, with one hopeful insisting a community-wide effort is needed to effect lasting change.

However, ahead of York and North Yorkshire residents going to the polls on Thursday, there are differences in the way candidates for the £74,000-a-year role believe equality concerns, both inside and outside the services, should be addressed.

The latest published workforce profile for the fire service from 2018 shows 95% of operational officers are male, and 84% described themselves as white British.

While the service says it supports staff to respect individual values and differences and takes an active part in diversity events, such as Pride, just one per cent of staff said they were homosexual in the profile.

Among the many equality issues North Yorkshire Police is trying to tackle includes a gender gap that is significantly above the national average, despite its chief officer team comprising more women than men.

Read More:

The force has said it is committed to setting challenging equality objectives, but the five challengers following Mr Allott resigning over women’s safety comments all insist more could be being done by both services.

Hannah Barham-Brown, Women’s Equality Party

Hannah Barham-Brown, of the Women’s Equality Party said ending gender-based violence would be her top priority, and would work to identify issues that most affect women in North Yorkshire.

She said: 

“Equality is not something that can take place just inside or out of the services – it’s a collective, communal movement that requires the participation and contribution of every member of the community.”

Keith Tordoff, Independent

Independent Keith Tordoff said he would ensure hate crime and hate incidents were being dealt with properly to protect marginalised groups. 

He said: 

“With confidence in the police, recruiting from diverse and ethnic backgrounds will be more likely for the police and fire service of North Yorkshire.”

Emma Scott-Spivey, Labour

Labour candidate Emma Scott-Spivey said equality would be at the heart of all the work she does, adding it would be “hardwired into my police, fire and crime plan and it will be something that I will expect the services I oversee to reflect”.

She said: 

“As will a zero tolerance approach to crime, including hate crime, that targets protected groups. I will be the voice for all people but most of all for those whose views are not being heard.”

James Barker, Liberal Democrat

Making the services “genuinely inclusive places to work where diversity is championed” is vital, said Liberal Democrat James Barker, before adding North Yorkshire “is ahead of the game in some respects in that it was one of the first forces in the country to record misogyny as a hate crime”.

He said: 

“We need to protect and support all of North Yorkshire’s diverse communities, and I will ensure that guidance and training is introduced to make services trans inclusive and implement a strategy to provide specialist BAME and LGBT+ services.”

Zoe Metcalfe, Conservative

Conservative candidate Zoe Metcalfe said she would work with the services to ensure the correct recruitment strategies are in place. 

Mrs Metcalfe said: 

“There can be no room for inequalities in North Yorkshire and I will ensure the commissioner’s office leads the way on equality issues and will work with senior figures within the services so they do likewise.”

Harrogate MP silent after saying scrapping HS2 would ‘betray the north’

Harrogate and Knaresborough MP Andrew Jones has so far remained silent on the expected scrapping of plans to extend the HS2 line from Birmingham to Leeds.

The former rail minister has been a vocal advocate of the project. In February 2019, he said that it would be a “betrayal of the north” if it did not go ahead.

However, government sources briefed national media outlets over the weekend about the decision ahead of an expected announcement on Thursday.

Just two months ago Mr Jones reiterated his support for HS2 at the annual Transport for the North conference in Leeds. He said:

“I hope that we do not see any compromise on our desire for big investment in our infrastructure. We have failed spectacularly to invest enough in our infrastructure.

“This has meant it is now too expensive and too difficult to move people and goods around the country. So I do not support the argument that we need to abandon longer term infrastructure investment.”

Read more:

At a previous Transport for the North conference in February 2019, Mr Jones went further and criticised media outlets for reporting speculation over the future of the HS2 Birmingham to Leeds line.

“We have all probably seen some media reports claiming that the northern stages of HS2 might not be built. They are nonsense.

“HS2 was conceived, developed and is now being delivered as a national railway. But in particular to improve links for our area.

“So our commitment to the full network of HS2 is undiminished. To cancel anything would be a betrayal of the north.”

The Stray Ferret asked Mr Jones for his thoughts this morning. However, he did not reply to our request for comment by the time of publication.

North Yorkshire PFCC candidate launches campaign with single policy

A candidate for the North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner (PFCC) by-election has launched her manifesto with a single policy.

Dr Hannah Barham-Brown, on behalf of the Women’s Equality Party (WEP), has written a manifesto with a single policy to end violence against women and girls.

She unveiled her manifesto today at Oatlands community centre in Harrogate before she said she would bring a revolutionary approach to the role of PFCC.

The WEP candidate then said she would work with politicians to urge them to do more for women concerned about the threats they face.

Dr Hannah Barham-Brown said:

“I am contesting this election for one reason and for one reason only: to put ending violence against women and girls front and centre in our policing and political priorities in North Yorkshire, and I challenge all of my fellow candidates to join me in this.

“So far in the campaign, I’ve seen other candidates pay lip-service to ending violence, but offering no clear plan on how they’ll do so. Enough is enough.

“While this doesn’t mean I won’t engage with residents’ concerns on a wide range of topics, it does mean I will be singularly focused on ending violence in my campaign.”

During her speech Dr Barham-Brown added that women and girls had been badly let down by Philip Allott, who stepped down as PFCC after his comments on the Sarah Everard case.

Read more:

If elected, she has pledged to fund specialist support for those who have reported abuse or sexual violence, introduce an expert scrutiny panel for rape and sexual violence cases.

Her plan also includes rooting out misogyny in the police force, addressing racism in domestic abuse cases and guaranteeing that migrant women have access to specialist support.

She added:

“This violence is not inevitable, but we are at this point because of a total failure of political leadership.

“Politicians of all parties are consistently failing to show up for women, except when it’s already too late.

“Women and girls deserve a PFCC who focuses on ending violence against women – not just managing it – every day and not just when it hits the headlines.

“I promise to deliver that. Women and girls in North Yorkshire deserve to live free from threat and fear of violence, and with the right political leadership we can make that happen.”

Other candidates for the PFCC role

The election of North Yorkshire PFCC will be held on November 25.

Harrogate becomes battleground for National Trust woke and hunting rows

Harrogate became the battleground today in the ongoing debates about wokeness and hunting at the National Trust.

The charity held its annual general meeting at the Harrogate Convention Centre today. Local people passing the building this morning may have noticed a wave of green protesters outside from the League Against Cruel Sports.

But there was also another group, Restore Trust, campaigning for change on the inside at the meeting.

The trust, which has more than 500 properties including Fountains Abbey and Studley Royal Water Garden near Ripon, held various votes today to determine how the organisation moves forward.

Some of the motions to have attracted national media attention were for a ban on hunting on trust land and for the protection of volunteers who refuse to support political movements.

Orna NiChionna Turner, deputy chair of the National Trust, speaking at the event today.

Emma Judd, deputy director of policy, campaigns and communications at the League Against Cruel Sports, told the Stray Ferret:

“I am overwhelmed by how much support we have got, they have come from near and far to give up their time because they are passionated about animal welfare.

“Hunting was made illegal in 2004. But after the ban came trail hunting. We have been saying for a long time that it is often a smokescreen for illegal hunting.

“So by allowing trail hunting, the National Trust is risking criminal activity on their land. Hopefully we can make history in Harrogate today if the National Trust bans it.”

Read more:

Cornelia van der Poll, a spokesperson for Restore Trust denied any interest in wokeness despite it being the centre of a great deal of media coverage in the run up to the AGM. She told the Stray Ferret:

“We have put forward three resolutions today on remuneration, on curators and on volunteers. The woke debate is not something I am interested in.

“Restore Trust is interested in proper consultation of staff, members and volunteers. We are interested in proper curatorship and the things the National Trust looks after.

“It should not be Disneyfied or dumbed down but presented in a scholarly way that presents understanding. That is the way. We should not be amused or entertained but to understand and appreciate.”

Women’s Equality Party puts forward police commissioner candidate

The Women’s Equality Party (WEP) has put forward a candidate for the North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner (PFCC) by-election following the resignation of Philip Allott.

Dr Hannah Barham-Brown, who is well-known for her campaigning work on both women’s and disabled people’s rights, is set to contest the role.

While some candidates for this election stood at the previous election in May when Mr Allott won, this is the first time that Dr Barham-Brown has put herself forward for North Yorkshire’s PFCC.

If elected, she said her first step would be to launch an independent inquiry into misogyny and sexism in North Yorkshire Police.

Dr Barham-Brown, the Women’s Equality Party candidate for the North Yorkshire PFCC by-election said:

“If elected as PFCC I will put ending violence against women and girls at the top of the policing and political agenda.

“Women and girls in North Yorkshire deserve to live their lives free from the fear and the threat of violence, and that is why I am contesting this election.

“We were let down by Philip Allott as our PFCC who proved he didn’t understand the importance of ending violence against women and girls with his disgraceful, victim blaming comments.

“But our community did not accept that and now it’s time to finish the job.”

Read more:

The PFCC is being held following the resignation of Mr Allott, who stepped down after his comments on the murder of Sarah Everard led to hundreds of official complaints and a vote of no confidence.

Voters will head to the polls to elect a new police commissioner on November 25.

Mandu Reid, leader of the Women’s Equality Party, added:

“Ending gender-based violence must be at the heart of this election, so we can build a better future for women and girls in North Yorkshire.

“I am delighted that Dr Hannah Barham-Brown is contesting this election for the Women’s Equality Party.

“We need real political leadership that focuses on accountability and preventing violence against women, not just managing it.”

Other candidates for the PFCC role

Strayside Sunday: Get a grip or election defeat looms

Strayside Sunday is our monthly political opinion column. It is written by Paul Baverstock, former Director of Communications for the Conservative Party. 

Oh dear.  Since last we communed in these pages the Prime Minister has had to accept the resignation of his Secretary of State for Health Matt Hancock and, as a result it seems, failed to win an important by-election this week down the road in Batley and Spen, when set fair to do so.  Has the electoral worm turned?

When Mr. Hancock was caught on CCTV in the corridor outside his office at the Department for Health and Social Care the grainy images showed him engaged in enthusiastic tongue wrestling with his advisor Gina Colangelo, his hand clearly grabbing her bottom.  Not a dignified look.  Both parties concerned are married (but sadly not to each other) with six children between them.  When confronted with the story, Mr. Hancock’s hand was forced and he told his wife and family he was in love with another and would be setting up shop with Gina.

While marriage break up is often a cause for sadness, especially when children are involved, Mr. Hancock has let it be known through friends that he has found a “love match.”  Good for him.  Initially the PM let it be known that everyone was entitled to a private life and that he considered the matter closed.  Boris being Boris he could hardly have done anything else.  If he had sacked the man, he would have brought the chequered history of his own private life into sharp relief, which the media would have gleefully welcomed.

The issue of course is that Ms. Colangelo had been advising Mr. Hancock in government.  Further, following a period during which she acted in an unpaid capacity, she was then appointed to the board of the DHSC as a Non-Executive Director paid £15,000 annually from the public purse.  In other words, she became a public servant tasked with marking her lover’s homework.  In the United States this would be called “inside the beltway” and just won’t do.

Mr. Hancock tried to hang on to see which way the political wind was blowing; his fate sealed when his own party, in the form of cabinet ministers and MP’s, named and unnamed, turned against him and briefed the media that his behaviour was not on.  He resigned and posted a doleful video mea culpa to his Twitter account.  And with that he was gone.  No more lectures on rules of six and social distancing from our bouncy school prefect.

No one emerges from this sorry matter with much credit; the Health Secretary, his advisor, nor the PM.  But what grinds my gears most is that the British national media was shown again at its sanctimonious and hypocritical worst.  I want to know where, when and how did The Sun receive security footage from inside a government department?  And, while I agree that Ms. Colangelo’s paid position at the DHSC of course represented a conflict of interest for both parties, one must think that the hacks at the current bun were most excited by the prurient way it all came to light.  There is nothing the tabloids like more than a bit of how’s your father in public life.  And don’t we all?

A good friend of mine, an erstwhile bigwig in local government, is a member of the 2019 parliamentary intake.  A formidable campaigner, the aforesaid honourable member had been spending a significant amount of time recently telephone canvassing, knocking doors and delivering leaflets in the Conservative interest in the Batley and Spen constituency. We saw each other three weeks ago for a catch up and drink was taken.  Heavy in our botanicals he convinced me that the seat would be won, such was the blue-tinged sentiment on the doorstep.  Just a short cameo this week for our own Andrew Jones MP; Harrogate’s finest was spotted helping the cause in Batley and Spen, sharing fish and chips with the candidate.  No word on whether mushy peas or curry sauce provided the accompaniment.

Just three weeks ago the party was convinced it was on for another astonishing Red Wall win.   As it transpired the Labour Party held the seat by just 323 votes, Kim Leadbeater holding off the Conservative Ryan Stephenson.  Amanda Milling MP, the Conservative Party Co-Chair admitted that the Hancock affair had been a contributory factor in the final days leading up to the vote.  Of course it was; we don’t like being told what to do at the best of times but this government is clearly of the “do as I say” not “do as I do” school.

No one has been happier in all of this than the dreadful Dominic (Barnard Castle) Cummings.  Having attempted to bring Matt Hancock down during his appearance before a joint parliamentary committee hearing into the coronavirus – “he should have been sacked 17 times etc.” – Mr. Cummings has been playing out his own personal psychodrama through endless blogs and Twitter chains.  The man’s ego, as well as his prose, knows few bounds.  I guess that’s what happens when you are played by Benedict Cumberbatch on the telly.

In the end one is left with a vague and uneasy feeling that the ship of state isn’t being run by men and women of principle or decency.  People fall in love all the time.  They have affairs and leave marriages.  But Matt Hancock was the first to tell us he had been working tirelessly to beat coronavirus, yet, in addition to his work battling a national crisis and being a husband and father to three children he found the time to have a passionate affair.  Boris was willing to let this go unpunished because his own copy book is far from clean in this regard.  All of this contributes to a feeling of one rule for them, one for the rest of us.  Unless the government gets a grip, that way electoral defeat looms.

That’s my Strayside Sunday.

Do you have a view on this column or is there a political issue you’d like Paul to write about? Get in touch on paul@thestrayferret.co.uk

Harrogate council leader: Sustainable transport ‘will always cause controversy’

Harrogate Borough Council leader Richard Cooper says schemes to improve walking and cycling infrastructure in the town “will always cause controversy” but they are essential to reduce emissions.

Cllr Cooper was speaking yesterday evening at a Q+A session for members of the Yorkshire and Humber Climate Coalition, of which he is vice-chair.

Proposals such as the Station Gateway scheme have divided opinion in Harrogate with some welcoming it as a bold step to encourage people out of cars but others believing it will hurt local businesses and shops.

The Stray Ferret asked Cllr Cooper why these schemes have been so divisive and what local politicians can do to ensure they bring all residents along with them.

In response, he said local politicians have “to be honest with people” about the climate challenges ahead and accept that they will not please everyone.

He said:

“You can’t say we support sustainable transport but on the other hand carry on using cars. The two things are not able to be done at the same time.

“Sustainable transport means taking away tarmac from cars to buses, bikes and walking. That will always cause controversy.

He added:

“People want to carry on as they are. If we carry on we’ll never get to net-zero. Travel is one of the biggest emitters. It’s about being honest with people and the putting facts in front of people.”

“Whenever you change things it’s going to be divisive. You’ll never get everyone agreeing with you.

“If people are committed to net-zero they have to realise that we can’t have no change and expect things to get better.”

Read more:

Cllr Cooper also responded to a question about the impact of new housing developments on the environment in Yorkshire.

He said that in Harrogate he gets housing developers together with residents to discuss environmental issues.

“I try and get developers together with local residents to talk about how we can get cycle routes or how we can put green barriers in. 

“Every developer wants residents to support their development. They will usually be amiable to discussion with residents.”

The Yorkshire and Humber Climate Coalition was set up earlier this year to bring public, private and third sectors together to support climate actions across the region.

Other members include Liz Barber, the CEO of Yorkshire Water, Dan Jarvis MP, the Mayor of the Sheffield City Region, and Professor Andy Gouldson from the University of Leeds.

Bilton by-election: every candidate announced

All the candidates have been named for the Bilton & Nidd Gorge county council by-election on May 6.

The election is taking place following the death of Liberal Democrat Geoff Webber.

The six candidates are all hoping to join Conservative Paul Haslam as the second North Yorkshire County Council councillor for the ward.

The Conservatives, Liberal Democrats, Labour and the Yorkshire Party all said on Friday that they would pause campaigning as a mark of respect for Prince Phillip.

The candidates are below:

Liberal Democrats 

Andrew Kempston-Parkes has previously served as a councillor for Bilton on Harrogate Borough Council. He is a local businessman and is the managing director of a chartered surveying firm.

He said:

“The Bilton & Nidd Gorge division is a very special community to me. As Bilton’s councillor, I worked hard to not only protect green space, but also to invest in it.”

Conservatives

Cllr Matt Scott has represented the Bilton Woodfield ward on Harrogate Borough Council since 2018 and works in Harrogate and Knaresborough Conservative MP Andrew Jones’ office. He has lived in Bilton all his life.

He said:

“I will work hard to ensure we continue to have great schools, safe neighbourhoods and that our valuable green spaces remain untouched.”

Harrogate & District Green Party

Arnold Warneken was a Green HBC councillor in the 1990s and went to school in Bilton. He is a partner in an organic horticulture & food distribution business.

He said:

“Local councils must have our climate in mind as we build the economy back after Covid.”

Labour

Tyler Reeton is the youngest candidate at 19 years old and lives in Bilton. He works in retail and recently set up a community Facebook page for the Bilton area.

He said:

“I’m young but it doesn’t mean I have any less passion for the area.”

Yorkshire Party

John Hall has lived in Yorkshire all his life and moved to the Harrogate area over 6 years ago.

He said:

“Unfortunately, the party does not yet have a Biltonian which I appreciate would have been an advantage. So I have a lot of catching up to do. However, if elected this will be easily overcome by working closely with the community.”

Independent

Harvey Alexander is standing as an independent. He contested the Bilton Woodfield HBC seat for UKIP in 2018. 

Read more:

The Conservative-controlled county council currently has 53 Conservative councillors, four Labour councillors and four representing the Liberal Democrats. There are also eight North Yorkshire Independent and three independent councillors.

When the Bilton & Nidd Gorge seat was last run in 2017, Conservative Paul Haslam and Liberal Democrat Geoff Webber won the ward’s two seats with 1,618 and 1,414 votes respectively.

Liberal Democrat Mark McDermid came third with 1,285 votes and Conservative Graham Swift was fourth with 1,207 votes.