A number of Harlow Hill residents have questioned why North Yorkshire Police took 18 hours to offer any reassurance to families after alleged gunshot last weekend.
Residents have also criticised police claims that they responded immediately, saying armed officers took about 45 minutes to arrive and the police helicopter was deployed later still.
Police say they were called to reports of “loud bangs” in the Pinewoods at 5.01pm on Friday.
Armed officers attended and were stood down shortly after 7pm. But another 16 hours passed until police issued a five-paragraph media statement at 11.04am the following day.
The Stray Ferret has received calls from several residents saying children had been playing in the Pinewoods at the time of the noises and people were frightened. They were therefore disappointed not to be kept informed by police.
One person said:
“There was no reassurance whatsoever. We are a community very close to Harrogate police station and I would have thought some form of panic prevention and reassurance would have been issued.”
Read more:
- Police search of Harrogate’s Pinewoods found nobody with a weapon
- Five Harrogate firefighters could lose jobs in plans to reduce service
Residents praised the police for sending armed officers and a police helicopter but said the following day’s media statement, which said ‘officers immediately attended and carried out an extensive search in the area’, was misleading.
They said two plain clothes officers turned up after about 10 minutes but the length of time it took armed officers and the helicopter to arrive, although understandable given that those involved had to travel, allowed plenty of time for anyone responsible to leave the Pinewoods.
‘Proportionate response’
Andy Colbourne, Chief Inspector for Harrogate and Craven, told the Stray Ferret the force control room assessed 999 calls to ensure a proportionate response and he was satisfied the right action was taken in this instance. He said:
“We provided a response that was suitable to the information we had at the time.”
Chief Inspector Colbourne added he did not know exactly when the armed officers and police helicopter arrived on the scene.
He said a male in the area was searched on the night but released because “nothing was found on him that would link him in any way to the incident”.
Chief Inspector Colbourne added he would look into the delay in issuing any update to the community, adding:
Harrogate town council referendum will be held ‘as soon as possible’“If we are getting calls from the public about something that could be significant I would expect they will get an update quickly.”
A referendum to decide whether Harrogate should create a town council will be held “as soon as possible,” the county’s leader has said.
Harrogate and Scarborough are the only major places in North Yorkshire not to be parished and could be given control over areas including parks, tourism and events when the seven county and borough councils are abolished in April.
Councillor Carl Les, leader of North Yorkshire County Council, said he has faced calls from local politicians, businesses and community groups for the town councils to be created.
But he added it would be up to residents to decide via a vote whether the plans should go ahead.
He told the Local Democracy Reporting Service:
“I’m a great advocate of parish and town councils, and I do believe Harrogate and Scarborough would be well served if they had them.
“That said, it is for the people to decide whether they want them or not.
“I’m very keen that we start the process as soon as possible and we will go to the public in Harrogate and Scarborough at the earliest opportunity.”
Read more:
- Liberal Democrats push for creation of Harrogate Town Council
- Harrogate set to have just one fire engine at night
The creation of town councils would require a community governance review and it is understood that legal powers to start the process have been handed to the county council’s new executive.
Cllr Les said the legislation was now being examined and the authority would work alongside Harrogate and Scarborough’s borough councils.
Could take a year
He also said it would be “logical” for the town councils to be created after the new North Yorkshire Council launches next April.
His comments come after Cllr Pat Marsh, leader of Harrogate’s Liberal Democrats, called last week for the process to start “within the next couple of months”.
When asked when the referendums could be held, Cllr Les said this was currently unclear but he added it would be “as soon as possible”. He said:
“We are getting a lot of requests about town councils made to us from people including local politicians, as well as the business community and groups like Harrogate Civic Society.
“There is clearly an appetite to do something about this.
“And of course the sooner we can do it, the sooner we can find out whether there is an appetite amongst the general population.
“They are the key people in all of this. They have to be asked for their opinion and will say yea or nay.”
Councillor Les also said there was a possibility that more than two town or parish councils could be created – if that’s what voters wanted. He said:
“Another aspect to this of course is – how many councils?
“Would Harrogate or Scarborough just want one town council each, or perhaps there are options to consider about the various parts of the towns being parished.
“This is all part of the work that will have to be done.”
North Yorkshire’s Chief Constable admits policing contains racismNorth Yorkshire’s Chief Constable issued an apology today after admitting that policing “still contains racism, discrimination and bias”.
Lisa Winward was speaking in response to the publication of the Police Race Action Plan, which covers all forces in England and Wales.
The plan outlines proposals, such as mandatory training for all police officers and staff about racism and Black history.
However, although it admits failures, it does accept that forces are institutionally racist, which has drawn criticism from the father of Stephen Lawrence, who was murdered in a racially motivated attack in London in 1993.
Chief Constable Winward said in a statement:
“On behalf of North Yorkshire Police, and all our current and former employees, I accept that policing still contains racism, discrimination and bias.
“I apologise for where North Yorkshire Police has fallen short of the standards we hold ourselves to, and the impact that this has had on individuals, communities and police colleagues.
“However, there is also frustration – both inside and outside of policing – that we have not been able to tackle the accusation of being institutionally racist.
“We have fantastic officers and staff supporting the communities of North Yorkshire who come to work every day to make a positive difference to the lives of everyone we have responsibility for.
“The national Police Race Action Plan proposes that racist bias continues to persist in policing due to our processes and systems. We can’t begin to tackle this issue until we accept that there is a problem in how our force operates.
“We are going to use the Plan to shine a light on the disparities that exist in how we police our communities and individuals and explain or amend our ways of working.”
Read more:
- Gay man says Harrogate police take women victims of stalking more seriously
- Harrogate’s Sun Pavilion awarded Grade II listed building status
Chief Constable Winward added North Yorkshire Police would put plans in place “to challenge our own policies, procedures and practice” and would “work closely” with North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe on making changes.
‘Right and courageous’
Ms Metcalfe said in a statement:
“There should be no place for racism in North Yorkshire and York, and no place for racism in North Yorkshire Police.
“This action plan, the response of police forces nationwide and reaction of North Yorkshire’s Chief Constable is welcome.
“Unless we recognise there is a problem, not enough will be done to address it, so it is right and courageous for Lisa Winward to accept that policing still contains racism, discrimination and bias.”
She urged people to take part in a national survey on the plan, which has gone out for consultation. It can be completed here.
Bilton has ‘sufficient primary places’ if Woodfield school closes
Education officials have said there should be “sufficient primary places” in Bilton if Woodfield Community Primary School closes, even though most nearby schools are full.
A report to councillors today will recommend they approve beginning a consultation on closing Woodfield by December 31 this year at the earliest.
The report recommends the consultation is shortened from the usual six weeks to four weeks because of “the urgency of the position and the need to provide as much clarity as possible to parents before the summer holidays”.
It says parents and carers of the 37 pupils remaining at Woodfield will be asked to apply for the preferred school that they would like their child to transfer to in the event of closure, adding:
“Once the full picture of all preferences is known, the local authority would liaise with the schools regarding potential allocations, and seek to meet the highest stated preferences wherever possible.”
Read more:
- Woodfield school closure ‘an absolute disgrace’, says union
- Bilton community centre to offer free meals as cost of living hits hard
Woodfield has a capacity of 150 pupils — 113 more than it currently caters for. Many parents have moved their children amid the ongoing uncertainty.
Nearby schools full
Nearby Bilton Grange Primary School, Grove Road Community Primary School and Richard Taylor Church of England Primary School are all currently operating beyond capacity, the report says, while St Robert’s Catholic Primary School is one pupil below capacity.
Woodfield’s closure would therefore put pressure on nearby schools but the report to councillors at tomorrow’s North Yorkshire County Council children and young people’s service committee says:
“There are no significant housing permissions within the Woodfield school catchment area, although there are several housing developments underway or planned in neighbouring school catchment areas.
“If the closure proposal went ahead, there would be a reduction of 150 primary school places available in the local area.
“Given current forecasts, including the likely demand from new housing, and current patterns of parental preference, there would appear to be sufficient primary places available in the local area, should the closure of Woodfield school be approved, as overall birth rates are falling in Harrogate district, and pupils living in the Woodfield school catchment area already attend a wide variety of primary schools.”
The report says pupil numbers determine school funding and Woodfield is forecast to have a budget deficit of £97,000 this year and a cumulative deficit of £229,000 by 2023/24.
Future of site unclear
A decision on the future of the school site has yet to be made. The report says:
“The county council owns the school site, which also accommodates Bilton and Woodfield Community Library, Harrogate Bilton children and family hub, and Oak Beck House.
“Decisions about the future use of the school premises will be taken after the closure proposal has been determined.”
Woodfield was rated inadequate by Ofsted in 2020. It subsequently failed to find an academy sponsor and a proposed merger with Grove Road fell through this year.
Harrogate set to have just one fire engine at nightHarrogate fire station’s overnight capacity looks set to be halved under new proposals.
The station, on Skipton Road, currently operates two fire engines 24 hours a day. But under plans put forward today, it would have just one appliance from 10pm to 9am when fewer incidents usually occur.
North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe has suggested the move as part of a three-month consultation on proposed changes to fire and rescue services, which she launched today.
Ms Metcalfe wants to get rid of the station’s tactical response vehicle and have two emergency appliances instead. But only one emergency appliance would operate at non-peak hours overnight.
If approved, the move could result in some Harrogate firefighters facing redeployment elsewhere in the county.
Ms Metcalfe’s new Risk and Resource Model 2022-2025, which sets out how the fire service would deploy its people, equipment and resource, comes against a worrying financial backdrop.
‘Struggling to buy the basics’
Three months ago the Fire Brigades Union warned North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service was “struggling to buy the basics” and in need of a £25 million loan.
Ms Metcalfe, who will discuss her proposals at her monthly public accountability meeting tomorrow, said in a statement:
“The role of a fire and rescue service has changed and continues to change, with only 26% of our incidents last year relating to a fire emergency.
“We want to ensure we are addressing our current and future challenges and that we have the capacity to prevent and protect to stop incidents happening in the first place and prevent harm before it can take place, while also having the capacity to respond to emergencies when they do take place. We are confident these proposals would do that.
“Inevitably, there are some areas where the setup of the service would change but I’m confident the right people, right equipment and the right support would continue to be available to everyone.”
Ms Metcalfe’s office said in a statement today that there was a higher demand for services during daytime hours than at night, and the proposed change in Harrogate would offer “increased ability to respond during daytime hours, as well as boost resilience more widely”.
Read more:
- Masham Police House to be sold as officers relocate to fire station
- Jennyfields has Harrogate’s noisiest neighbours
However, it declined to answer questions from the Stray Ferret about how many firefighters faced redeployment, saying Ms Metcalfe would address questions in tomorrow’s meeting.
Ms Metcalfe will hold 12 events in North Yorkshire to discuss the proposals, including one in Harrogate, as well as running an online questionnaire.
Chief fire officer Jon Foster said:
“The risk and resource model would support the transformation of our fire and rescue service and enable a greater focus on prevention that is underlined by our assessment of community risk. It would also facilitate increased investment in our on-call service.”
The Stray Ferret has approached the Fire Brigades Union for comment.
Multiple vehicle crash on A1 at Allerton ParkEmergency services were called out shortly after midnight last night to reports of a car crash on the A1 in the Harrogate district.
Two people needed treatment from ambulance crews at the scene following the incident, which happened on the northbound carriageway at junction 47.
North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service‘s incident log says firefighters from Knaresborough and Harrogate attended a “multi-vehicle road traffic collision”. It adds:
“On arrival crews found that no persons were trapped. Two walking wounded casualties with minor injuries were left in the care of police and ambulance crews.
“Crews made the scene safe and carried out a thorough search of the embankment for further casualties. Incident left in the hands of police.”
Read more:
- Man seriously injured in crash on Harrogate’s Leeds Road
- ‘Oyez! Oyez! Oyez!’ Knaresborough’s town crier ready for special jubilee weekend
Have devolution fears that Harrogate will be voiceless come true?
One of the key concerns in the run-up to this year’s shake-up of North Yorkshire local government was that the vast new unitary authority could leave the Harrogate district without a strong voice.
This week, when the dust settled on the local elections and Carl Les, the Conservative leader of North Yorkshire County Council named his new 10-person executive team, the concerns appeared to have merit.
Just one councillor from the district — Michael Harrison, who represents Killinghall, Hampsthwaite and Saltergate, was included on the executive.
It means many of those making key decisions affecting Harrogate, Ripon, Knaresborough, Boroughbridge, Pateley Bridge and Masham might not even have been to some of those places.
For the last 48 years, local political decision making has been shared between North Yorkshire County Council and Harrogate Borough Council.
But with the latter in its death throes, it seems likely that all local political decisions will soon be made at County Hall, the 1906 Grade II listed building in Northallerton, a market town in Hambleton, firstly by North Yorkshire County Council and then by North Yorkshire Council.
Just nine of the 47 Conservative councillors on the county council are from the district. So will the Harrogate district not have adequate representation?
‘Strong voice will remain’
Despite the changes, Cllr Harrison told the Stray Ferret he is confident the district will continue to have a strong voice.
He said local councillors will shape the executive’s decisions, firstly through task groups that will inform the transition to the new North Yorkshire Council next year and then through the Harrogate and Knaresborough Area Constituency Committee.
Read more:
- ‘Where’s the infrastructure?’ New councillor queries 480-home Bluecoat Wood plan
- ‘Tough cookie’ Masham councillor becomes final chair of county council
The six area constituency committees are expected to be given stronger powers next year, possibly over key issues such as planning, as part of Cllr Les’ ‘double devolution’ pledge. The Lib Dems will have eight of the 13 councillors on the one for Harrogate and Knaresborough.
Cllr Harrison said:
“There will be real power devolved to the area constituency committees and the fact that the Conservatives don’t control the one for Harrogate and Knaresborough won’t stop that.”
Cllr Harrison added that he expects Harrogate Borough Council’s offices at Knapping Mount to continue to play a key operational role when staff transfer to North Yorkshire Council next year because “it’s a modern fit-for-purpose flexible office space”.
The Conservatives were returned to power in North Yorkshire with a greatly reduced majority of four on May 5.
Andrew Williams, an Independent who was elected in Ripon Minster and Moorside, said the more even political composition since the May 5 elections meant the views of opposition parties would be heard more, whereas in the past the previous huge Tory majority meant many issues were just waived through. He said:
“If you go about things in a constructive and positive manner it’s possible to get things done.”
Harrogate town council
Cllr Williams, who is also the leader of Ripon City Council, said the best way to ensure Harrogate’s voice was heard would be through the creation of a Harrogate town council.
He said Ripon City Council had effectively provided a voice for the city and suggested the same could happen in Harrogate.
He added that such a move would pave the way for more independents.
“People will be looking for voices on a town council that stand up for Harrogate and will appreciate a less partisan approach.”
Five Harrogate Independents failed to come close to winning a division on May 5. But Cllr Williams suggested they got their tactics wrong:
“They started campaigning too late. You can’t just rock up at election time and win.
“To win an election as an Independent you have got to be known by a lot of people and campaign early.”
A referendum could take place in Harrogate to see if people want to create a town council.
But Cllr Harrison said people ought to know what the purpose of a Harrogate town council would be and what the added charge to their council tax precept would be before any vote takes place.
Whatever one’s political persuasion, the political scene has been enlivened by the shake-up to local government.
But whether local voices are heard strongly at County Hall, the 1906 Grade II listed building where the county council is based, remains to be seen.
The Stray Ferret asked the Liberal Democrats in Harrogate and Knaresborough to comment for this article but did not receive a response by our deadline.
Pinewoods gunfire: ‘Children were playing – people were terrified’A woman who heard three gunshots in the Pinewoods last night has said people were terrified when the reality of what was happening dawned on them.
The female, who lives in the Plantation area on Harlow Hill and asked not to be named, said children were playing in the woods as normal at about 5pm.
She said the three shots were fired over the space of about 15 minutes, adding:
“The first shot shook us up. The second time it happened I came out of the house and went into the woods.
“There were children playing in the woods, as usual. Parents had gathered to collect them. They were absolutely terrified.
“There was a longer gap between the second and third shots and when it came it sounded very close. My partner speculated that somebody might have been shooting at us.”
Read more:
- Armed police close off Pinewoods after suspected gunfire
- Police silent over gunfire in Harrogate’s Pinewoods
North Yorkshire Police has not commented on the incident and the witness, who said she saw an officer carrying. a taser gun, said residents would have appreciated some news that the area was safe. She said:
“It’s not reassuring at all.”
The witness also said the gunshots were categorically not related to a training exercise at the nearby Army Foundation College, as many people have suggested on social media.
Police silent over gunfire in Harrogate’s Pinewoods“We are a close community and we know what we heard. These three shots came from the Pinewoods.”
North Yorkshire Police has so far remained silent over gunfire heard at the Pinewoods yesterday.
Armed officers closed off the area after residents reported hearing “very loud” bangs at about 5pm.
A police helicopter circled the 96-acre woodland, which is located a kilometre south of Harrogate town centre, for some time afterwards.
The Stray Ferret contacted the police for information last night, but 15 hours after the incident, no information has been released.
Officers at the Pinewoods entrance on Plantation Road said only that a ‘containment exercise’ was being carried out. Armed police were stood down in the area after at about 7.15pm.
We spoke to several residents in the area who reported hearing gunfire. Many said they heard three shots and then noticed armed police and a helicopter brought in. There were also reports of a taser being brought to the scene.
One woman said she’d heard three gun shots but didn’t think such things happened in Harrogate so she assumed it was a car backfiring and went swimming.
Another person said a residents’ what’s app group had been going crazy with people wanting to know what was going on, as the Pinewoods is a popular local beauty spot.
But so far the police have remained silent and it is not known if anyone was hurt or if any arrests have been made.
Read more:
- Harrogate district people asked for views on police 101 and 999 calls
- Armed police close off Pinewoods after suspected gunfire
Armed police close off Pinewoods after suspected gunfire
Police have closed off the Pinewoods after suspected gunfire was heard this evening.
Someone in the area told the Stray Ferret they heard three “very loud” bangs, which they presumed to be gunshots, at around 5pm.
They said a police helicopter has been circling the woodland since then.
The Stray Ferret spoke to one police officer who said armed police had “contained” the area but did not give any further information. It is not known if anyone has been hurt.
We will have more information on this developing story as we get it.