A community psychiatric nurse who was based in Harrogate has been struck off after facing a series of charges of misconduct.

Gordon Eric Finlay was found to have failed to keep accurate records for patients in his care, or to maintain professional boundaries, when he worked for the Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust, covering the Harrogate area in 2017.

He was also found to have acted inappropriately with colleagues, including sexually inappropriate behaviour, when working for Bradford District Care NHS Foundation Trust in 2019.

In a nine-day hearing last month, the Nursing and Midwifery Council heard evidence from multiple witnesses in relation to 19 charges. A report from the hearing said:

“It came to light that that Mr Finlay had communicated with a vulnerable mental health patient (Patient A) by telephone and a number of text messages which contained inappropriate content after the patient ceased to be under his care.

“Further regulatory concerns identified from this referral relate to a failure to preserve patient safety, in that Mr Finlay failed to escalate Patient A’s care when Patient A had disclosed a decline in mood and increased thoughts of suicide in a number of text messages to Mr Finlay. Patient A committed suicide during this period of communication.”

The three-person panel also heard he had signed off text messages to Patient A with “Gx”. The report said she had “severe and enduring” mental health problems, “particularly in relation to building trust and maintaining relationships”, and was “particularly vulnerable to any blurred… lines of professional communication”.

Mr Finlay, who was not present or represented at the hearing, was found to have failed to share Patient A’s deteriorating mental health with colleagues not through a genuine mistake, but in order to protect his job.

Relating to other charges of failing to keep accurate records for his patients in both Harrogate and Bradford, the report said:

“The panel considered the written representations of Mr Finlay, in particular, his admission that he was unfamiliar and not comfortable with the electronic diary and therefore recorded appointments in his paper diary.

“The panel was of the view that Mr Finlay would have had sufficient time to learn and use the electronic diary system over the approximate four-month period that was affected and he should have escalated any concerns or issues that he believed were preventing him from completing his patient records as required.”

The NMC panel also heard Mr Finlay’s line manager had offered him additional support with his record-keeping, but this had not been taken up.

Read more:

• M&S employee in Harrogate unfairly dismissed after face mask confrontation
• Ex-Ripon Grammar School matron loses unfair dismissal claim

Mr Finlay was also accused of hugging and kissing a colleague on the cheek, as well as touching another colleague’s bottom, and making sexual comments in his workplace as well as showing an inappropriate video to colleagues.

In a written response to the charge of the hug and kiss, he said:

“It felt like a normal thing to do around someone’s birthday and I didn’t give it much thought, it was innocent and I would stress this hopefully reinforced by the CCTV footage that it was non-sexual and did not appear to create a reaction.”

The panel found the kiss and the hug was not sexual in nature, but that touching the other colleague’s bottom was.

It also found the latter – against a colleague described as “a junior colleague and a young and inexperienced person in the workplace” – amounted to bullying and harassment. The other sexual behaviours were found not to be bullying.

‘Undermine public confidence’

Addressing all charges, the panel found Mr Finlay’s conduct had fallen “seriously short” of the standards expected of a nurse and amounted to misconduct. Its report said:

“In considering whether the conduct has been remediated, the panel acknowledged that Mr Finlay cooperated in the local investigation and made admissions to some of the charges.

“He has also engaged with the NMC process and provided detailed written information by way of reflection and further information, although he did not attend the hearing.

“The panel acknowledged Mr Finlay had developed a health issue over the course of these events relating to depression and anxiety. The panel also acknowledged that both Mr Finlay and the rest of the mental health team in the area were under considerable work pressure.”

The report said there were 315 patient contacts which had not been recorded by Mr Finlay and that he had shown “no insight into the impact of his failures… on wider patient care or upon his colleagues”.

It said Mr Finlay’s written submissions had shown he felt he was “prioritising patient care”. However, the panel said having had the matter addressed by one NHS trust, he still failed to keep accurate records when he moved to a new trust.

The report concluded:

“Mr Finlay’s actions were significant departures from the standards expected of a registered nurse, and are fundamentally incompatible with him remaining on the register.

“The panel was of the view that the findings in this particular case demonstrate that Mr Finlay’s actions were serious and to allow him to continue practising would undermine public confidence in the profession and in the NMC as a regulatory body.”

As a result of the panel’s findings, Mr Finlay was struck off the nursing register.

A 17-year-old male has admitted robbing a male on the Stray and possessing a zombie knife in Harrogate.

The teenager, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was charged with stealing a mobile phone, cash and credit cards during the robbery.

It took place on the Stray at Knaresborough Road on July 23.

He also admitted possessing a zombie knife the following day on The Ginnel in Harrogate.

The youth denied assaulting a police officer on The Ginnel on July 24 and the charge was dismissed. But he admitted resisting arrest by the same officer that day.

Read more:

• Amazon driver killed Ripon motorcyclist while he sent Snapchat message, court hears
• Girls aged 13 and 14 admit setting fire to bins in Harrogate

The teenager, from Sheffield, was remanded into the care of the local authority until August 19, when he is due to appear in front of Harrogate magistrates again.

He was given a doorstep curfew between 7pm and 7am, told to attend three appointments a week with the Youth Justice Service and not to enter Harrogate before the court appearance.

A council report has warned Harrogate Convention Centre will suffer huge losses of £250 million unless a major redevelopment is carried out.

The ageing centre is facing a pivotal moment in its 40-year history as it presses ahead with renovation plans while competition from new conference venues – including one planned for Leeds – ramps up.

Harrogate Borough Council owns the venue and has proposed an investment project which could cost £49 million in what would mark the single biggest spend by the authority in its lifetime.

Without this, the council has warned the centre will “fall behind in the market” and “may fail to survive”.

£250 million losses

A report to a meeting of the council’s cabinet next week said the venue could be hit by £250 million losses over the next 40 years which would have to be subsidised by taxpayers.

The warning comes as the clock is ticking until the centre is handed over to the new North Yorkshire Council next April and as questions mount over how the redevelopment could be funded after cash was not included in a devolution deal for the county.

Harrogate Borough Council has also bid for convention centre cash from the government’s Levelling Up Fund.

However, the maximum amount available per project is £20 million and Harrogate is ranked as a low priority area.

The report to next Wednesday’s meeting said: 

“The redevelopment of the Harrogate Convention Centre (HCC) site offers the only opportunity to modernise facilities, improve connectivity within and replace failing mechanical and electrical systems – and to turn around the financial performance.

“HCC plays an important role in the district’s and region’s economy, attracting visitors and significant spend each year.

“It is the only event venue in the Yorkshire and Humber region that is able to compete with major facilities in cities elsewhere, such as Liverpool, Manchester, Gateshead and Glasgow.”

Read more:

• Harrogate Convention Centre redevelopment to seek levelling up cash
• Council leader ‘shares disappointment’ over lack of HCC funding in devolution deal
• Harrogate Convention Centre to face competition from Leeds events venue

The new events venue planned for the former Yorkshire Bank HQ in Leeds highlights a growing conference industry which is seeing more venues compete for big events that local economies benefit hugely from.

Council officials have estimated that Harrogate Convention Centre attracts over 150,000 visitors a year, with an economic impact of more than £35 million.

But the venue’s own financial performance has been poor over the last decade when its annual revenue has decreased by an average of 3% per year.

That is according to the new report which described the centre as “underutilised” and said increasing competition and operating costs have resulted in a need to “rethink” its offer.

Redevelopment plan

The redevelopment plans include a major refurbishment of event areas and upgrades to the venue’s heating and ventilation systems.

There are also plans to create a flexible events space for up to 1,200 people. These works were due to start in October after a warning that the centre could miss out on several big events next year, however, the plans have now been delayed.

The next stages of the redevelopment will see a £3.3 million contract awarded for further design, price and programming works.

More than £1.5 million has already been spent on the project before a final decision has been made. This is scheduled for July or August next year – meaning it will be the new North Yorkshire Council which will decide whether to proceed.

If approved, construction on a first phase of works would start in September 2023 for just over a year.

Harrogate Borough Council estimates the upgrades would increase the centre’s visitor numbers from 147,000 in 2020 to 192,000 in 2040, with profits of £29 million over a 40-year period.

The report added: 

“Investment in HCC will attract business visitors, support significant employment, encourage conversion of business to repeat leisure visitors and support inward investment.

“The redevelopment has the potential to provide a significant place-shaping, cultural and economic boost to the region.”

Harrogate District Hospital has started issuing yellow socks to victims of falls.

The scheme, which has been introduced by other hospitals, allows staff and visitors to identify patients who require extra assistance with their mobility.

Under the scheme, if a Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust patient is admitted having previously fallen, they will be automatically given a pair of non-slip yellow socks.

Katie Butterworth, falls specialist and corporate nurse at the trust, said:

“The bright colour of the socks let both staff and visitors know that a patient who is wearing them may need assistance when walking and could be a potential fall risk.

“We would like all staff to see (yellow socks), think (extra assistance) and then act (review falls risk assessment).”

Read more:

• ‘Huge’ increase in demand for Harrogate council homeless services
• Harrogate Convention Centre ‘could lose £250 million without investment‘

Harrogate Borough Council has revealed a “huge” increase in demand for its homeless services due to the cost of living crisis which is only set to get worse as inflation rises.

A 60% jump in people seeking help has been reported by the council which also said it is struggling to recruit staff in line with national shortages.

It added cases which its staff deal with are “more complex than normal” and that finding suitable accommodation for those facing homelessness “isn’t always easy due to complicating factors like mental health or debts”.

A council report said:

“Following a huge increase in the number of families approaching the service, the homelessness indicators performance have worsened.

“Our homelessness performance indicators, though off target, unfortunately reflect broader national trends around homelessness.

“Housing teams across the country have been dealing with higher case loads.

“In Harrogate, cases are about 60% higher than previous years.”

Read more:

• Harrogate Convention Centre to face competition from Leeds events venue
• Council leader ‘shares disappointment’ over lack of HCC funding in devolution deal

The increase comes amid big rises in the cost of living with soaring prices, especially energy, putting a squeeze on people’s finances.

Energy bills are expected to rise even further later this year when a typical household will be spending almost £300 a month. That is according to the Bank of England which also predicts the UK economy will fall into a recession, with inflation climbing as high as 13%.

Harrogate Borough Council itself has not been immune to the price rises and is forecasting a £701,000 overspend on this year’s budget.

This time last year, the forecast was an underspend of £32,000 for 2022/23.

The latest outlook is largely due to soaring energy bills, with the council expecting to spend around an extra £1 million on gas and £750,000 on electricity this year.

A report said: 

“The council’s latest financial position shows that we are forecasting an overspend of £701,000.

“It is, however, early in the year and there will inevitably be other variations during the course of the year.

“We have yet to receive any actual bills for this year and the national position with regard to future price increases remains highly volatile.”

A former Harrogate headteacher has been found guilty of making indecent images of children.

Matthew Shillito, 42, pleaded not guilty to making 20 Category B images and 3,829 Category C images between December 3, 2012 and December 31, 2015.

Shillito was appointed headteacher of Western Primary School in 2019.

He was previously headteacher across the Goldsborough Sicklinghall Federation of schools.

None of the offences related to his employment.

Shillito appeared before York Magistrates Court this morning, where District Judge Adrian Lower found him guilty on both charges.

He said the evidence showed Shillito had a “corrosive, addictive interest in child pornography”.

Read more:

• Former Harrogate headteacher ‘repeatedly accessed’ website with indecent images, court hears
• Ex-Harrogate headteacher denies making indecent images of children

During the case, “making” was defined as knowingly accessing a site that contained an indecent image.

The court was told that there was no evidence that Mr Shillito downloaded the material onto his laptop.

The prosecution opened proceedings at Harrogate Magistrates Court last month and said the indecent images were found on the cache in Shillito’s computer, which could have only have got there had he accessed sites with those images.

Philip Morris, prosecuting, said there were “indicative” terms found on Shillito’s laptop which showed intent to access the images.

Police arrested Shillito and seized two computers at his address on January 4, 2020.

Officers recovered a Dell laptop and a MacBook Pro, which contained a back up from an iPad mini which was not found.

Giving evidence to the court last month, Zoe Warboys, a digital forensic investigation officer at North Yorkshire Police, said that while the defendant may not have been aware of the cache, he could have only got them by accessing the material.

A Russian website named in court was frequently accessed on the Dell laptop, which Ms Warboys told the court was a site which contained indecent images of children.

The site is public and allows users to upload albums of images which others can view.

The court heard how the site was frequently visited on February 26, 2011.

Mr Morris told the court that Shillito visited some of the pages which were “indicative” of possibly including indecent images 30 times.

Shillito repeatedly denied both charges throughout the case.

This morning, District Judge Lower adjourned sentencing Shillito until September 7. He bailed Shillito but warned him all sentencing options would be considered including jail. 

More to follow.

There are just a few days left for people to comment on controversial plans to cut the number of night-time fire engines in Harrogate to just one.

This Sunday is the final day of a three-month consultation on the proposals from the North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service.

The county’s Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe is running an online survey on the plans which she said would “continue to provide an immediate emergency response” during the night when emergencies are less likely to occur.

She has also insisted the proposals are not cost-cutting measures as the fire service already has a balanced budget.

Yet union officials and councillors have raised concerns over the plans which have been described as “seriously concerning” and “putting money before lives”.

Read more:

• Fire Brigades Union ‘seriously concerned’ over cuts to Harrogate service
• Harrogate firefighter brands plans to rely on one fire engine ‘farcical’
• Harrogate fire station changes won’t increase risk to life, says commissioner

Steve Howley, secretary at the North Yorkshire Fire Brigades Union, said the proposed move would leave the area with a “second-rate emergency response service that will put lives at risk” as he also urged commissioner Metcalfe to fight for more funding from the government.

The proposals are included in the fire service’s new risk and resource model which sets out how it will deploy staff and equipment over the next three years.

There are similar proposals for fire stations in Scarborough and Huntington which commissioner Metcalfe said along with the Harrogate plans would save over £1.5 million a year to allow for investment in fire prevention.

She added the proposals are based on an “extensive risk assessment” which has identified the likelihood of fires, road traffic collisions and other emergencies.

Commissioner Metcalfe said: 

“The assessment shows that in our area, the risk of having a fire in your home is generally low, with pockets of higher risk in some of our urban areas and also in the south-east of the service area.

“In fact, other emergencies, such as collisions on our roads or rescues from water during storms and floods, make up a larger proportion of what our service responds to.

“Based on this evidence, your fire and rescue service has put forward proposals that it feels will ensure it has the right people with the right equipment in the right place at the right time to reduce the risk of harm in our communities.

“Before I make my decision on whether to implement them, I want to know what you, the people of North Yorkshire and York, think of them.”

To have your say go to www.TellCommissionerZoe.co.uk.

Harrogate’s Rachel Daly has signed for Aston Villa on a three year deal for an undisclosed fee.

The 30-year-old England international has joined the club from Houston Dash, where she spent six years and made 101 appearances in the National Women’s Soccer League.

Daly joins Villa off the back of a historic Euro 2022, where the Lionesses won the tournament after defeating Germany 2-1 at Wembley.

On joining the club, she said:

“It was a big decision, I’ve been away from home now for 10 years and for me family is the most important thing.

“I had a tough year with family and being away from them, so it was a big decision to come home.

“I spoke to a few clubs along the journey and it felt right to sign for Villa. The journey that the club is on is one I want to be a part of.”

Read more:

• Harrogate’s Rachel Daly given hero’s welcome at Elland Road

• Rachel Daly continues to support Killinghall team, coach reveals

• Former school leads messages to Harrogate’s football champion Rachel Daly

Villa will embark on their third season in the Women’s Super League after finishing 10th and ninth in their last two campaigns since promotion.

Manager Carla Ward said:

“This is a big signing for us and one we’ve worked hard on completing. Rachel is a top forward and a proven goalscorer.

“Having performed admirably at full-back this summer, she showed us that she is a player you simply need in your team.

“But for us, she is a forward and we can’t wait to see her scoring goals.”

#NewProfilePic pic.twitter.com/WQwRrYJ7Yw

— Rachel Daly (@RachelDaly3) August 9, 2022

An online event on Harrogate’s Station Gateway project will be held today after officials signalled their determination to push ahead with the scheme despite a legal threat.

It will be held at 6pm after drop-in sessions took place at the Victoria Shopping Centre last week.

The events are part of a third consultation on the £10.9 million project which aims to make the town centre more accessible with cycle lanes and pedestrianisation.

However, the plans have failed to win over the support of some residents and businesses who are worried the changes could cause more congestion and drive shoppers away.

These concerns came to a head when one of Harrogate’s leading property companies made a proposed claim for a judicial review against North Yorkshire County Council which is leading on the project and delayed the submission of a final business case to secure funding.

Hornbeam Park Developments claims a previous consultation was “unlawful” and that the county council “failed conscientiously” to take into account the feedback.

Yet the authority said it “does not accept” the claims and now aims to submit the final business case at the beginning of next year.

Read more:

• Beech Grove road closure in Harrogate to end in 10 days
• Beech Grove decision leaves Harrogate in slow lane for cycling

Cllr Keane Duncan, executive member for highways, said the county council wanted to “crack on” with next stages of the project as he also urged people to share their views on the latest designs.

He said: 

“The county council is keen to hear views on ambitious plans to help make Harrogate town centre more accessible to residents and visitors.

“As part of the latest consultation we will be sharing updated designs and seeking views on key elements of the Gateway project, particularly around traffic and transport.

“Your responses will be vital to ensuring we deliver the very best scheme for residents and businesses.”

An online survey is also being run as part of the latest consultation which will close on 23 August.

The county council has stressed that the survey is not revisiting the principle of key parts of the project – including reducing Station Parade to one-lane traffic and a part-time pedestrianisation of James Street – but instead is gathering views on final designs and traffic impacts.

After the consultation ends, the authority aims to start construction early next year with completion in winter 2023/24.

There are, however, questions over how possible court proceedings could impact deadlines for the project which is being funded by the government’s Transforming Cities Fund.

A Department for Transport spokesman said it expects the project to be delivered by an already extended deadline of March 2024 and that where there are any further delays, deadlines will be “reassessed by a panel on a case-by-case basis”.

But when asked what a possible judicial review could mean for the scheme, the spokesman added “we can’t comment on the specific funding arrangements… as this information is commercially sensitive”.

Also included in the Gateway plans are upgrades for Station Square and the One Arch underpass, as well the Odeon cinema roundabout and several other streets in the area.

More details of the proposals are available online where you can also have your say and find out more about today’s online event.

Go to www.yourvoice.westyorks-ca.gov.uk/harrogate.

Business Breakfast is sponsored by Harrogate law firm Truth Legal. 

A Harrogate man has launched a new app in Leeds which aims to reduce health inequalities.

The Caterpillar app aims to encourage people to take small steps to improve their’ lifestyles, such as increasing daily steps or making healthy changes to dietary habits.

The app was founded by Paul Baverstock, who lives in Harrogate, and has been hailed by Leeds City Council chief executive Tom Riordan as a “gamechanger”.

It is also backed by two-time Olympic gold medallist and public health advocate, Alistair Brownlee.

Mr Baverstock said:

“We’re using Nobel Prize-winning behavioural science techniques to help people create healthy habits that stick. 

“This isn’t for those who set extreme fitness challenges or track every calorie, it’s for those who might struggle to engage with and make small and important changes in their lives.”

Caterpillar connects to health apps, such as Google Fit and Apple Health, and sets personalised physical activity goals. 

It uses the latest expert information to help people make choices about their dietary habits.

Caterpillar is based at Leeds University and was incubated by the Leeds City Council’s BUILD programme in 2021.

Business groups hold first social

Business members at Harrogate District Chamber of Commerce and Harrogate BID social.

Harrogate businesses leaders met up for the first Harrogate District Chamber of Commerce and Harrogate BID summer drinks event on Monday night.

Representatives from firms from across the district attended 63rd+1st cocktail bar on Albert Street for the get-together.

It gave business leaders the chance to network with other members.