North Yorkshire County Council’s transport boss has issued the stark warning that the county’s bus network is “facing a really grave situation”.
Councillor Keane Duncan, executive member for highways and transportation, made his remarks after a meeting where members representing communities across North Yorkshire heard many commerically-run services were in peril or being downgraded.
Seven months ago the government rejected North Yorkshire County Council’s bid for a £116m share of Boris Johnson’s high-profile Bus Back Better initiative, saying the local authority’s plans lacked ambition.
The council has been trialling Yorbus, a demand-responsive transport scheme around Ripon and Masham in the hope of finding a sustainable public transport solution for rural areas. It is yet to announce any alternative public transport proposals to its rejected plans.
A meeting of the authority heard opposition members highlight the importance of public transport as a means of cutting carbon emissions and question the authority’s intentions over investing in the area.
Read More:
- ‘Use it or lose it’ warning as bus passenger numbers fall across Harrogate district
- YorBus: On-demand service’s running costs are twice as much as regular buses
Liberal Democrat councillor for Pateley Bridge, Andrew Murday, said residents of his division faced having just two services a day to Harrogate.
He said:
“We just have to do something about bus services, and encourage more people onto buses. We need to know how we are going to go about discouraging people from driving and encouraging people on to buses, so bus services can thrive.”
The meeting heard a call from Scarborough Labour councillor Tony Randerson for a “nationalised bus service”.
Cllr Duncan responded saying bus services in the county were facing unprecedented pressure due to higher costs and passenger numbers had fallen to just 80 per cent of pre-covid levels.
He said:
“For many of the routes that represents the difference between profitability and not profitable services.
“It is important to point out that the bus network is North Yorkshire is facing a really grave situation. I think unprecedented pressure as a result of reduced passenger numbers, as a result of higher costs.”
He added: “The message across the county is use it or lose it. We need people to support these services.”
He said the authority subsidised routes to the tune of £1.6m annually, but the situation in the county would “outstrip that many times over”, adding:
“That subsidy is not at a level that which we would be able to support those 79 routes, so it is a very grave situation.”
He added:
Harrogate Christmas Fair: The perfect place to find unique festive gifts“Creating a nationalised service would not solve those fundamental issues if those operators are not there to deliver those services.”
“There may be is more that we could do to become more interventionist in terms of the bus network, but at the moment the backbone of the county’s bus service is the commercial operators.”
This story is sponsored by the Country Living Harrogate Christmas Fair.
Many of us are already in full swing with our Christmas shopping and the challenge is well and truly on to find those extra special gifts.
The Country Living Harrogate Christmas Fair, which returns for its tenth year next week, is the perfect place to find that special something.
The four-day event, on December 1-4, will feature more than 200 small UK independent producers, crafters, and artisan retailers under one roof at the Convention Centre.
There will be a host of unique gifts that can’t be found on the high street.
From handcrafted products, stylish decors, soft furnishings to gourmet cheese, Christmas puddings, sweet and savoury treats, tasty tipples and fine wines, visitors can shop to their hearts’ content while soaking in the festive vibes with live music throughout the day from the Fair’s brass band and choirs.

Fiona Fawcett, from Yorkshire brand Plewsy.
Shoppers can opt for a special VIP experience, including bottomless prosecco and gift bags worth more than £100.
Over the four-days, around 15,000 people are expected to attend the Harrogate Convention Centre.
Dan Sewell, the event director for Country Living’s Christmas Fair, said:
“It shows there’s a really strong appetite for this special tenth anniversary year, with so many new exhibitors bringing fresh, exciting ideas alongside the traditional, festive favourites who return year-on-year.”
The Christmas Fair will be a foodie’s delight
The Country Living Kitchen Theatre will see some of the country’s finest food and drink producers and culinary experts whip up their ultimate festive recipes and seasonal showstoppers.
Demonstrations offer the chance to ask for tips, interact with the experts, and even try a taster or two.
Stephanie Moon will deliver a workshop on ‘Christmas Canapes to Impress with Rudding Park’. Harrogate’s Three’s A Crowd will also be on hand with ‘A Christmas Tipple’, with some unique festive cocktails.
The artisan foodie brand Charlie & Ivy’s will also be on hand to demonstrate how to create simple party food for the festive season.
Visitors can expect tailored chocolate tasting sessions, as well as hands-on workshops from crafting experts where they can create needle felted baubles to unique Christmas table decorations to take home.

Christmas canapes by Charlie and Ivy’s.
Country Living’s Harrogate Christmas Fair promises gifts you can’t find on the high street, while supporting and championing the country’s independent businesses.
Shoppers can also enjoy a Champagne Bar, cocktails or an Afternoon Tea dining experience.
The Stray Ferret is working with Country Living to giveaway two VIP tickets worth £150 and to offer our readers a special two for one ticket offer.
Country Living Christmas Fair will take place on December 1-4, 2022.
Join the mailing list here to be the first to know about Country Living’s Events.
Charity pays for two cancer nurses at Harrogate hospitalA charity has funded two cancer nurses at Harrogate District Hospital in response to fears not enough people can access specialist cancer care.
Macmillan Cancer Support announced today it had spent £214,000 on the two-year posts as part of a £4.5 million investment across Yorkshire and the north-east of England.
The funding will pay for 42 specialist cancer nurses in northern England, of whom two will be employed by Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust.
The development roles will see nurses with an interest in moving into cancer services step into specialist cancer roles.
Noreen Hawkshaw, the Macmillan lead cancer nurse at Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust, said:
“We’re facing incredibly challenging workforce issues at the moment and I know Harrogate is not unique with this.
“Undoubtedly the Macmillan investment into the two development roles will ease the pressure on the specialist cancer care we are able to provide for patients by creating more capacity.
Ms Hawkshaw added the investment would “allow nurses the time and space to develop into these specialist cancer nurse roles”, adding:
“We urgently need more of them to meet the rising demand on our services.”
Read more:
- Harrogate hospital well below urgent cancer referral target
- Cancer patients take to catwalk in Harrogate fundraiser
Macmillan said in a statement too many people in the north of England cannot access specialist cancer care and there are too few Macmillan cancer nurse specialists employed across the region.
It said a “crisis in cancer nursing” had left 630,000 people with cancer in the UK with a lack of dedicated support.
2,500 cancer nurses needed
The charity estimates an extra 2,500 specialist cancer nurses are required now.
Heather McLean, Macmillan’s head of partnerships for the north, said:
“Macmillan cancer nurse specialists are the people at the heart of cancer care, this unique role makes a huge difference to people diagnosed with cancer and their families at a very distressing time in their lives.
“There are currently a huge number of specialist cancer nurse vacancies across Yorkshire because it’s increasingly difficult to get people with the right knowledge and skills, who are ready to step into those specialist nursing posts.”
Rachel Moser, the interim programme manager with the West Yorkshire and Harrogate Cancer Alliance, which is hosting the programme in partnership with Macmillan, on behalf of the four cancer alliances across the north-east and Yorkshire region, said:
“Patients tell us how much they value cancer nurse specialists and the care and support they provide.
“I’m delighted to be leading this programme on behalf of the regional cancer alliances which will help us ensure we have a ready supply of skilled individuals for these crucial roles into the future.”
Calls for council to go ‘further and faster’ on climate change in North Yorkshire
North Yorkshire County Council has faced pressure from opposition councillors to reconsider how its environmental actions are managed before postponing a decision on whether fracking is appropriate in the area.
A full meeting of the authority saw a North Yorkshire Climate Coalition, which includes 18 environmental groups, calling on the authority to move “further and faster” over environmental issues, and drop party politics to introduce measures more rapidly.
The coalition pressed the council – which declared a climate emergency in the summer – to address the twin climate and ecological emergencies and to harness “huge economic opportunities” during a transition to a cleaner, greener economy.
The meeting was told that the authority’s leader, Councillor Carl Les, had this week called for people to support the Yorkshire and Humber Climate Change Commission move to declare an ecological emergency, before his Conservative group voted to stop the creation of a biodiversity crisis working group at the council.
Councillor Greg White, executive member for climate change and customer engagement, said the authority did not want to be judged on what it said, but rather its actions, and that its plan for cutting carbon was “bold”.
Coun White added while the council was working to introduce carbon-cutting measures it also needed to focus on its main purpose, which was to provide much-needed services.
Nevertheless, opposition councillors insisted more action and a greater focus was needed.
Read more:
- Call for council to oppose fracking in North Yorkshire
- Harrogate and Knaresborough MP denies voting in favour of fracking
The administration then faced numerous questions from opposition members over its environmental actions, ranging from public transport to buying zero carbon electricity, and from installing air source heat pumps to offloading pension fund investments in fossil fuels.
Conservative members said the authority put environmental considerations at the heart of its existing system, which was be best placed to guide the council over cutting carbon and accused opposition members of “grandstanding”.
The meeting also saw opposition councillors prevented from debating proposals to brand fracking in a county which has declared a climate emergency as inappropriate, so the authority’s executive could consider them first and report its conclusions at the next full council meeting in February.
Labour, Liberal Democrat, Independent and Green group leaders lined up to back proposals designed to create greater oversight of the authority’s climate change actions, with some claiming the Conservatives were “resisting transparency”.
Green group leader Councillor Andy Brown accused the administration of “downplaying the order of the problem” and said they needed to develop “a clear, costed action plan”.
He said:
“We have had floods destroying a bridge at Tadcaster, we’ve had Richmondshire experiencing floods, we’ve had more fires every summer virtually, we got close to 40 degrees in the summer in Yorkshire, we’ve had 20 degrees in February and in November in North Yorkshire. We are on track for the warmest year ever.”
Ahead of Conservative councillors voting down two climate change proposals, they highlighted that while funding was the biggest determinant of potential climate change action, from April the county’s new unitary authority was facing a black hole of up to £70m.
A young Harrogate politician has spoken for his constituents in the House of Commons on the need for better mental health support.
Fourteen-year-old Brando Halloum is the Member of Youth Parliament for Harrogate and Craven.
Now a Year 10 student at Harrogate Grammar School, he moved to the UK in Year 5 having previously attended school in the United Arab Emirates.
He was one of more than 200 MYPs aged 11-18 who attended the meeting on November 4 in the House of Commons, the first of its kind since 2019.
Speaking of the experience, Brando said:
“To be elected as MYP and have the chance to represent my constituents in Westminster was a surreal experience – debating issues that matter most to my generation at the heart of our democracy, Parliament.
“It is now for decision makers, local and national, to ensure action is taken to address these issues. Ensuring no decision about my generation is made without us and that we remain at the heart of these integral conversations.”
Brando was invited to speak by the speaker of the house, Sir Lindsay Hoyle. He spoke of the need for improved mental health services across the UK for young people, telling the house of the racial abuse he had received and the lack of support he was given afterwards.
In the House of Commons, he said:
“I was unfortunately the victim of racial and Islamophobic abuse… When I reported this experience, people doubted me and I was given a plaster response, just put a quick band aid over the problem. It didn’t help.
“I spent months waiting for counselling which never came. I am calling for young people to be given adequate treatment and adequate response to racism and all forms of discrimination across this country and give mental health support to those who need it.”
Read more:
- Uncertainty over Harrogate district investment zones after government ‘refocuses’ scheme
- Businesses across Harrogate district to face ‘tough winter’ after autumn statement
Brando was elected by more than 9,000 young people to be the MYP of Harrogate and Craven this March, voted on through the Make Your Mark initiative for young people. Members of Youth Parliament are elected every two years.
He regularly campaigns with his fellow MYPs throughout the country to represent his constituent’s voice and debate issues and policies.
The primary campaign issue for Members of Youth Parliament this year is the cost of living crisis.
He said:
“The cost of living crisis is at the fore of my generation’s minds, and I am concerned about the clear and disproportionate impact this is having on my constituents’ mental health and wellbeing.”
Brando is also a member of the North Yorkshire Youth Council, in addition to being an RAF cadet.
The full morning session in which Brando spoke is below. He began speaking around 37 minutes into the session.
Time to sparkle: Your guide to Christmas lights switch-ons across the districtDuring the current climate, we all need a bit of sparkle in our lives.
And what better way to inject some festive cheer than switching on the Christmas lights.
Here are the dates for your diary for switch-on events across the district:
Harrogate – Thursday, November 17
The countdown to Christmas in Harrogate will officially get underway this evening, with Harrogate BID flicking the festive switch.
There will be no official switch-on event this year, however Christmas lights around the town centre will start to dazzle for the first time this evening.
The whole town will be illuminated by the weekend.
Ripon – Saturday, November 19
Ripon’s festive season gets into full swing this weekend, with the switch-on of the city’s Christmas lights on Saturday.
The city’s Market Square will be a hive of activity from 1pm, ahead of the lights switch-on, which takes place at 5pm.
The reindeer, which proved popular when they visited Ripon for last year’s event, will be returning with Santa and once again there will be free fairground rides and a climbing wall for children to enjoy.
The Ripon City Council event will also provide free musical entertainment from 2pm.
Knaresborough – Friday, November 25
Boroughbridge – Wednesday, December 7

Santa’s sleigh out and about in Boroughbridge in 2018.
The annual late night Christmas Shopping and lights switch-on event, organised by the town’s Chamber of Trade, will take place on Wednesday, December 7.
The event kicks-off with the official switch-on of the Christmas tree lights in Hall Square at 5.30pm, followed by short performances by school choirs.
Boroughbridge Lions will have Santa and his sleigh on display and there will be children’s rides, along with the Scouts’ roast chestnuts and Brighter Boroughbridge with a mulled wine and mince pies stall. There will also be a hog roast.
The shop window display competition theme this year is “A Christmas Panto”.
The lights on the Christmas tree will be switched on by BBC Radio York’s Georgey Spanswick and the Mayor, Sean Hynes.
Businesses across Harrogate district to face ‘tough winter’ after autumn statementLocal organisations are in unison with their reaction to the autumn statement, warning there will be a ‘tough winter’ ahead of us.
Small businesses are expected to struggle as result of this morning’s autumn statement, with consumers predicted to cut disposable spending.
Harrogate District Chamber of Commerce chief executive David Simister said the statement was “exactly as previewed”:
“Whilst it will no doubt have reassured the markets, there seems very little to support businesses when they need it most.
“The cost of running business will continue to rise and these increases will have to be passed on to the customers, who in turn are worse off with soaring inflation and eye watering energy prices…
“I’m afraid to say many businesses are looking at a very bleak future.”
David Simister
Harrogate BID chair Sara Ferguson echoed the chamber’s projection:
“There was little in today’s autumn statement to boost our high street economy… Everyone is going to have less disposal income, this will mean consumers pairing back on their spending, which will shrink the economy further.”
Mr Simister and Ms Ferguson also agreed that the £13.6 billion business rates relief package would help soften the blow of April’s expected rise.
Sara Ferguson
Read more:
- Government grants needed to help finances, says county council leader
- ‘It’s still too high’ – Harrogate residents on the government’s energy announcement
Ripon BID welcomed some elements of the statement, such as the increase to pensions and benefits in line with September’s inflation rate as well as the early news of the rising national living wage for over-23s.
In a statement, the organisation said:
“The UK falling into recession was expected and Ripon BID hopes that the chancellor’s measures to reduce inflation will be in his words ‘as short and shallow as possible’, however we would welcome any help available to businesses from the government and urge them to come up with non-inflationary measures which would aid them.
“Now more than ever it is important that we try and support our local businesses by shopping locally and giving support to our Ripon city region independents.
“Ripon BID is here to help BID businesses and would urge those businesses to get in touch with us to enable us to help promote their business and any promotions over the festive season and into the new year.”
Chancellor Jeremy Hunt delivered the autumn statement earlier today. Millions across the country will face rising taxes and Mr Hunt spending cuts have been made to “tackle the cost of living crisis and rebuild our economy”.
Hosepipe ban to remain despite heavy rain across Harrogate districtThe hosepipe ban across the Harrogate district will remain in place despite today’s heavy rainfall.
Yorkshire Water confirmed it will keep the ban in order to help refill its reservoirs ready for dry weather in spring and summer next year.
A spokesperson for the company said:
“Although we have had some rainfall recently, reservoir levels are still significantly below where we would expect for this time of year and are only around half full.
“Winter is the best chance our reservoirs have to refill and be ready for the warmer and drier months in spring and summer next year.
“We’re grateful to our customers who have been saving water where they can this summer, it’s important that we all continue to do so over winter too. Our teams are out 24/7 fixing leaks and moving water around the region to where it’s needed.
“The hosepipe ban is still in place to help protect the environment and give our reservoirs the best possible chance at returning to healthy levels.”
The Met Office has issued a weather warning for heavy rain across the district today and into tomorrow morning, saying there is the possibility of localised flooding.
Read more:
- Met Office issues weather warning for rain in Harrogate district
- Hosepipe ban introduced for Harrogate district
Meanwhile, extensive surface water has appeared on the Stray in Harrogate and there are reports of small patches of flooding on roads across the district.
One hardy resident was out this morning trying to clear leaves from blocked drains on Leadhall Lane, in an attempt to clear the flooded road between the junctions of Leadhall Road and By-ways.
Spotted a problem caused by the weather? Email us the details to let others know.
Call to retain taxi zones in North Yorkshire amid proposed changesCalls have been made for North Yorkshire to consider keeping local taxi licence zones amid a proposal to move to a single policy.
Cllr Andrew Williams, county councillor for Ripon Minster and Moorside, called for assurances that council officials would look at retaining local licensing zones after concern from cabbies.
Under proposals already put forward, the new North Yorkshire Council would create a single licensing policy for hackney carriages and private hire vehicles in the entire county.
It would mean drivers in Harrogate could operate anywhere in North Yorkshire, whereas they are currently restricted to the Harrogate district.
Cllr Williams told a council meeting yesterday that local drivers had raised concern that the changes would lead to taxis flocking to areas during high demand, such as a large event, leaving customers in other areas struggling to get a cab.
He said:
“I have been approached by taxi drivers who I represent who are very concerned that any form of deregulation could lead to problems in terms of actually being able to get a taxi because taxi drivers will move from rank to rank depending on when there is a busy day in a certain locality.”
Read more:
- No increase in wheelchair accessible taxis in Harrogate district
- Taxi licensing changes will cause ‘chaos’, says Ripon cabbie
- New council plans single taxi licensing for North Yorkshire
Cllr Williams added that fare rates for the entire county should be based on the highest charged otherwise drivers could lose out on income.
The council said previously that fares for hackney carriages would be reviewed at a later date.
In response, Cllr Carl Les, leader of the county council, said that all views submitted to a consultation over the changes would be considered.
He said:
“I think they are all valid points.
“Hopefully they will all come out in that consultation and then we will make the decisions when we have heard what people have actually said.”
Changes will cause “chaos”
The move to propose a single licensing policy has caused concern for cabbies in the Harrogate district.
Richard Fieldman, who has operated his cab in Ripon for 28 years, told the Stray Ferret previously that the planned changes would see drivers “swamp” areas during the busiest times of day.
Mr Fieldman said the move would see quieter areas deprived of taxis during the busier times.
He said:
“It will mean that any taxi can work in any area.
“You are going to have swamps of taxis in busy areas at busy times. That in itself brings chaos.”
A consultation into the policy changes is open until January 19, 2023. You can have your say here.
Government grants needed to help finances, says county council leaderMore measures are needed to help North Yorkshire County Council’s finances despite support from government on council tax, says the leader of the authority.
Cllr Carl Les said the council needed grants from central government in order to help balance its books.
His comments come as Chancellor Jeremy Hunt is expected to announce an increase in the threshold in which authorities can increase council tax by without a local referendum.
Currently, the threshold is 2.99% – but Mr Hunt is expected to hike this to 5% in today’s autumn statement.
Cllr Les told a meeting of the county council yesterday that while the measure would be welcomed, more support would be needed.
He said:
“It will give us flexibility, but I don’t think that it’s the only leaver that we need to pull.
“Government grants has got to be part of that answer as well.”
The move comes as county council leaders warned in June that the upcoming North Yorkshire Council could face a blackhole of £50 million in its finances.
Read more:
- North Yorkshire Council faces £50m black hole, says finance boss
- North Yorkshire to tackle housing crisis with second homes charge
Cllr Gareth Dadd, executive member for finance at the county council, said the situation was largely due to deficits it will inherit from district councils and high inflation.
The new unitary authority will replace Harrogate Borough Council, the county council and the remaining six districts.
Although he did not estimate the total structural deficits that the seven second tier authorities, including Harrogate Borough Council, would have accumulated by the time the new council is launched in April, he said it was believed it would be “substantial”.
It has been estimated the combined ongoing deficits of the district and borough councils could be in the region of £10 million.
In addition, ahead of the recent increasing inflation rate the county authority had been prepared to cover a deficit of up to £20 million.
With inflationary pressures, which include the council’s gas and electricity bill rising by some £3m, it is believed the total deficit could nearly reach £50 million.
Cllr Dadd said at the time:
“That is a frightening figure, but nonetheless, I think we are right to raise that at this stage.”