The 56-year history of Harrogate’s Woodfield Community Primary School is set to come to an end after councillors confirmed its closure today.

The school in Bilton will shut on December 31 despite complaints that pupils and parents have been “badly let down” by education bosses at North Yorkshire County Council.

But the council claims it has “exhausted all options” to try to keep the school open after years of falling pupil numbers and an inadequate rating by Ofsted.

Speaking at a meeting of the council’s executive today, ward councillor and school governor Paul Haslam repeated his objections to the closure which he blamed on an “unfounded allegation” about the school that was posted on social media several years ago. Cllr Haslam said”

“Today is a sad day. We have allowed social media and its consequent impact to close a perfectly good school.

“This cannot be allowed to happen to another school and it is only a failure if we do not learn from this sad event.”

Read more:

• Fears more Harrogate schools could follow in footsteps of closure-threatened Woodfield primary
• Fate of Woodfield primary school to be confirmed next week

Cllr Haslam, who represents the Bilton and Nidd Gorge division, added that the closure will “rip a large hole in this community” as he also called for a review into how it happened.

Paul Haslam

Stuart Carlton, the council’s corporate director of children and young people’s services, responded to say he “could not compel” other education bodies to discuss the issues around social media, but that he would meet with Cllr Haslam. He said:

“These are always very difficult decisions, but we have followed all the processes.

“The problem nationally of social media is one that isn’t unique to ourselves or particular schools here – it is something that plagues out across the country at times.

“I’m more than happy that I commit with my assistant director of education to meet with councillor Haslam and the chair of governors to talk through that point.”

Conservative councillor Annabel Wilkinson, the executive member for education and skills, also said the decision to close the school was made with a “heavy heart”.

Today’s decision comes after pupil numbers at the school dwindled from 155 in 2018 to just one earlier this month.

The inadequate rating by Ofsted inspectors came in 2020 and meant the school had to become part of an academy, however, it failed to one to secure its future.

Woodfield Community Primary School, which opened around 1964, then held merger talks with the nearby Grove Road Community Primary School, but these fell through.

Financial troubles have also hit the school, with debts forecast to reach almost £100,000 by the end of 2022/23 set to be absorbed by the county council.

The closure will also mean the Woodfield catchment area will be shared with both Bilton Grange Primary School and Grove Road Community Primary School.

Richard Taylor Primary School in Bilton has received a ‘good’ rating by Ofsted.

The government schools inspector, which visited Richard Taylor in June, praised the quality of learning as well as how much children enjoy attending.

The report said pupils work hard to meet the high expectations set by teachers and that children with special educational needs were particularly well supported by a “broad and ambitious” curriculum.

The report said:

“Pupils say that they love school and their friends at Richard Taylor primary.

“Pupils feel safe, and are safe, because staff look after them well and help them with any problems they may have.

“Teachers help them to do their best. They are well supported by school staff.”

Read more:

• North Yorkshire gets less than half national average for special schools
• Closure notice published for Harrogate school

The report praised the “calm and orderly environment” and said child welfare and safeguarding were well catered for. It said:

“Pupils say that bullying does not happen, but if it did, they trust that adults would deal with it quickly.”

Richard Taylor school

Staff, it added, “are proud to work at the school” and “say that leaders support them well”.

Most parents say the school is a “great community to be part of” and feel supported by staff.

Founded in 1793

Richard Taylor was founded in 1793 and moved to its current site on Bilton Lane in 1973.

The 275-pupil school, which is a founding member of the Yorkshire Causeway Schools Trust, was last inspected in 2017, when it was also rated ‘good’.

The latest report highlighted “some inconsistencies in staff expertise to deliver phonics”, adding:

“As a result, some pupils in the earliest stages of reading are not competent at blending letter sounds to read a word.”

It said leaders were in the process of putting in place “a more systematic approach to the teaching of phonics”.

Headteacher Andrew Symonds and deputy headteacher Emma Crisell

Andrew Symonds, who has been headteacher at Richard Taylor for 13 years, said:

“Everyone at Richard Taylor school is very pleased with the outcome of our most recent report.

“We are delighted that the inspector recognised the strong sense of community where a culture of respect and kindness is in every classroom.

“The report also clearly identified the strong duty of care and united vision for the pupils, based upon our Christian values, which is shared by everyone associated with the school.

“I would like to thank the children, parents, governors and leaders within the Yorkshire Causeway Schools Trust for their hard work and support which is reflected in this report.

“As a school we are ready to focus on the agreed targets for development as we prepare to celebrate 230 years as a learning community in Harrogate and our 50th anniversary on our current site.”