Council confirms closure of Nidderdale primary school with no pupils

Fountains Earth Church of England Primary School will officially close for good at the end of this month.

North Yorkshire Council’s Conservative-run executive met yesterday in Northallerton to approve the closure following a consultation.

The school in Lofthouse near Pateley Bridge has faced dwindling pupil numbers in recent years and currently has no pupils on its books.

The council’s executive member for education Annabel Wilkinson said “nobody wants to close a small school” and it was “a very hard decision”.

Fountains Earth is part of Upper Nidderdale Federation alongside St Cuthbert’s Church of England Primary School in Pateley Bridge and Glasshouses Community Primary School.

Earlier in the meeting, Cllr Andrew Murday (Liberal Democrat, Pateley Bridge and Nidderdale) pleaded with councillors to delay a decision as he called for an investigation to take place first into the leadership of the school’s federation related to its academic and financial performance as well as communication with parents.

He noted that the school received a ‘good’ rating from Ofsted in 2022 and if the issues were resolved, he believes parents would bring their children back.

Cllr Murday said:

“There would be pupils if the dispute with the federation hadn’t happened. Families have put houses up for sale because the school’s not there. It’s a chicken and egg situation.

“Rural schools are important for communities and they gain something from being small and within the community.”

However, the council’s legal officer Barry Khan suggested it would be out of its remit to investigate governance at the federation.

The number of pupils at the school had declined from 20 in 2017 to 10 in 2022.

This led executive member for finance Cllr Gareth Dadd to say keeping a school open with such few potential pupils “would be doing a disservice to those children”.

Cllr Greg White, executive member for environment, said for rural schools to remain open, residents need to “breed and have children”.

Cllr Dadd said: 

“I feel very uncomfortable sending a child to a primary school with 8 pupils. I don’t think it can be beneficial to that child. It’s not just about education it’s about social interaction as well.”

Amanda Newbold, assistant director for education and skills at North Yorkshire Council, said this had been a factor when parents withdrew their children.

She said: 

“Four to 11-year-olds were being taught in one class. This was a challenge for the one member of staff who then moved on and the school struggled to recruit. They relied on agency staff or other teachers from the federation.

“When a child became the only one in their year group, the parents wanted to move them to schools with other children their own age to prepare for secondary school.”

The school will officially close on March 31 and its catchment area will become part of St Cuthbert’s Church of England Primary School in Pateley Bridge.

Read more:

Harrogate district school unable to find new teacher for five years

A Harrogate district school facing closure has found it impossible to recruit a single permanent teacher for five years, according to North Yorkshire Council.

The council has recommended consulting on whether to close Fountains Earth Church of England Primary School in Lofthouse, near Pateley Bridge, on March 31 next year.

Elected councillors will vote whether to accept the recommendation next week.

The council claims the decision is largely due to falling pupil numbers, and with no children remaining on the roll the decision appears a formality.

But villagers claim they have been let down by the council and the Upper Nidderdale Federation, which the school is part of, and say closure will rip the heart out of Lofthouse.

The federation also includes St Cuthbert’s in Pateley Bridge and Glasshouses Primary School. The three schools share one headteacher.

A report by council officers ahead of next week’s vote said “it has not been possible to recruit a permanent teacher” for the last five years.

It attributes this to the school’s remote location as well as difficulty finding someone capable of teaching a wide range of ages and abilities from reception pupils to year six.

The report adds:

“Staff retention has also proved difficult with a high turnover of staff over the last five years resulting in use of agency staff which comes with increased staffing costs.

“The school is just over six miles from Pateley Bridge at the top end of Nidderdale which, by virtue of the local road, can be a slow journey as part of a longer commute for staff.”

Read more:

The report added supply staff only need to give a day’s notice, which caused further disruption.

It said:

“Recruitment of the right people is a time-consuming activity which has required a substantial amount of the federation’s senior leadership team resource over the past few years.”

Rated ‘good’ at last Ofsted

Fountains Earth was rated ‘good’ at its most recent full Ofsted inspection in April 2017.

The school’s governing board recently approached the council to request consultation on a proposal to close the school after all pupils had transferred to other schools by the start of the current academic year in September.

Cllr Annabel Wilkinson, the council’s Conservative executive member for education, learning and skills, will decide whether to trigger a five-week consultation starting in November.

Cllr Wilkinson said:

“North Yorkshire maintains more small, rural schools than any other local authority in the country. Sadly, the reality is that many of our schools, particularly those in rural areas, are seeing pupil numbers reduce year-on-year.

“Fountains Earth Primary School is among the rural schools finding itself in a difficult position, particularly around pupil numbers and funding, and I will consider these issues carefully when deciding if a public consultation should proceed.”

 

Pateley school rated ‘good’ by Ofsted after major changes

A Pateley Bridge primary school has been rated ‘good’ by Ofsted.

St Cuthbert’s Church of England Primary School has undergone major changes over the last 18 months.

A new executive headteacher and deputy headteacher were appointed in April last year and in January this year the school became part of the Upper Nidderdale Primary Federation.

The federation also includes Glasshouses Community Primary School and Fountains Earth Church of England Primary School in Lofthouse.

Ofsted inspectors visited St Cuthbert’s for two days last month and their report, published yesterday, said the school “has been on a journey of improvement over the last 12 months” and rated it good in all areas.

They described the school as “a safe and caring place” and said pupils had caring attitudes, behaved well and don’t tolerate bullying. Staff have high morale and feel well supported.

Safeguarding arrangements are described as effective and leaders are praised for introducing “a well-considered and ambitious curriculum to the school” and for having “high expectations” of pupils.

The report says:

“This school has been on a journey of improvement. Pupils, staff, parents and carers acknowledge the changes that have been made. Leaders are committed to ensuring that this journey continues at pace.”

The report also highlights how the school provides good opportunities for personal development but says it should provide a wider breadth of extra-curricular opportunities, such as after-school clubs and activities

Nicola Thornber

Nicola Thornber

Executive headteacher Nicola Thornber said:

“This report recognises the hard work and drive that leads to excellent outcomes, while developing the pupil’s character as part of a supportive and caring school community.

“Despite the new rigorous inspection framework where judgements are harder to achieve, combined with the ongoing demands of the pandemic, this report recognises the excellent work, progress and achievement the school has made. Our inspiring federation staff team and pupils work tirelessly together to provide an excellent education.”

Chair of governors Abi Broadley, said

“We, as the governing board, are delighted that this final inspection across the Federation highlights the skill, competency and hard work of the executive headteacher, leadership and staff team.

“As governors, we have seen first-hand the positive impact on pupil behaviour and educational quality, that means that each child at St Cuthbert’s has an excellent opportunity to develop and thrive. We look forward to continuing to support the school’s leadership to build on this strong foundation.