A Harrogate personal trainer and nutrition coach says there isn’t a right or wrong answer when it comes to calories being listed on menus.
Lyndsay Wells said one of the benefits of the new regulations was that people might actually change their order to something they would enjoy more.
However, she said it would be more beneficial for people to understand their own needs and the nutritional content of what they ordered, rather than a simple calorie count.
She said:
“There are occasions where someone might assume a dish is low calorie because it’s a salad or fish dish for example. However, by the time you’ve added in oil, butter, cheese or dressings, you might find that a burger is around the same energy value.
“This is where it might help people move away from demonising certain foods and choosing something that they would enjoy more.
“This is again dependent on whether the focus of an individual is to create a calorie deficit or just be more mindful of consumption.
“The other thing to note is that lower calorie doesn’t equal more healthy.
“There are plenty of low calorie, but highly processed, carbohydrate snack foods with little benefit to our body, where avocado or nuts, for example, would be much more nutritious but also much higher in calories.”
Lyndsay’s comments follow a Stray Ferret report yesterday on a top Harrogate hotelier’s views on new rules that mean the calorie count of dishes must be published on some restaurant menus.
Under new regulations, restaurants, cafes and takeaways with more than 250 staff must print how many calories are in meals on their menus, websites, and on delivery platforms.
The new rule, which was brought in at the start of the month, is part of Government plans to tackle obesity by helping people to make healthier choices.
Mrs Wells said she could see it could be problematic in some instances, such as for people with eating disorders.
She also said there was no evidence that it will improve people’s choices when eating out.
She said:
“For this to truly work, an individual would firstly need to know their daily energy needs and be motivated to stay within these parameters, either for overall health and weight maintenance or with a deficit for fat loss.”
Even if people know their energy needs, Mrs Wells said values on menus could be inaccurate and should only be used as a guide.
Read more:
- Listing calories on menus is ‘bizarre’, says top Harrogate hotel boss
- Six outdoor workouts to try across the Harrogate district this spring and summer
She said calorie counts should only form part of the decision, with individual needs and overall nutrition also to be considered.
She added:
“I might still have something with a higher calorie value because I’m focused on eating for health and strength.
“I totally appreciate that my goals are completely individual and we are all different, this is why I feel there’s no right answer.
“But we have to make some changes to encourage restaurants to improve the way they prepare foods and reduce portion sizes, which are often far bigger than they need to be. This is often more problematic.
“We live in an increasingly obesogenic environment. I do think more needs to be done to update education on nutrition guidance and the ‘whys’ of moderation and the benefits of eating more whole foods, protein and vegetables.”
A leading Harrogate hotelier says new rules which see calories listed on menus are “bizarre”.
Restaurants, cafes and takeaways with more than 250 staff must print how many calories are in meals on their menus, websites, and on delivery platforms.
The new rule, which was brought in at the start of the month, is part of Government plans to tackle obesity by helping people to make healthier choices.
Peter Banks, managing director of Rudding Park, said:
“From an industry perspective, it is bizarre.
“Why is the number 250? It’s an entirely arbitrary figure. Surely it’s nothing to do with the number of people you employ, it’s to do with the number of calories.
“It means a business that might employ 200 people for example doesn’t have to put calories on the menu, which makes no sense.”
Peter Banks, managing director of Rudding Park in Harrogate.
Mr Banks said other problems included it being a huge task to get the calorie information for dishes, making it more difficult to change or update the menu.
He added that guests were also being put off from ordering food.
He said:
“The big one last week was a lady ordered cauliflower cheese and broccoli for her main course. When it was pointed out that these were side dishes, she said she only had a 2,000 calorie daily allowance so couldn’t have anymore.
“This means it is limiting spend in restaurants. We have certainly noticed a decrease in the number of puddings being ordered.”
Read more:
- Pret A Manger set to open in Harrogate ‘very soon’
- Harrogate sandwich shop re-opens after 2 year closure
He stressed that he understood what the Government was trying to achieve and agreed that action needed to be taken to tackle the obesity crisis.
However, he added:
“I’m not sure it’s a very well through piece of legislation. Diners should be given a choice. If they want to see a menu with calories listed then they should have that option. This way it’s forcing it down their throats. It’s really strange.
“It’s another layer of admin, it’s another layer of costs.
Also, how are the Government going to monitor if the number of calories is correct? Is there going to be someone coming around to weigh how many potatoes are in a dish? How are they going to enforce it?”
Members of the F45 Harrogate gym, on Albert Street, have mixed opinions on the new legislation.
Georgina Lambley said:
“Personally I don’t mind it and I find it useful for tracking calories. However, I think it’s detrimental to the mental health of many people such as those battling eating disorders.”
Megan Rose said she had mixed feelings.
She said:
“I understand that on one hand there is an obesity epidemic in the UK and this is another way of tackling that.
“On the other hand, I used to have an eating disorder and would have found it crippling when I was at my lowest. I have heard however that restaurants are still able to offer calorie free menus for those that are prone to disordered eating.”
However, Sarah Hart said it was a positive change.
She said:
“I think it’s a great idea and helps guide choices – thumbs up from me!”
Richard Hall added:
“I think it will make me think a bit more carefully and maybe go for a more ‘sensible’ option.“We were at Côte Brasserie on Saturday night and the calories were on there (in really small print). I chose a salad rather than something with dauphinoise potatoes.”