A bid to build a retirement complex in Knaresborough has failed for the second time after concerns were raised over the impact on “massively stretched” health services.
Harrogate Borough Council’s planning committee has today deferred a decision on the latest proposals for 61 extra care apartments near Grimbald Bridge on Wetherby Road after previously refusing the development a year ago.
It follows an objection from the NHS North Yorkshire CCG (Clinical Commissioning Group) which said it was “extremely concerned” that another care facility could increase the elderly population and “overload” local services.
The CCG said in a letter:
“This proposal for a new care facility is not something the local population are in need of, and is being proposed in an area that does not have healthcare staff or infrastructure available to be able to safely manage these patients.”
Defending the plans, Robert Gaskell, planning manager at the developers Adlington Retirement Living, claimed there is a “critical” need for new care facilities in the area and that the impact on health services would be “minimal”.
He told a meeting today:
“The majority of people who move into these apartments come from the local area.
“Our experience is that 80% of residents actually reside in a 10 mile radius. If these people are currently visiting primary care, then the impact is already occurring.
“This development actually helps solve the problem because there are less visits to GPs because people are getting the care they need and are in a supportive environment.”
Read more:
- 23 trees in Knaresborough to be felled this week for new leisure centre
- Plea for ‘moratorium’ on controversial 181-home Kingsley development
Mr Gaskell also said the proposed building had been scaled back from four storeys to three, and also included a new access and footpath upgrades after other concerns were raised.
However, road safety and the risk of flooding has remained an issue for residents and councillors – despite specialists in these areas not raising any objections.
Councillor Phil Ireland, who represents the area on Harrogate Borough Council and Knaresborough Town Council, told today’s meeting that he believed the site was not suitable for any development of this size.
He said:
“The site is subject to flooding as witnessed on Sunday, February 20 when some residents of Nidderdale Lodge Park just downstream had to be physically carried out from their properties.
“This site is unsustainable and totally unsuitable for a development of this scale.”
Resident Steve Benn also described the changes in the latest plans as “minimal” and said many locals in the area were against the development.
Mr Gaskell responded by claiming there were no records of flooding at the site, as he also said the proposed widening and resurfacing of footpaths on Wetherby Road represented an improvement from the previous scheme.
He said:
“The site has not flooded. There is no record from the Environment Agency of the site flooding.
“Indeed, the site will provide some betterment in terms of flooding as a flood basement will accommodate an additional 600 cubic metres of flood water.
“In terms of the highways impacts, these have been addressed satisfactorily and a road safety audit has been conducted.”
Councillors voted to defer a decision on the plans to allow for more information on health services, flooding and other potential footpath improvements to come forward.
The proposals will be brought back to the planning committee at a later date.
Walk-in boosters at Great Yorkshire Showground extended to Christmas EveWalk-in booster vaccinations will be available at Harrogate’s Great Yorkshire Showground until at least Christmas Eve, health bosses have confirmed.
Prime Minister Boris Johnson last night announced that every adult in Britain will be offered a covid booster jab by the end of December, as he warned there was a “tidal wave of Omicron coming”.
North Yorkshire Clinical Commissioning Group has since confirmed that people over-18 will be able to get a jab at the showground without an appointment until December 24.
Staff at Yorkshire Health Network, a federation of the 17 GP practices in the Harrogate district, also said today the showground site was offering walk-in clinics for 12 to 18-year-olds from 2pm to 4pm on Wednesday and 2pm to 4pm on Monday next week.
On Christmas Eve, the vaccination site will be open from 9am until 11.30am.
Booked appointments
All adults will also be able to book appointments on the NHS national booking service from Wednesday.
Those who choose to book will be given appointments at either the Yorkshire Event Centre, Knaresborough’s Chain Lane pharmacy, Ripon racecourse or other pharmacy sites in the district.
So far, 74,680 booster vaccines have been given in the Harrogate district, according to government figures.
Read more:
- Meet the showground heroes boosting Harrogate’s vaccine programme
- Harrogate district records 200th covid death
- First suspected omicron cases found in Harrogate district
70 infections today
Meanwhile, the Harrogate district has reported a further 70 covid cases, according to today’s government figures.
Data from the UK Health Security Agency shows that five suspected cases of the omicron variant have been reported in the district.
The Harrogate district’s covid rate now stands at 407 infections per 100,000 people.
Across the county, the average stands at 382 and the England rate is 515.
No further deaths from patients who tested positive for covid have been reported at Harrogate District Hospital, according to NHS England.
Latest available figures show nine covid patients are being treated at Harrogate District Hospital.
No Harrogate district walk-in vaccine centres as clinics ‘at capacity’Health officials say they are unable to open any walk-in covid vaccination centres in Harrogate because clinics are already running at capacity.
The announcement on Monday that booster jabs were being made available without appointments caused some confusion as no Harrogate district sites appeared on the NHS online walk-in finder.
Those eligible for their third jabs were being sent to the nearest sites in Leeds or Middlesbrough, although a centre in Pateley Bridge has since appeared online.
NHS North Yorkshire Clinical Commissioning Group has now explained that it is unable to open any more walk-in sites in the area due to capacity and supply issues.
A CCG spokesperson said:
“All clinics are running at capacity and we will open walk-ins in a planned way as soon as we are able to.
“If we open walk-ins now it is likely we would exceed our vaccine allocation and there would be some disappointed people and negative feedback, which we are trying to avoid.”
Read more:
- Knaresborough vaccine centre welcomes first 12 to 15-year-olds
- Great Yorkshire Showground vaccine site to reopen for just two weeks
- Harrogate people face trip to Leeds for booster jab walk-ins
Appointment-based vaccines for over-50s and those with underlying health conditions are still available to book at local clinics via the national booking system.
Dedicated slots for 12 to 15-year-olds are also available at the Homecare Pharmacy site in Knaresborough.
These jabs for 12 to 15-year-olds are also being offered at schools and outside the district at the Askham Bar site in York, Leeds United’s Elland Road stadium, the Northern Echo Arena in Darlington and Middlesbrough’s Riverside Stadium.
New sites ‘as soon as possible’
The CCG said it was looking to add additional sites across North Yorkshire “as soon as possible”.
It was announced last week that Harrogate’s Great Yorkshire Showground will reopen as a vaccine centre for an expected busy period of booster jabs in December.
The venue – which was used as a vaccine site for most of the year before closing in August – will reopen for two weeks at the start of the month.
Public Health England figures show a total of 130,898 people in the Harrogate district have received their first vaccine dose and 122,140 people their second.
No figures are available for booster jabs.
Vaccine take up is lowest among 12 to 15-year-olds with just 18% receiving their single dose.
The CCG said everyone in this age group will be offered their vaccine by the end of November.
Great Yorkshire Showground vaccine site to reopen for just two weeksHarrogate’s Great Yorkshire Showground will reopen as a coronavirus vaccination centre for two weeks in December, it has been announced.
The venue – which was used as a vaccination site for most of the year before closing in August – will reopen at the beginning of December for an expected busy period of booster jabs, the NHS North Yorkshire Clinical Commissioning Group said.
A CCG spokesperson said:
“Plans are in place to run pop-up covid vaccination clinics at the Yorkshire Showground at the beginning of December for two weeks, as this is when we are anticipating a peak in the number of patients eligible to receive their booster jabs.
“In the meantime, patients over 50 and those in other priority groups who are now eligible for their booster dose, who would prefer not to wait until December, have a number of additional options they may wish to consider, including booking an appointment at an alternative vaccination centre via the NHS National Booking Service or 119.
“Patients can also use this service to book a first or second dose of the vaccine if they’ve not yet taken up the opportunity to be vaccinated.”
The announcement comes after an NHS official last week told a press briefing that the showground would reopen as a vaccination centre, but did not say for how long.
Read more:
- Great Yorkshire Showground vaccine centre to reopen
- Great Yorkshire Showground vaccination site closes in June
- Exclusive: Great Yorkshire Showground gave 117,000 vaccines in six months
More than half of all over-50s across the UK have now received a booster jab and the government is urging greater take up to ease pressure on the NHS ahead of a difficult winter due to covid pressures and long backlogs.
There is also a focus on getting more 12 to 15-year-olds vaccinated after the recent record levels of infections in Harrogate was linked to young people.
High infections rates
The high case rates led to health officials urging schools in the district to reintroduce face masks and postpone some activities to try keep infections under control.
Every headteacher was also contacted with the offer of extra support and advice.

The Great Yorkshire Showground operating as a vaccine site in February.
Latest Public Health England figures show just over 16% of 12 to 15-year-olds in the Harrogate district have received their single vaccine dose.
An NHS North Yorkshire CCG spokesperson said:
“We continue to encourage people to get vaccinated. The coronavirus vaccines are safe and effective.
“They offer the best protection against covid.”
Figures also show a total of 130,232 people in the Harrogate district have received their first vaccine dose and 121,915 people their second.
That equates to 83% and 77% of the population respectively.
No figures are available for booster jabs.
Harrogate hospital covid patients increase as infections soarThe number of covid patients in Harrogate District Hospital has increased, as case numbers reach their highest levels since January.
A covid press briefing today heard there are now 80 covid patients in hospitals in North Yorkshire, up from 47 seven days ago.
In Harrogate, the number of patients being treated stands at five, compared with two last week.
North Yorkshire’s seven-day infection rate is now 355 per 100,000 people and there have been more than 2,000 new infections since this time last week. The figure for the Harrogate district is even higher at 410.
Amanda Bloor, NHS North Yorkshire Clinical Commissioning Group’s accountable officer, told a meeting of the North Yorkshire Local Resilience Forum today that hospital numbers had not reached the levels of previous waves.
She said:
“The last time that the infection rate across North Yorkshire and York was at 300 per 100,000 population, and it is slightly higher than that now, was back in late January and at that point there were over 400 patients in hospital beds across North Yorkshire.
“So whilst we can see that the numbers are increasing they are not at the height of the numbers that they were back in January when the vaccine program was at its very early stage.”
Ms Bloor said those being admitted to hospital in North Yorkshire tended to be younger than in previous waves and were mainly among those who had not yet taken up the offer of a vaccine.
Read more:
- Knaresborough vaccine centre to hold first walk-in clinic this weekend
- Map shows second covid vaccine rate in Harrogate district
- Walk-in vaccine clinics in Harrogate, Knaresborough and Pateley Bridge this weekend
She said the vaccine was making a difference to the numbers of people being admitted to hospital but warned that people should continue to be careful when restrictions are lifted on Monday.
Mrs Bloor said:
“Whilst the rules are changing as we move towards next Monday we all still have the power to ensure that the behaviours that we exhibit help prevent the spread of infections, to help stop other people becoming infected and help protect yourself and your families and I would encourage everyone to make responsible choices as we emerge from the final stage of lockdown next week.”
At the same meeting Louise Wallace, North Yorkshire’s director of public health, said that the rise in the number of covid cases tended to be concentrated in those under the age of 35 but that they were now starting to see increases in older people also.
She encouraged people to continue to keep taking precautions even after restrictions are lifted.
Ms Wallace said:
‘They’re only trying to help us’: GPs face verbal abuse over delays for non-covid services“We are going to take the next step to stage four on the roadmap and it is about living with covid and I urge people to think of the combination of things that we can all do to protect ourselves, our friends, our families and communities.
“Whilst it is now the summer and we are enjoying meeting up and doing things that we could not do a few months ago there are things that we should all do to respect and protect each other.
“This includes meeting in well ventilated areas, where possible outdoors or with windows open if we are indoors.
“Wear face coverings when you come into contact with people you don’t normally meet or in an enclosed or crowded space.”
GP practices are facing a wave of abuse from patients frustrated with delays for non-covid health services stretched by the pandemic, an NHS boss has said.
Amanda Bloor, accountable officer for NHS North Yorkshire Clinical Commissioning Group, told a briefing today that patients are being aggressive on an “increasingly frequent basis” as GPs struggle to cope with huge demand for routine services including appointments and prescriptions.
Ms Bloor has issued a plea for patience and politeness towards staff which she said are working under difficult circumstances as they not only try to deal with this demand but also spearhead the covid vaccination drive.
She told a North Yorkshire Local Resilience Forum briefing:
“We are continuing to see significant system pressures across North Yorkshire and York in all of our health care settings but we are also now sadly hearing some feedback about abusive behaviour towards staff.
“A number of our GP surgeries have said their practice teams are being subject to verbal abuse on an increasingly frequent basis, particularly receptionists.
“The wider NHS and all of its staff are here to help you, so please do work with us and be kind. I don’t think anybody deserves to be abused at work particularly when in challenging situations they are only trying to help us.”
Over the past 14 months, while all GPs have been working throughout the pandemic, surgeries have reduced face-to-face appointments which have been replaced with telephone and online consultations.
Read more:
- North Yorkshire’s covid vaccine ‘success’ to be examined
- More than 100,000 people have first covid vaccine in Harrogate district
It has meant long telephone queues and online forms for patients seeking the medical help they need, however, surgeries have now begun restarting more services.
Earlier this month, the NHS published updated guidance which said patients should be able to request an in-person appointment with their doctor unless they have covid symptoms.
But in order to keep the pressure off staff, Ms Bloor said patients should still use online and telephone services where they can, including 111 for any urgent medical help and the NHS app for ordering prescriptions.
She said:
“Please do use the NHS wisely and that way we can best support everybody’s needs.”
Meanwhile, Ms Bloor also told today’s briefing that more than 482,000 people in North Yorkshire and York have now received their first covid vaccine dose, while 312,000 people have had their second.
There are, however, still more than 31,000 residents who belong in the top nine priority groups and have yet to come forward despite receiving their vaccine invites.
Ms Bloor said:
More than 95,000 receive first covid vaccine in Harrogate district“We encourage everyone across North Yorkshire and York to take up the vaccination when they are invited and also make sure they do attend for the second dose when the time comes as we know that second dose does just make all the difference.
“We also know that over 31,000 people have not yet come forward and it is really important that we get as many people across all communities covered by the vaccination as possible.
“It is not just about stopping you getting the virus, it is about protecting families, loved ones and the wider community.”
The number of people who have received the first dose of a covid vaccine in the Harrogate district has reached 95,000.
According to NHS England statistics, 95,137 have had a first vaccine.
The figure is an increase of 710 on last week.
It comes as Amanda Bloor, chief accountable officer at NHS North Yorkshire CCG, said 45 to 49-year-olds were being invited for their first jabs at the Great Yorkshire Showground site.
Read more:
- No vaccinations at Great Yorkshire Showground for 19 days this summer
- ‘It’s been superb’: Nidderdale welcomes Pateley Bridge vaccination centre
However, she said the number invited was dependent on vaccine supply.
The CCG confirmed that 428,000 people have had a first dose across North Yorkshire and York, while 140,000 have had a second dose.
Meanwhile, health bosses confirmed the Yorkshire Showground site in Harrogate will not be open for vaccinations for 19 days this summer due to the Great Yorkshire Show and other events taking place.
The NHS has an agreement to use the site until August 13.
Harrogate district gets NHS scheme to help children sleepA project to help young people overcome sleeping difficulties has been extended to cover the Harrogate district.
NHS North Yorkshire Clinical Commissioning Group initially commissioned The Sleep Charity to run pilot projects in Whitby, Scarborough and Ryedale.
The scheme has now been extended to families across North Yorkshire for 12 months, starting on April 1.
The free scheme uses behavioural therapy, sleep clinics and workshops rather than medication to aid sleep.
It also provides professional training to GP practice staff, health visitors and school nurses.
Read more:
- Harrogate dentist drops plans to stop NHS services
- More funds needed for Girlguiding centre at Birk Crag to open
Research by The Sleep Charity, The Sleep Council and Sleepstation found that since the pandemic began, 70% of children are going to bed significantly later than usual.
Vicki Dawson, chief executive of The Sleep Charity, which is based in Doncaster, said:
“Quality sleep is absolutely essential for a child’s growth and development.
“It helps children to concentrate on learning, allows them to react more quickly to situations, have a more developed memory and solve problems.
“Plus, it makes them less susceptible to colds and other minor ailments, less irritable and better behaved.”
Dr Charles Parker, NHS North Yorkshire CCG clinical chair, said:
“We know how debilitating, disruptive and distressing it can be for families when a child is struggling to sleep, and we see first-hand how it can lead to a number of physical and mental health issues which require treatment.
“It’s heartening to hear that The Sleep Charity’s work has already made a huge difference to many families in Whitby, Scarborough and Ryedale and I’m delighted these services are now available across North Yorkshire.”
Families participating in the project gain access to the Teen Sleep Hub, which contains links to twice-weekly live chats with professional sleep practitioners.
The service is available for people aged 12 months to 18 years.
For children and young people with a special education need or disability and/or education health care plan, the service is available from ages 12 months to 25 years.
Access to the scheme is available by self referral. Email support@thesleepcharity.org.uk for details.
Over 70s in Harrogate district urged to contact NHS for covid vaccine
Over 70s in the Harrogate District who have not been invited for their covid vaccination are being urged to come forward and arrange an appointment.
It comes as the health service is aiming to vaccinate all those in the top four priority groups by February 15.
North Yorkshire health officials have previously said that they were confident of achieving the target.
Read more:
- Council chairman rolls up sleeve for covid vaccine
- Woman gets first covid vaccine at Ripon racecourse
Amanda Bloor, accountable officer at North Yorkshire CCG, said:
“Healthcare colleagues across North Yorkshire and York and in the wider Humber, Coast and Vale area have been doing a fantastic job to vaccinate people in the first four priority groups, but we want to ensure that all those who are eligible, have been offered the jab.
“We know that people over 70 and those on the shielded patient list are particularly vulnerable to coronavirus. It’s important they come forward if they haven’t had their vaccine yet.
“I urge everyone to check with their parents, grandparents, relatives, neighbours and friends who are 70 years old and over if they have been vaccinated. If they haven’t had the vaccine yet, please help them book an appointment as soon as possible.
“If you have previously turned down the opportunity to get the vaccine but have changed your mind, please also come forward now. We are determined that nobody should be left behind.
“The vaccine is safe, simple, and will offer you and those around you crucial protection against this virus.”
Those who are eligible for the vaccine can book an appointment through the national booking system at www.nhs.uk/covid-vaccination.
Those who cannot book online can call a free 119 telephone number, anytime between 7am and 11pm seven days a week. The national system allows patients to pick a convenient location and time.
Health bosses said those who receive a letter from the NHS to book with the national system, but already have an appointment booked with their local GP practice, should ignore the letter and keep the existing appointment.
Vaccinations are currently being offered at the Yorkshire Events Centre, Askham Bar in York and at Elland Road in Leeds.
North Yorkshire ‘will be prepared’ for covid vaccineHealth bosses in North Yorkshire have said they will be prepared to rollout a coronavirus vaccine in December, if it is available.
Amanda Bloor, accountable officer at North Yorkshire Clinical Commissioning Group, which buys medicines for the county, said it was working with national officials to make sure plans are in place to offer the vaccine.
It comes as preliminary results of the Pfizer and BioNTech vaccine showed that it was 90% effective after being tested on 43,500 people.
Ms Bloor told a press briefing yesterday of the North Yorkshire Local Resilience Forum, a partnership of agencies that tackle emergencies, there was “significant work” to do on the safety of the vaccine but the CCG would be ready for a rollout next month.
Read more:
- Harrogate district covid rate soars past 300 people per 100,000
- Covid patients in Harrogate hospital nearly double in a week
She said:
“Although there is some uncertainty on timescales, we will be ready in December to deploy a vaccine if it is available.
“But it is likely that wider vaccination will take place after Christmas and into the New Year. Any vaccination that happens before Christmas would be for very vulnerable groups.
“We are planning to be ready for this with our partners.”
“Even when we do have a vaccine, we still need to observe any social distancing measures, lockdown measures and the guidance around hand washing and hygiene.”
‘Don’t contact your GP’
Ms Bloor urged patients not to contact GP practices about the vaccine as it is not available. She said once it is, the CCG will be “very clear about the process”.
The government has said that any vaccine will be offered to the public in phases.
The first phase will include people living and working in care homes, those over the age of 80, then over 75, over 70, over 65 and then over 60.
It will then be offered to adults with health conditions that put them at risk, before it is given to those over the age of 55 and then 50.
The vaccine is given in two doses, three weeks apart.
‘Cautiously optimistic’
Dr Lincoln Sargeant, director of public health at North Yorkshire County Council, welcomed the preliminary results of the Pfizer vaccine.
Dr Sargeant said he was “cautiously optimistic” about the results but added there needed to be “long-term behavioural change” to overcome the virus.
He said:
“Any new drug or any new vaccine, the preliminary results are always going to be rosey for a variety of reasons.
“It is likely that when this vaccine is deployed fully that the effectiveness will be somewhat less than 90%.
“But it is still positive news, because it says that we have a vaccine that not only does the biology in terms of triggering the anti-bodies but in practice it can actually prevent infection.”
Meanwhile, a further 75 cases of coronavirus have been confirmed across the Harrogate district according to Public Health England figures today.
It takes the total number of cases since the start of the pandemic up to 3,178.
The seven-day rolling average rate of covid infections for the district has risen above 300 people per 100,000 for the first time.
The rate, which was 160 just over a fortnight ago, is now 307, which is above the England average of 254.