Councillors have approved plans to erect a 35 metres-high communications mast near Masham to boost 4G coverage in rural areas.
Mobile infrastructure provider Cornerstone submitted plans to North Yorkshire Council to build the tower in Ox Close Plantation, Healey where a report said existing 4G coverage is “spasmodic”.
The application is part of the shared rural network venture, which is a £1bn drive between government and operators Vodafone, Three and Virgin Media-O2 to improve the UK’s digital connectivity.
However, because the plantation sits within the Nidderdale Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty, which has strict planning laws, a council officer recommended refusing the application to preserve “scenic beauty”.
But at a meeting of the Skipton and Ripon planning committee yesterday afternoon, councillors ignored the recommendation and enthusiastically backed the mast proposal due to its positive impact on residents and businesses in the area.
A statement was read out on behalf of Cllr Felicity Cunliffe-Lister, a Liberal Democrat who represents Masham and Fountains, and who has previously campaigned for better rural internet connectivity.
Although she said she supported the plans, her statement informed councillors she also has an interest as her husband owns the land that the mast would be built on so would receive rent.
Cllr Cunliffe-Lister’s statement said:
“Life without this connectivity would become very challenging and become harder as services such as banking come online.
“Any concern about impact on landscape should be considered but not given priority.”
Read more
- Council to bid for government funding to progress Harrogate social housing schemes
- Communications tower plan near Masham would ‘harm landscape’
Veteran Skipton councillor Robert Heseltine said the plans should be approved “as a matter of principle” so rural communities can receive the same services as urban ones.
Cllr Heseltine said:
“Residents and businesses of rural North Yorkshire have an absolute expectation to receive the same service as the rest of this nation.
“Communications are a necessity for the safety of the public and viability of farming and rural businesses.”
Ripon councillor Andrew Williams, a member of the Conservative and Independents group, said there were exceptions for building in the AONB and the Yorkshire Dales and referred to the giant “golf balls” at RAF Menwith Hill which “obliterate” the landscape and the Bilsdale television transmitter.
Cllr Williams said:
“The landscape has always changed and will continue to change. Here are people who are unable to work from home, they can’t get any form of communication, that has an impact on running businesses.
“It’s not for townies to impose rules and restrictions on rural communities that makes them impossible to be viable. The plans are to be welcomed.”
The plans were approved unanimously.
Metal fences to remain in Harrogate’s Crescent Gardens until next yearThe metal fencing around the pavilion in Harrogate‘s Crescent Gardens will remain in place until the new year, North Yorkshire Council has confirmed.
The fencing was erected last month as a “temporary measure” to prevent a group of rough sleepers from occupying the building.
The group, which inhabited the pavilion for two weeks in September, returned twice after being dispersed by officials.
A spokesperson for the council told the Stray Ferret this morning:
“The fencing is a temporary measure, but will remain in place until the new year as a result of the Christmas ice rink going into the gardens this month.”
The ice rink, which was put up on Crescent Gardens for the first time last year, is part of a three-year Christmas activity licence introduced by the former Harrogate Borough Council.
In a report at the time, Kirsty Stewart, the council’s grounds and maintenance manager, said the festive licence “will generate a minimum income of £37,500 per year”.

A rose arch has been erected as part of the Crescent Gardens revamp.
This has helped to fund a £21,000 revamp of Crescent Gardens.
Last year, the pavilion was used as a makeshift boot room for ice skaters, however its use this year is uncertain following the recent update.
Read more:
- Metal fencing to remain indefinitely in Harrogate’s Crescent Gardens
- Rose arch erected — but will Harrogate’s Crescent Gardens be renamed?
Lib Dem leader accuses Tories of ‘pinching’ Harrogate Station Gateway ideas
The leader of the Liberal Democrats in Harrogate and Knaresborough has accused the Conservative transport chief of “pinching” their ideas for the £11.2 million Station Gateway.
North Yorkshire Council is hastily assembling new proposals for the scheme after admitting its previous plans failed to follow the correct procedure in the wake of legal action.
Councillor Keane Duncan, the Conservative executive member for highways, revealed last week that two of the most controversial aspects of the scheme — reducing Station Parade to one lane and pedestrianising James Street — would be scrapped.
A detailed new plan has yet to be published but it is expected to include improvements to Station Square and One Arch and upgrading traffic signals.
Lib Dem leader Pat Marsh said the Lib Dems suggested dropping the Station Parade and James Street proposals at an online meeting of the council’s Harrogate and Knaresborough area constituency committee working group on October 31 — shortly before Cllr Duncan’s announcement.
She said the 13 members of the area constituency committee are due to walk around the gateway site tomorrow (Thursday, November 8) with a senior officer at the council.
Cllr Marsh said the visit would enable the council to better understand the area and consider a “better connected” Lib Dem plan for the town centre.
She said previous gateway proposals “started nowhere and ended nowhere”.
Cllr Marsh said:
“There are simple solutions that would connect the town better. They would enable cyclists to feel safer and not upset motorists.”
She added she would reveal full details of the proposals after tomorrow’s meeting but said they included improvements to the public realm near the train and bus stations, keeping the Station Parade taxi rank where it is and “tidying up” the area around the train station car park.
Cllr Marsh said:
“What we feel we have come up with is a better connected scheme.
“We are not playing politics — that is why we put something forward and offered to do a walk round.”
The Stray Ferret has asked Cllr Duncan to respond to Cllr Marsh’s comments but has not had a response.
Read more:
- Harrogate BID says amended Station Gateway scheme ‘should proceed’
- Major elements of £11.2 million Harrogate Station Gateway scheme to be scrapped
- Council concedes it should have held public inquiry into Harrogate Station Gateway
Petition calls for investigation into leadership of Harrogate district school
A petition calling for an investigation into the leadership of a Harrogate district school has been launched.
North Yorkshire Council has begun moves to close Fountains Earth Primary School in Lofthouse, near Pateley Bridge.
The school has no pupils left and although the council attributes this and a struggle to recruit teachers as key factors in opening a consultation on closure, parents say long-running leadership issues contributed to its decline.
They say pupil numbers were increasing until parents were alienated and poor leadership prompted them to send children elsewhere.
Their petition has already achieved 500 signatures.
Fountains Earth is part of the Upper Nidderdale Federation, which also includes Glasshouses Community Primary School and St Cuthbert’s Church of England Primary School in Pateley Bridge.
Parents previously said they were “devastated to have been left with no choice but to remove our children” and warned closure would “rip the heart” out of Lofthouse.
Now a petition, launched by Ashley Gatehouse, calls for “a full, objective and thorough investigation into the leadership of the Upper Nidderdale Federation”.
It says small rural schools foster community spirit and can deliver high quality education, when managed and governed appropriately.
The petition says:
“This investigation should carefully assess the leadership and management of the Upper Nidderdale Federation, including their academic performance, financial stability, community engagement and communication with parents.
“It is imperative that all relevant stakeholders, including parents and former parents, direct and non-direct contracted staff as well as local residents, have the opportunity to contribute their insights and concerns during this investigation process.
“We request that this matter is taken seriously and that the best interests of our community’s children are prioritised.
The petition concludes by urging the council to halt closure “until a full and thorough investigation has been conducted”.
A ‘heavy and sad decision’
The Stray Ferret asked the Upper Nidderdale Federation if it wished to respond to the parents’ claims.
A statement by co-governors Helen Nelson and Hugh Smith said:
“The autumn term started at Fountains Earth with no pupils on roll.
“Unfortunately, this is not an unprecedented situation in North Yorkshire and the governing body has looked at every possible option for the school to keep going.
“Without children, there will be no future per pupil funding for the school from April 2024.
“Taking everything into account, and having discussed the situation with officers at North Yorkshire Council and the Diocese of Leeds the governors took the heavy and sad decision to ask North Yorkshire Council to begin consultation on a proposal to close Fountains Earth school. This is a formal process led by North Yorkshire Council.”
Read more:
- Angry parents say closure of Lofthouse school will ‘rip heart out of community’
- Lofthouse Moor owner fined for illegally burning peat
Amanda Newbold, the council’s assistant director for education and skills, said:
A59 Kex Gill resurfacing to be complete on Friday“We very much recognise the problems of falling pupil numbers at small rural schools, which is an issue affecting a number of communities in North Yorkshire.
“Sadly, there are currently no children enrolled at Fountain’s Earth CE Primary School in Lofthouse in Nidderdale.
“After a challenging time for all, the school governors have made the difficult decision to begin the formal process of applying to the council for a consultation on proposed plans to close the school.
“The request will be formally considered in November. If a consultation is given the go-ahead, it would be undertaken later this year and include a public meeting.”
Work to resurface a section of road on the A59 Kex Gill is set to be completed on Friday.
North Yorkshire Council closed the road for five weeks to undertake the resurfacing between Church Hill and Pace Gate as part of a £500,000 scheme.
It also involved essential stabilising work to the slope of the existing road as well as drainage repairs, gully-clearing, cat’s eyes replacement and maintenance of ground monitoring equipment
The move has caused a lengthy diversion through Pool in Wharfedale and Otley before rejoining the A59.
Now, a spokesperson for North Yorkshire Council has said the work is on schedule to be completed on Friday (November 10).
The move comes as the council is constructing a new road off the A59 at Kex Gill after a series of landslips.
The Department for Transport is providing grant funding of £56.1 million for the £68.8 million Kex Gill re-alignment project, with the remaining £12.7 million allocated from North Yorkshire Council’s capital reserves.
A new four-kilometre stretch of road will be created, replacing an existing part of the A59 which has been affected by the landslips.
The re-aligned route will leave the A59 at North Moor Road and re-join the existing road at Blubberhouses. It is due to be completed by autumn 2025.
Read more:
- Minister ‘open’ to inflation funding discussions for A59 Kex Gill
- Concern about inflation on £68.8m Kex Gill road scheme
Almost 100-year-old Harrogate sports club to get upgrades
North Yorkshire Council has approved plans by Harrogate Racquets Club to resurface its tennis courts and install new LED floodlights.
The members club on Firs Road was founded in 1924 on the same site and as it approaches its centenary next year, there will be a major upgrade of the facility which offers a place to play tennis, table tennis and badminton.
It includes four tennis courts with artificial grass but planning documents state they have been in use for 14 years and are wearing out.
The foundations under the courts have also “deteriorated significantly” and the fencing needs replacing.
Three of the four courts are floodlit but the lights were installed more than 20 years ago. The plans will see the structure under the courts reinforced, the surface of the courts replaced with new state-of-the-art artificial grass, new fencing installed and floodlights on courts 1-3.
Read more:
- St Aidan’s floodlights raises old concerns over light pollution
- Rooms at closed addiction centre near Harrogate could be let to holiday makers
Plans submitted by St Aidan’s CE High School in 2020 to install new floodlights on its sports pitches proved to be controversial due to the potential for light pollution on neighbouring properties.
Harrogate Racquets Club said it sought expert advice and believes the new lighting will reduce the flare currently emanating from the courts and will meet guidance on obtrusive light.
The club sent letters to neighbouring properties and received six responses, none of which raised concerns about the plans.
It has outreach programmes with local schools including Oatlands Primary and Junior schools, Harrogate Ladies College and Pannal Primary School.
The club also runs coaching programmes with over 200 children participating in the weekly programmes across all three sports during term times as well as easter and summer camps.
It’s situated in a residential cul-de-sac off Leeds Road on the south side of Harrogate, opposite the Oatlands Marks & Spencer supermarket.
The facilities are open every day of the week between 8am and 10pm.
Ripon hornblower ‘calls the watch’ in London for first time in 1,000-year historyRipon’s hornblower “called the watch” over the River Thames last night for the first time in its 1,000-year history.
Allison Clark, who became the city’s first female hornblower in 2017, represented the north’s smallest city on City Cruises’ flagship vessel, Erasmus, as part of the World Travel Market Event – a travel and tourism trade show which takes place at Excel London.
The special dispensation was agreed by Ripon City Council, and the event was jointly hosted by North Yorkshire Council, Visit York, Visit Leeds and Herriot Country Tourism.
North Yorkshire Council’s executive member for the visitor economy, Cllr Derek Bastiman, said:
“The visitor economy is a major contributor to North Yorkshire’s economy, bringing in more than £1.5 billion a year and attracting over 33 million visitors from domestic visits alone to the county.
“I am extremely proud of our heritage and having a hornblower from our area sound the horn over the River Thames for the first time in over a thousand years is quite the honour.”

Allison Clark calls the watch last night. Pic: James Glossop.
Representatives from each local board were invited as part of the All Aboard For Yorkshire initiative, which aimed to showcase the culture and beauty on offer across York and North Yorkshire.
Ms Clark added:
“Along with my three hornblower colleagues, I must have one of the longest-standing, unaltered job descriptions in the world.
“I never imagined when I took the role that I would be on the Thames next to the Tower of London announcing that North Yorkshire is ‘at large’ in London!”
Gemma Rio, head of tourism at North Yorkshire Council, also said the council is “on a mission to broadcast to the global travel industry, to look, and book, ‘up north’”.
North Yorkshire was represented at the World Travel Market by North Yorkshire Council, Herriot Country Tourism and Visit York as part of the UK Inbound stand.
Read more:
- Ripon’s hornblower to ‘call the watch’ in London for first time
- Three independent retailers take space at Halls of Ripon
Valley Gardens bike track — further details revealed
Further details of the proposed new bike track in Harrogate’s Valley Gardens have been revealed.
North Yorkshire Council is running a six-week consultation on whether to replace the nine-hole pitch and putt course with a pump track.
Pump tracks use bumps and bends in the land to allow cyclists and scooter riders to generate momentum.
The consultation says the “new facility would be approximately 2,000 square metres”.
However, the council has now said the track itself wouldn’t be this size, and much of the pitch and putt course would be returned to grassland.
A council spokesperson said the track, which would cost £2,000, is likely to be similar in size to the one in Wetherby, which is shown below and in the main image. It could be open by April.
A council spokesperson said:
“It is a small beginners track that would be made of compacted hardcore.
“It would be 1 to 1.5 metres wide and will be based in a circular shape.
“The pump track is aimed at beginners to complement the existing skate park that attracts older and more competent children.
“It is not going to cover the whole area of the pitch and putt, only a smaller area where holes one to nine are. The frisbee golf is staying.”
Asked what would happen to the remainder of the pitch and putt area, the spokesperson added:
“The whole pitch and putt course would be closed and the remainder would be returned to normal parkland.”
Karl Battersby, the council’s corporate director for environment, previously said:
“The track proposed would have gentle slopes, curves and bumps, be accessible all year, and replace the existing nine-hole pitch and putt golf course.”
Read more:
- Harrogate and Knaresborough Lib Dems criticise homeless tent restriction plan
- New bike track could be in Harrogate’s Valley Gardens by April
Rooms at closed addiction centre near Harrogate could be let to holiday makers
A Christian charity that runs training for people recovering from drug and alcohol addiction near Harrogate could offer bedrooms at one of its sites to holiday makers.
Horizon Life Training provides residential training facilities to people who have already been through addiction rehab centres, teaching them life and employment skills.
The charity runs a men’s centre at Kennel Hall Farm in Killinghall and a women’s centre at Bramall House on Skipton Road, which was formerly the Black Bull pub and is close to RAF Menwith Hill.
During the covid pandemic, the centres closed for new intakes, which the charity said has let to a “break in the supply” for suitable applicants for the training.
As a result, all of its activity is now taking place at the Killinghall centre, leaving nine bedrooms and a flat at Bramall House currently unused.
In plans submitted to North Yorkshire Council, the charity said it does not want the building to remain empty so it’s asking the council to approve a temporary change of use application so it could be used for holiday lets.
It also said the move would bring in much-needed income for the charity. It said the move may be necessary for up to two years before it can reopen the centre for recovery training.
Planning documents state that contractors working on the Kex Gill A59 new road scheme could potentially rent rooms at the site.
They add:
“The charity still bears the sizeable fixed costs of operating the building, placing its own financial continuance at risk.
“This proposal would ensure the use of the building in a constructive manner during a period when it would otherwise be empty. It will provide much needed accommodation for those who will use it and an income to facilitate the upkeep of the building for Horizon Life Training.”
Read more:
- Kingsley Drive developer to pay £1m towards Harrogate schools
- Fresh plan to convert pub near Pateley Bridge into a cottage
Knaresborough bridge to close tonight for nighttime resurfacing
High Bridge in Knaresborough will be closed to nighttime traffic for the next 11 days from this evening due to resurfacing.
North Yorkshire Council posted on X, formerly known as Twitter, today that the closure will be in effect from 7pm until midnight daily until Friday, November 17.
It added a “fully signposted diversion” will be in place.
The grade two listed bridge over the River Nidd, which passes Mother Shipton’s Cave, is the main route into Knaresborough from the Starbeck direction.
Councillor Matt Walker, a Liberal Democrat who represents Knaresborough West, said it was a standard resurfacing project and he wasn’t aware of any concerns.
But he added:
“What the council haven’t done is put new lights over the bridge yet.
“This funding was put in place prior to us being elected and we keep getting a push back on when it will happen.”
Read more:
- Gothic dancers from Knaresborough seek recruits
- MP rejects company’s offer of Knaresborough asphalt plant discussions