A Ripon councillor has suggested there is little for tourists to do in Harrogate after visiting the famous tearooms Bettys.
Andrew Williams, independent councillor for Ripon Minster and Moorside on North Yorkshire County Council, was speaking at the final Skipton and Ripon area constituency committee meeting before the new North Yorkshire Council is formed on April 1.
He referred to the sometimes thorny relationship between Harrogate and Ripon and said reorganisation was a chance for the city to be presented in a different way to tourists.
Ripon is currently marketed as a tourist destination within Destination Harrogate — Harrogate Borough Council’s destination management organisation.
But Destination Harrogate’s future is unclear as the new council looks to set up a county-wide tourism strategy instead.
Cllr Williams was critical of how Ripon has positioned within Destination Harrogate. He said:
“[We need to] remove the idea that Ripon is somehow linked to Destination Harrogate. It should be Destination Ripon.
“We are two very distinct localities. We don’t want to be marketed as a day trip from Harrogate. We’re far more than a day trip from Harrogate.”
“Once you’ve been to Bettys you’ve done Harrogate, quite frankly.”
‘Rose-tinted view’
Officers spoke to councillors about the economic opportunities in Ripon, which included a presentation on how the city’s economy has performed since covid.
Dave Caulfield, who will be assistant director economic development at the new council, said tourism was crucial to Ripon’s economy and the city’s offer would form part of a new tourism strategy that is being developed for North Yorkshire.
But Cllr Williams said the report presented a “rose-tinted view” of Ripon. He called on the new council to “listen to local people in Ripon and work with them rather than ignoring them”.
In response, Mr Caulfield said:
“It’s important we do listen as a new council. We want to look at opportunities to do things better when we can.”
There were also warms words for Ripon from David Staveley, Conservative councillor for Settle and Penyghent.
He told Cllr Williams:
‘An absolute nonsense’: Ripon’s £85,000 regeneration plan thrown into doubt“You are stepping out of the shadow of Harrogate and you will be equal partners here. Ripon has an awful lot to offer.”
A Ripon councillor has strongly criticised Harrogate Borough Council after an officer confirmed a report costing £85,000 that was supposed to present a new vision for Ripon city centre remains unfinished — over two-and-a-half years since it was first announced.
At a meeting of the Skipton and Ripon area constituency committee yesterday in Skipton, officers at North Yorkshire County Council and Harrogate Borough Council spoke to councillors about the economic opportunities for Ripon ahead of the new council forming on April 1.
But it was the current status of the Ripon Renewal Project masterplan that Ripon councillors Andrew Williams and Barbara Brodigan were seeking answers to.
Harrogate Borough Council awarded a contract to Bauman Lyons Architects in 2020 to draw up a vision for the future of the city.
The company was tasked with producing funding options and a business case for Ripon to bid for money for regeneration projects.
A consultation was held in 2021 when residents, businesses and community groups highlighted problems in the city. These included not enough things for young people to do, traffic in the market place and a lack of affordable housing.
However, publication of the document has been beset by delays, which led Cllr Brodigan to accuse the council of letting it “gather dust” at an office in Harrogate.
Ripon City Council and Ripon BID have submitted freedom of information requests to HBC in an attempt to find out what has been produced.
The project is being co-funded by North Yorkshire County Council and the York and North Yorkshire Local Enterprise Partnership.
‘No draft masterplan’
The borough council’s acting head of place-shaping and economic growth Linda Marfitt told councillors the project was initially delayed due to the consultation exercises taking longer than expected.
She said the council then tried to extend the contract with the architect but were not able to come to an agreement so had to “bring the commission to a close”.
Read more:
- Harrogate council spends £45,000 on outside help for failed Levelling Up bid
- Harrogate council pays out almost £20,000 in compensation to tenants due to damp
- Ripon regeneration plans ‘paused’ amid contract talks
Ms Marfitt said despite the council not being in possession of a draft masterplan, officers have looked at what work has been done so far and will present a summary to councillors next week.
She added around £55,000 of the £85,000 that was earmarked had been spent.
Ms Marfitt said:
“It isn’t something that sits on a shelf, we’re proactively moving it forward. We’re working with the new council to see what can be done. There will be an update next week. I do apologise for the elongated time frame but we were trying to get a successful outcome.”
It was a response that exacerbated Andrew Williams, independent councillor for Ripon Minster & Moorside and the leader of Ripon City Council.
He said:
“It’s astonishing that we’ve spent £85,000 of public money to get nothing, not even a draft executive summary from a consultant — that’s how bad this is.
“A lot of time has spent on this by organisations in the city but it’s fallen off a cliff-edge. It’s an absolute nonsense.”
A spokesperson for Bauman Lyons Architects issued the following statement:
Old Deanery calls for Ripon Cathedral’s £6m scheme to be rejected“Following a positive and helpful period of community and stakeholder engagement, the initial stages of the project took longer than envisaged. This meant it was necessary for the council and Bauman Lyons Architects to enter into discussions about a new contract to complete the work.
“An agreement on the terms could not be reached and the commission has now come to a close.”
Ripon Cathedral‘s proposed £6 million building poses a threat to the future of the Old Deanery and should not be approved, it has been claimed.
The cathedral has submitted a planning application to Harrogate Borough Council to create an annex that would include a song school, refectory, retail unit and toilets on Minster Gardens.
The nearby Old Deanery is governed by the Chapter of Ripon Cathedral, which agreed a 20-year lease on the property to Layton Hills Hotels in 2021.
Layton Hills Hotels now holds events at the Old Deanery and plans to re-open it as a hotel and restaurant.

The Old Deanery is just metres from the cathedral.
Now LCF Law, which has offices in Harrogate and is acting on behalf of Layton Hills Hotels, has written to the council claiming the proposal threatens the future of the business.
LCF Law also questions why the Old Deanery does not appear to have been assessed as a site for the new development because, it says, the building has the space and facilities to accommodate such a scheme.
Masterplan
The law firm also claims that since signing the lease, Layton Hills Hotel has seen a masterplan developed by the cathedral six years ago that includes “not only the current development but also hotel and housing on land close by, including in the garden of the Old Deanery on land comprised within the leased area”.
It adds:
“However, in discussions for the lease for the Old Deanery, no mention was made to Layton Hills Hotel about any of these commercial proposals which, if permitted, would be in direct competition with the Old Deanery.
“This is somewhat surprising, not least because the Old Deanery, a grade 2* listed building, would have been available for use by the Chapter to satisfy the alleged need for additional space and facilities.”

The Old Deanery currently caters for events, such as weddings. Photo: Tim Hardy
The letter goes on to say the leaseholders are concerned about what impact drinks receptions and evening events at the new cathedral building might have on the Old Deanery. It adds:
“If Layton Hills Hotel had been notified by the Chapter about its future plans, including the possibility of the development of an events’ venue in direct competition with its business and immediately adjoining it, then it is unlikely that it would have entered into the lease of the Old Deanery as its future is directly threatened by it.
“Layton Hills Hotel are concerned that the proposal may be used for commercial ventures which go above and beyond a visitor facility for the cathedral and will be used to hold events in direct competition to the operation of the Old Deanery.”
LCF Law’s letter also raises wider concerns about the planning application, including the loss of trees in Minster Gardens.
It concludes:
“The proposal will cause significant harm notably through the loss of trees, the loss of open space and the adverse impact it will have on the setting of four listed buildings of great importance.
“It is therefore contrary to both local and national planning policy. It should therefore be refused without an exceptional justification with public benefit at its heart which has not been provided.
“There has been no convincing justification for why the uses must be combined in a single building of such scale.”

Ripon Cathedral says the new building will attract more visitors to the city.
The Stray Ferret asked the cathedral for a response to LCF Law’s letter. A cathedral spokesperson said it didn’t feel it was appropriate to comment on individual responses while the planning process took place.
However, a cathedral website about the project says:
“The proposed new building will provide key facilities to ensure it can continue to play its role in the life of the city, diocese (of Leeds) and region and enable it to host more events, exhibitions, and concerts, which will attract increased numbers of people to the city, to the benefit of all.
“We understand people’s concerns around the removal of 11 trees, but the building will deliver a range of much needed facilities for the people of Ripon and visitors, along with the cathedral community, and the loss of these trees will be offset by the planting of 300 trees at Studley Royal where land has been made available to us.
“Extra storage space will mean that the cathedral will be able to declutter its internal space, which will enable historic parts of the cathedral, currently not viewed, to be accessible to the public.
“There will be an increase in the conservation area and biodiversity of the cathedral estate.”
Zoë Metcalfe confirms bid to become North Yorkshire’s first mayor
Zoë Metcalfe has confirmed she wants to stand as the Conservative candidate in next year’s York and North Yorkshire mayoral election.
Ms Metcalfe, who lives near Boroughbridge, is the current North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner.
The Stray Ferret reported on Saturday that she was believed to be planning a bid for election.
Ms Metcalfe is the first person to formally declare an intention to stand for the role of mayor, which is being created as part of the North Yorkshire devolution process. The election will be held in 14 months’ time.
The mayor will oversee a significant budget for York and North Yorkshire covering areas such as transport, education and housing.
He or she will also swallow up the commissioner’s role currently occupied by Ms Metcalfe, who was born in Ripon, educated in Harrogate and lives in Aldborough.

Speaking to the media
In a statement issued last night, she said she was “uniquely qualified” for the role and had the “necessary business experience and close links to Westminster to promote economic growth”,
Ms Metcalfe is a former Harrogate borough councillor who was elected to the commissioner’s role in 2021 following the resignation of fellow Conservative Philip Allott.
Since taking up the role on a salary of £74,000, she has overseen the introduction of a Risk and Resource Model for North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service, which sets out how resources will be deployed from 2022 to 2025.
The changes included reducing Harrogate Fire Station’s nighttime cover from two fire engines to one.
‘Close links to Westminster’
Ms Metcalfe’s statement in full said:
“This is a really exciting role that I am uniquely qualified to do.
“The mayor will have responsibility for economic growth, transport, housing and regeneration, but will also see the integration of the responsibilities and decision making of my current role as Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner within it too.
“There is a rich synergy between creating safer streets and economic growth, two areas that I am passionate about.
“I have the necessary business experience and close links to Westminster to promote economic growth. I will also continue the great work I have started in turning around community safety in York and North Yorkshire and I will see through the transformation of both the police force and fire and rescue service.
“I have always been a supporter of devolution as it will bring many exciting opportunities for York and North Yorkshire, it will be a great platform to enable and enrich the lives of our residents and businesses bringing hundreds of millions of pounds worth of investment into our region”.
Read more:
- Is crime commissioner Zoe Metcalfe aiming to be North Yorkshire’s first mayor?
- Crime commissioner Zoë Metcalfe resigns from Harrogate Borough Council
Vandalism prompts closure of Ripon playground
Quarry Moor playground in Ripon has closed to the public after vandals damaged equipment and daubed graffiti.
Ripon City Council, which manages the site, said on social media it had taken the decision today “for safety reasons”.
It added:
“Unfortunately the site has been vandalised, we’ve been left with damaged equipment and really unpleasant graffiti written on site.
“We are seeking quotes for repair and will provide an update on when the repairs will be undertaken when we can.”

Signs have been put up announcing the closure.
The 24-acre Quarry Moor limestone grassland was donated by Alderman Thomas F Spence in 1945, and held in trust for the benefit of the people of Ripon.
It was designated a site of special scientific interest in 1986.
The playground previously closed for six months from September 2021 due to rats.
Read more:
- Demolition completed of subsidence-hit Ripon flats
- Heritage watchdogs disagree over £6m Ripon Cathedral annex
Demolition completed of subsidence-hit Ripon flats
The demolition of a block of four empty Ripon homes stricken by subsidence issues has been completed by a team of experts.
The properties at 1, 3 and 5 Bedern Court and 17 Skellgarths were evacuated in October 2020 after being declared unsafe for habitation.

The block was fenced off ready for the start of demolition in early February
Planning permission for their demolition was granted by Harrogate Borough Council in November and Dewsbury-based Hutchinson Demolition & Dismantling Ltd carried out a fortnight of preparatory work before starting to take the block down in early February.
Following successful completion of the task, site manager Ashley Hutchinson, told the Stray Ferret:
“Apart from a couple of days when we couldn’t work because of Storm Otto, everything has run smoothly and to schedule.”

A cherry picker was used so that the demolition team could remove the roof tiles and timbers and demolish the chimney stacks.
Mr Hutchinson added:
“The work was carried out by our team using hand-held tools for the majority of the demolition tasks, with a rubber tracked excavator brought in for the latter stages.”
With the demolition works complete, the final clear up of the site will be carried out over the next couple of days.
Roof tiles, bricks, timber and other materials have been removed for recycling.
Read more:
- Ripon Theatre Festival organisers reveal plans for this year’s event
- Plans approved to convert Ripon office block into flats
Plan to convert Ripon office block into 16 flats approved
A plan to convert the Athelstan Court office block in Ripon into 16 flats has been approved.
Site owners Athelstan Court Ltd proposed the scheme to convert the building, which has stood empty for 10 years.
The building on Kearsley Road lies within the College Business Park. It was previously used as offices by the Inland Revenue.
Now, Harrogate Borough Council has approved the scheme.
Read more:
- New Harrogate district housing plan should not be ‘tickbox exercise’, says councillor
- Knaresborough housing site should be reviewed under local plan, says councillor
The developer said the proposal to convert the site into housing would regenerate the current building.
It said:
Is crime commissioner Zoe Metcalfe aiming to be North Yorkshire’s first mayor?“It is considered that the proposal would complement the area, and significantly enhance the character and visual amenities of the surrounding area, by regenerating a vacant building.”
Zoe Metcalfe, the North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner, is hoping to stand for election to become the county’s first mayor, the Stray Ferret understands.
A Conservative Party source has told the Stray Ferret that Ms Metcalfe had indicated she planned to launch a bid for the party’s nomination for next year’s mayoral election.
The mayor will oversee a significant budget for York and North Yorkshire and have the power to allocate funds to areas such as transport, education and housing.
He or she will also swallow up the commissioner’s role currently occupied by Ms Metcalfe.
Ms Metcalfe has strong local connections: she was born in Ripon, educated in Harrogate and lives near Boroughbridge.
A former Harrogate borough councillor, she was elected to her commissioner’s role in 2021 with 39.5% of the vote in a by-election caused by the resignation of fellow Conservative Philip Allott following comments he made about the murder of Sarah Everard.
Since taking up the role on a salary of £74,000, she has overseen the introduction of a Risk and Resource Model for North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service, which sets out how resources will be deployed from 2022 to 2025.
The changes included reducing Harrogate Fire Station’s nighttime cover from two fire engines to one.
The commissioner’s role gives Ms Metcalfe a countywide profile that could enhance her prospects of winning the Conservative nomination for mayor — a new role being created as part of North Yorkshire devolution.
The Stray Ferret contacted the crime commissioner’s office asking whether Ms Metcalfe planned to stand but did not receive a response.
Read more:
- Knaresborough’s Zoe Metcalfe pledges to be ‘people’s commissioner’ in £74,000 crime role
- Long-awaited £1.2m refurbishment of Ripon’s police and fire station confirmed
Harrogate district CCTV control room not manned due to staff shortages
A control room monitoring more than 200 CCTV cameras in the Harrogate district has not been manned at times over the last year due to staff shortages.
The control room, run by Harrogate Borough Council, oversees cameras operating 24 hours a day in Harrogate, Ripon and Knaresborough.
Control room staff are able to respond to police reports and track suspicious activity. Police can buy the footage to use as evidence in pursuing crimes.
Julia Stack, community safety and CCTV manager at the council, was asked by Councillor Victoria Oldham at a meeting of the council’s overview and scrutiny commission this week whether the room needed to be staffed.
Ms Stack replied the priority was to “man that service for 24 hours a day”, adding:
“I will be honest,. We have had some challenging issues in terms of recruitment within the last 12 months so there have been times when we have been unable to have the staff there but the cameras will be recording.”
Ms Stack added the team was now “almost at full complement of staff”.
Cllr Oldham, a Conservative who represents Washburn, replied:
“I’m aware of two incidents last week when it wasn’t manned and one of them could have been very embarrassing.”

Julia Stack speaking at the meeting
Ms Stack said the service worked closely with police but added:
“There’s always the risk we may be dealing with one location and there may be something happening in another one. That is down unfortunately to consistent funding cuts to the service.”
The long-term future of the service when Harrogate Borough Council is abolished at the end of this month and North Yorkshire Council takes over is unclear.
Scarborough and Northallerton also have CCTV control rooms in the county and Ms Stack the service overall was inconsistent and would be reviewed.

Cllr Windass speaking at the meeting
Councillor Robert Windass, a Conservative who represents Boroughbridge, said Boroughbridge had been “kicked out” of Harrogate Borough Council’s CCTV monitoring system years ago.
Cllr Windass said Boroughbridge Town Council now provided CCTV and, unlike Harrogate Borough Council, did not charge the police for accessing it. He said:
“If the police request footage for any crimes there is absolutely no charge because we consider it a valuable service we should provide and support to the police.”
Cllr Mike Chambers, the Conservative Cabinet member for housing and safer communities, replied:
“I agree it is a service that is valuable to the police. But we have a control room that has staff. If we don’t levy charges as many other departments within this council do then how do we pay for the staff?”

CCTV overlooking Harrogate’s Royal Hall
‘Limited resources’
After the meeting, the Stray Ferret asked Harrogate Borough Council about the control room staff situation and what will happen to the service when the council is abolished in four weeks.
A council spokesperson said:
New names revealed for top hotels in Harrogate and Ripon“Our CCTV control room is in Harrogate and has five operators and one CCTV and business crime operations officer, as well as a small pool of casual staff who work alongside full-time officers, who are responsible for surveillance of cameras covering Knaresborough, Harrogate, Ripon and council buildings.
“They also undertake reviews and produce evidence for the police and other third parties, operate a RadioLink service and support a business crime partnership.
“Like ourselves, North Yorkshire Police have limited resources and even if the control room report an incident to the police, there is no guarantee that they are always in a position to respond straight away. Therefore, we ensure cameras record 24-hours a day, 365 days a year so that our staff can aim to get the best evidence to assist with any incidents.
“Closures are kept to a minimum and shifts are extended with staff work overtime to ensure sufficient support for the CCTV control room.
“In recent months, we have seen a limited number of applicants to the roles available. And once appointed, each post is subject to police vetting which takes times to be thoroughly carried out, followed by a two-month training period.
“However, we can confirm that two new appointments have recently been made.
“From 1 April there will be no change to the service.”
The owners of the St George Hotel in Harrogate and the Spa Hotel in Ripon have confirmed the venues will be given new names and branding.
The properties, which are being refurbished, will be renamed The Harrogate Inn and The Ripon Inn.
The Harrogate Inn is due to re-open in early summer with 96 rooms — six more than previously. The Ripon Inn is expected to reopen in midsummer with 58 rooms — 15 more than previously.

The Harrogate Inn
The two hotels have also been given new coats of arms.
The new identities reflect the brand style of owners the Inn Collection Group, a Newcastle-based company that has historic venues across the north.
Inn Collection Group venues serve food and drink all day and are styled as pubs with rooms rather than hotels.
Its other venues include Knaresborough’s Dower House, which has been renamed The Knaresborough Inn.
Zoe Cooper, marketing manager for the Inn Collection Group, said:
“As with the new names we have unveiled for other sites recently, including The Knaresborough Inn, we have looked to embrace the history of the wider area and we hope the new look will create a talking point that serves as a link to the past while the site embarks on an exciting future.
“With both sites we have adopted the name of the locale for the property, which allows us to introduce its setting more easily for potential visitors who may be considering a stay, allowing them to look further into what all these fantastic places have to offer.”

The Ripon Inn
The refurbished guest accommodation at The Ripon Inn will provide a mix of double, twin and family bedrooms, accessible rooms, suites, and dog friendly rooms.
It will have an additional 15 en-suite rooms and the reconfigurated ground floor area will include a new bar and kitchen area.
The Harrogate Inn will see six new bedrooms added on the ground floor and a “complete transformation of the venue’s hospitality spaces”, according to the owners.
Coats of arms
The Ripon Inn, set in six acres of gardens, has been closed to guests since July 2020 for extensive internal and external works.
Its new coat of arms is made up of a shield flanked by a pair of stags, linking to the historical coat of arms of the Earl and Marquess or Ripon.
The left half of the shield contains a representation of the Ripon horn in recognition of the history of the city’s wakemen and hornblowers.
Sitting on a red background — a colour scheme and motif that appear in the city’s coat of arms – this is combined with a yellow chevron which is again informed by the Earl and Marquess of Ripon’s heraldry.
The right-hand side of the shield features a stylised illustration of the grade one listed Ripon Cathedral and its early English gothic west front, dating back to 1220 and regarded as one of the best examples of its type.
The Harrogate Inn closed in January for a 16-week refurbishment.
Its coat of arms sees the left half of the shield contain a red and white asymmetrical crossed pattern taken from the town’s original coat of arms, together with the white rose of Yorkshire.
The right-hand side of the shield features a lion ‘passant’ taken from the borough council’s arms, and this is bounded top and bottom by repeating wavy lines to represent the importance of springs in the town’s history.
Supporting the shield are a pair of griffins taken from the crest of the Slingsby family, who were instrumental in bringing prosperity to the town through Sir William Slingsby and his discovered of the first spring in Harrogate, the Tewitt Well, over three hundred years ago.
Read more:
- Harrogate hotel begins recruiting — three weeks after laying off 76 staff
- New name and coat of arms for Knaresborough hotel
- Stray Views: Memories of Harrogate’s St George Hotel