Stray Views: Harrogate’s Otley Road cycle path benefits neither walkers nor cyclists

Stray Views is a weekly column giving you the chance to have your say on issues affecting the Harrogate district. It is an opinion column and does not reflect the views of the Stray Ferret. Send your views to letters@thestrayferret.co.uk.

Otley Road cycle path benefits nobody

There has been much debate concerning cycle paths in Harrogate with Otley Road being the prime example.

It has been known from the outset that this was not a segregated path like in European cities, rather mainly just shared pavement. However some people are only just realising this.

At side roads there is some segregated cycle path, with the cars set back, blocking the pedestrians who wish to cross. A bus shelter removed, grass removed, more tarmac with 36 new metal signs and 32 painted white cycles on the tarmac over 600m of highway. An attractive entrance into Harrogate now full of street furniture.

At Harlow Moor Road, the grass has gone, trees felled (mainly but not solely for the road users) and the pavement much narrowed, but no decrease in traffic. The junction is much worse for pedestrians, squeezed up next to the road, no grass verge between car and pedestrian.

Government guidelines for good cycle infrastructure design say:

“Cycles must be treated as vehicles and not as pedestrians. On urban streets, cyclists must be physically separated from pedestrians and should not share space with pedestrians”.

The Otley Road cycle path totally disregards this and other aspects of the guidelines. This cycle path is sub-standard; it benefits no-one, not cyclists, not pedestrians, not residents, anything but an example of good design.

I have been criticised by cycling lobbyists for advocating infrastructure that meets modern standards. Being an Otley Road resident, I observe at first hand, much more than the cycling groups or North Yorkshire County Council in Northallerton, what happens on this road. I have much more contact with local residents; the overwhelming opinion, regarding what has happened to our local environment is not favourable.

Everything done by NYCC penalises pedestrians. Pedestrians do not like sharing pavements with cycles passing close by, often unheard. Segregated cycle paths, benefit both the cyclist and the pedestrian. So for a better sustainable transport system, we need much more involvement of local people and wider engagement – why does NYCC exclude residents?

We need this involvement to be fair to all and to get some consensus into this subject. We need to involve other means of transport, e.g. improvements in bus services, park and ride, improvements for pedestrians.

The nature of the existing built environment and maintaining a green environment in a floral town needs to be taken into account too. I fear otherwise Harrogate will only be changed for the worse not the better.

Chris Dicken, Otley Road, Harrogate

Read more:

Many people in Knaresborough welcome the new pool

Can I just offer an opinion on the contribution entitled ‘Harrogate is riding roughshod over Knaresborough with this unwanted new pool’

As a resident of Knaresborough, can I just say this certainly doesn’t reflect my views so please don’t let this person suggest they speak on my behalf.

I think the new centre is a brilliant idea. We need to get provision into the 21st century. So if this person still wants to wallow in the past, great, but don’t drag the rest of us down with them !

Ian Brown, Knaresborough

Ghosts on the Stray

Me and my husband saw a cult like gathering on The Stray playing bongo drums in the corner where the stone shelter is. It was so creepy and now we have seen that someone else thinks that The Stray is haunted we have come forward.

Carol Moore, Harrogate