Harrogate council paid £45,000 in Kirby Hill and Ripon service station legal fees

Harrogate Borough Council paid more than £45,000 in legal fees to defend a decision to refuse a controversial service station near Kirby Hill.

According to the council’s own public record of expenses, the authority paid Stephen Whale QC £45,491 in counsel fees for the inquiry.

The figures show the council made three payments of £43,000, £750 and £1,741 between January and March this year.

Harrogate Borough Council said the fees also included a successful defence of a decision to refuse a proposal for a service station on the A1(M) near Ripon at the same hearing.

The Stray Ferret asked the council whether the sum was the total paid to Mr Whale and if it wished to comment on the fees.

A council spokesman said:

“The legal fees for Stephen Whale QC were for two appeals; Kirby Hill and Melmerby. The latter was successfully defended by the council following its decision to refuse.

“When an appeal is to be heard at a public inquiry, it is appropriate and expected for a local authority to make use of highly rated and specialist legal counsel to run its case.”

Read more:

Mr Whale, of London-based Landmark Chambers, appeared at the hearing in February.

The hearing lasted two weeks and included multiple testimonies to defend the council’s refusal of the proposal. 

But it resulted in the service station between junction 48 and 49 on the A1(M) northbound being approved after 25 years of public inquiries and planning battles.

However, a separate appeal from Moto Hospitality Ltd for a motorway service station on the A1 near Ripon at junction 50 was rejected.

David Rose, the government’s planning inspector who oversaw the inquiry, said the benefits of the service station near Kirby Hill would outweigh the harm.

Campaigners call for review

Since the approval, campaigners in Kirby Hill have called on the government to review the inspector’s decision.

They have questioned one of the policies used in the inspector’s report to approve the site, which says that the distance between motorway service areas should be “no more than 28 miles, but it can be shorter”.

Gareth Owens, chair of Kirby Hill Residents Against Motorway Services, said the decision made in April “does not make sense”.

Mr Owens said the policy “appears to have been plucked out of thin air” and called for a review of the decision.

He told the Stray Ferret earlier this week:

“The government should admit that it made a mistake in approving the Vale of York motorway services and should announce a review of this controversial decision.”

Harrogate district covid rate reaches four-month high

The Harrogate district’s seven-day covid rate of infection has surpassed 100 per 100,000 people for the first time in four months.

Currently, the average stands at 103 — the first time since February 10 that it has been as high.

Elsewhere, the North Yorkshire rate is 93 and the England average is 112.

A further 39 covid cases have been confirmed in the Harrogate district today.

Read more:

According to Public Health England figures, it takes the total number of infections since last March to 8,170.

The figure is another four-month high for daily cases in the district, with the last highest reported on February 1, when 51 were recorded.

However, no covid-related deaths have been confirmed at Harrogate District Hospital since April 11.

The death toll at the hospital since the pandemic started remains at 179.

Police issue knife warning in Harrogate district schools

Police are urging parents to have “difficult conversations” with children after a spate of knife incidents in Harrogate district schools.

North Yorkshire Police said it was aware of five incidents of knives being brought into schools since September.

They include children flashing knives in the playground to other students.

Boys and girls had both been involved.

Officers said that, while the number of cases were high, no pupils or staff had been harmed or threatened.

Read more:

Police Constable Colin Steele, from Harrogate neighbourhood policing team said:

“Not only are young people risking their life, and the lives of other students and teaching staff by carrying a knife, they are also showing a disregard for their own futures. 

“Carrying a knife on school premises is a serious offence and a conviction for such an offence can stay with you for life. 

“I encourage the parents and guardians of young people to have what can be a difficult conversation with their children around the dangers of carrying knives and the real implications this can have on their child’s future.”

The police praised teaching staff for identifying children carrying knives at school.

First events at Harrogate Convention Centre to be government pilot

The first events in over a year at Harrogate Convention Centre will have no social distancing after being selected for a government pilot.

Organisers of The Home and Gift Buyers’ Festival and the Manchester Furniture Show 2021 confirmed the news after discussions with the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport.

Restrictions on the number of visitors will be lifted and social distancing requirements scrapped at the events, which are being held from July 18 to July 21.

However, visitors will be required to show proof of two vaccinations at least two weeks prior to attending or a negative NHS lateral flow test at least 48 hours before the event.

Read more:

The event comes as part of a limited number of pilots being held in the third phase of the government’s Events Research Programme, which examines the risk of covid transmission at events

Russell Rule, director of The Home and Gift Buyers’ Festival , said:

“With the backing of the government, public health bodies, and our key customers we can see that the appetite and enthusiasm are there for an in-person buying and selling event. 

“There is great excitement from both exhibitors and visitors to reconnect in Harrogate to celebrate our 60th anniversary.”

The convention centre is still waiting to get back to normality following the delay in lifting the final covid restrictions.

The pilot will be used to gather data and research how small and large scale events could be permitted in line with the government’s roadmap out of lockdown.

Nigel Huddleston, tourism minister, said the business and events industry was worth around £40 billion annually to the UK economy and he was delighted the events would be held at full capacity. He added:

“This will continue to trial the use of the NHS app as a means to show you’re covid safe.”

19 Afghans get homes in Harrogate district in resettlement scheme

A senior Harrogate borough councillor has said the district will be prepared to rehome more Afghan families after the authority agreed to take part in a resettlement scheme.

Up to four families totalling 19 people will be flown to the district in the coming months as fears for their safety grows, with international troops preparing to leave the country.

On the flight will be mostly former translators, their families and others whose lives are under threat because they worked for the British government during the two decades that the UK military has been fighting in Afghanistan.

A decision to welcome the families was agreed by Harrogate Borough Council’s cabinet last night when Madeleine Bell, head of housing and property, said the authority had asked to take part in the relocation scheme which is now being accelerated as the security situation in Afghanistan worsens.

She said:

“Since 2013 the government has had a programme of resettling locally employed Afghans who have worked with British armed forces.

‘Due to changes in the international presence in Afghanistan, this programme has now been accelerated and it has become urgent that Afghans who have worked with our armed forces together with their families are brought to this country for their own safety.

“We have asked to be part of this scheme and have provisionally agreed to accept three or four families, although of course we stand ready to accept larger numbers if we are asked to do so.”

The Harrogate district has previously taken part in other resettlement programmes, including welcoming 13 Syrian families between 2016 and 2017.

Read more:

Cllr Mike Chambers, cabinet member for housing and safer communities at the council, said the families are not only offered a place to live, but also given opportunities to go to school, learn English and find employment.

He added that the authority would be prepared to resettle more families if it was required to do so.

‘We will take more if necessary’

Cllr Chambers said:

“This district has a long and proud history of taking in people who are in need, people who are in distress and people who need shelter.

“It is clear that we need to play a part in ensuring that these people are brought to a place of safety and given every opportunity to move on.

“We initially looked to take about 19 people in total and should we be required to take further, then we will do so, because this is what we do in this district. We are known as places of sanctuary. My own city of Ripon is a city of sanctuary.

“It means a great deal to people that we show compassion and care, and that we play our part in ensuring these people are given every opportunity to live in a place of safety.”

Nationally, more than 3,000 Afghans are expected to be allowed to settle in the UK, joining 1,300 who have already done so.

A large number of translators were not eligible under a previous relocation scheme, which considered an applicant’s role and length of service.

But now any current or former locally-employed staff deemed to be under serious threat will be offered priority, regardless of their employment status, role, rank or length of service.

Announcing the acceleration of the scheme last month, Defence Secretary Ben Wallace said:

“As we withdraw our armed forces, it is only right we accelerate the relocation of those who may be at risk of reprisals. Nobody’s life should be put at risk because they supported the UK government to promote peace and stability in Afghanistan.”

Harrogate district records 38 more covid cases

The Harrogate district today recorded another daily high of covid cases, as 38 infections were reported.

According to Public Health England figures, the number takes the total cases since last March to 8,131.

The figure is the highest since February 1, when 51 cases were recorded.

No further deaths from patients who tested positive for covid have been reported at Harrogate District Hospital.

Read more:

NHS England figures show the last death was reported in April and the total number of covid-related deaths since the start of the pandemic remains at 179.

Harrogate hospital is currently treating three covid patients, according to the Local Democracy Reporting Service.

Meanwhile, the district’s seven-day covid rate stands at 96 cases per 100,000 people.

The North Yorkshire average is 86 and the England rate stands at 105.

UCI World Championships caused ‘major disruption’ in Harrogate, says report

A new report into the UCI Road World Championships 2019 has said the event inspired people to cycle more — but had a ‘major disruptive impact on the community in Harrogate’.

The study commissioned jointly by British Cycling, Sport England and UK Sport found that 45% of those surveyed said they would take up cycling or cycle more after watching the event.

The 11-day event in September 2019 received a hostile response from many local businesses because road closures hampered trade. The event also caused £130,000 worth of damage to the West Park Stray.

The report, compiled by the Sport Industry Research Centre at Sheffield Hallam University, covers awareness of the event, its perceived impacts, and the extent to which it influenced changes in physical wellbeing, mental wellbeing, individual and community development.

It found that:

But the report adds:

“There were also some negative consequences of the Road World Championships expressed by host community residents surveyed, particularly in Harrogate, where respondents were critical of the inconvenience and disruption due to the prolonged road closures compared with other host locations such as Doncaster and Leeds.

“Another sticking point in Harrogate was the damage caused to a section of the Stray – a protected public area of green space – where the Championship Fan Zone was located.

“The event was seen to have had a major disruptive impact on the community in Harrogate, which is illustrated starkly by Harrogate Borough Council’s decision to refrain temporarily from hosting major events of this scale.”

Read more:

Cllr Stanley Lumley, Harrogate Borough Council’s cabinet member for culture, tourism and sport, said the report showed the UCI Road World Championships had inspired people to get more involved in sport.

He added:

“It is inevitable that hosting an international event of this scale can cause some disruption on day-to-day life.

“But the global television audience has no doubt left a lasting impression on what Yorkshire and specifically the Harrogate district has to offer. This will no doubt encourage a number of visits in the future which our tourist economy so desperately needs.

“It was also positive to read that the volunteering opportunities the event created has had a lasting impression on those involved.”

Rod Findlay, British Cycling’s business services director, said:

“The 2019 UCI Road World Championships in Yorkshire was a truly momentous celebration of cycling, and from the report published today it’s clear that the legacy of those nine days of racing will be felt for many years to come.”

Review into UCI

Last week, a public survey into the UCI championships, which were held in Harrogate, closed.

Harrogate Borough Council’s overview and scrutiny committee set up the review to build on “its successes and identifying any areas for improvement to inform the organisation of future events”.

However, questions were raised over why the committee decided to hold a review on the UCI two years after the event.

Plans to convert Ripon garages into homes approved

Plans to build three council houses at the sites of two disused garage blocks in Ripon have been approved.

Harrogate Borough Council’s housing team will build the properties at North Road and Church Close where many of the council-owned garages have sat empty for years and the majority are currently not in use.

The council said the plans would help tackle the desperate need for affordable homes in the district, although some residents raised concerns over the impact on the nearby roads.

At North Road, a garage block will be converted into a three-bedroom bungalow but nearby resident Christine Shepherd said she was worried about what the development would mean for traffic in the area.

Speaking at a meeting today, she said: 

“Parking for the proposed building is opposite my gate where my disabled access is. It is a narrow part of road on a bend and we have to dodge cars coming out of the gate and the access road to the rear of Fremantle Terrace.”

Read more:

In response, an architect for the council said the development would in fact reduce the number of vehicles in the area due to the removal of seven garages and that highways officials had not raised any concerns.

At Church Close, a garage block will be demolished to make way for two three-bedroom semi-detached properties.

A petition against the plans, which had the support of 34 residents, was handed into the council with similar concerns over the loss of garage parking and increase in vehicles.

But council planners argued there was no demand for these garages and that although the roads can get busy with parked vehicles, a nearby council-owned car park provided for residents was underused.

Also at today’s meeting, a decision on separate plans to build three social rented homes at another site of disused garage blocks at Russell Dixon Square was deferred after a nearby resident raised concerns over access to her home.

It was agreed that the proposals would be revised before being brought back to the council’s planning committee at a later date.

Two arrested on suspicion of wounding in Jennyfields

Police have arrested two men in Harrogate on suspicion of wounding after a late night assault in the Jennyfields area.

Officers were called to Grantley Drive by the ambulance service at 11.20pm after two men were found with head injuries and cuts to their body.

A police helicopter was used to search the area and two men, aged 51 and 44, were later arrested on suspicion of wounding.

Read more:

The 51-year-old man was also arrested on suspicion of possessing class A drugs.

A North Yorkshire Police statement said:

“At around 1am, two men from Harrogate aged  51 and 44 were arrested nearby on suspicion of wounding. The 51-year-old was also arrested on suspicion of possessing class A drugs.

“Both men remain in custody at this time.

“The victims were taken to hospital for treatment, their injuries are not believed to be life-threatening.

“Anyone who was in the area of the Co-op store on Grantley Drive, Grantley Drive itself or Bramham  Drive and witnessed the incident is asked to contact North Yorkshire Police on 101 and pass information to the Force Control Room.”

If you wish to remain anonymous, you can pass information to Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.

Quote reference 12210145213 when passing on information.”

Man caught masturbating in public in Harrogate sentenced

A man who was caught masturbating in public in Walkers Passage has been conditionally discharged.

A 54-year-old Harrogate man pleaded guilty on Monday to outraging public decency.

Appearing before Harrogate Magistrates Court, he was handed a conditional discharge for 12 months.

Read more:

The incident occurred in September last year.

Walkers Passage is a popular cut through linking Harcourt Drive and Park Parade, on the edge of the Stray.

The court took into account the man’s guilty plea when imposing the sentence.

However, he was ordered to pay a £22 surcharge towards victim services and £85 costs to the Crown Prosecution Service.