Councillors have scrapped plans to install electrical vehicle charging points in Bilton due to concerns about vandalism and cost.

In October last year, Harrogate Borough Council approved its own planning application to demolish 10 garages at Woodfield Close to make way for two homes providing temporary accommodation for homeless people.

The scheme included five off-street public parking spaces with EV charging infrastructure.

But the council’s planning committee yesterday voted to amend its application by removing electric charging points from the plan and replacing them with solar panels on the roofs of the new houses.

Officials at the authority raised concern that the infrastructure would have a “lack of anticipated use” and, as a result, would be at a “higher chance of vandalism”.

Tom O’Donovan, economy and transport officer at the council, said in planning documents to councillors:

“All of our information shows that the area is the least likely to buy an EV any time soon and even if they did there are houses with off-street parking so they wouldn’t use the charging points; though there are some without. 

“It would be very unlikely for a visitor to Harrogate to go seeking them out as we’re currently installing charging points in all of our car parks.

“My concern is that they won’t be used and there is a higher chance of vandalism potentially increasing costs for a facility we never actually planned to provide.”

Read more:

• Homeless accommodation plan approved for Bilton garages
• Maltkiln developer still ‘confident’ in new town near Cattal

Mr O’Donovan said the points would cost £3,080 over five years to run and maintain and the installation costs “will depend on the costs from Northern Powergrid”.

Arthama Lakhanpall, planning officer at the council, said the justification given by the council officer demonstrated that the infrastructure would be “more of a liability than an asset to the council” and solar panels would be “more suitable in terms of delivery and energy monitoring”.

Questions over green credentials

However, some councillors on the planning committee yesterday questioned the move.

Cllr Victoria Oldham, a Conservative who represents Washburn, asked whether it would make sense to keep the charging points for staff helping homeless people at the accommodation.

She said:

“If there are likely to be any staff in the vicinity assisting the rough sleepers there, surely they ought to have the potential of having electric charging points for their vehicles?”

Cllr Robert Windass, a Conservative who represents Boroughbridge, said electric vehicle charging points had been fitted in Back Lane car park in Boroughbridge and had never been vandalised.

He said:

“It’s right at the side of the toilet block. The toilet block gets vandalised on a fairly regular basis.

“The electric vehicle charging points have never been touched. So, they are just assuming that there will be vandalism.”

Pat Marsh, a Liberal Democrat who represents Harrogate Hookstone, said removing the charging points raised questions about the council’s commitment to tackling the climate crisis.

Councillors approved the application by nine votes to two, with one abstention.

A 200-year-old building on the Ripley estate is set to be converted to support outdoor pursuits.

The bothy, adjacent to the east pavilion in the walled garden, will be fitted out with changing rooms, storage and toilets if a planning application is approved.

The proposals are to provide better facilities for Live For Today, an outdoor activities business based in the grounds of Ripley Castle.

Last year, the bothy had structural work done to improve its condition, including a new roof and repointing with lime mortar.

Sir Thomas Ingilby of Ripley Castle told the Stray Ferret:

“Live For Today need extra storage, so part of it is for that. We have got plans for toilets and locker rooms shared by Life For Today visitors to the gardens and garden staff.

“We’re hoping to do more work with community groups coming into the gardens. We’re really keen to get it done – we have spent a lot of money doing up the bothy and it will be nice to see if back in use.”

Now a listed building, the bothy is originally believed to have been the home of a gardener on the Ripley estate.

Read more:

• Ripley Castle garden buildings saved from risk of being lost
• Drone pic shows Ripley Castle after major scaffolding project

Live For Today runs activities including paddle boarding, axe throwing, body zorbing, kayaking, bushcraft and escape rooms at the Ripley estate.

It currently uses the east pavilion for storage, which the application said was causing damage to the fabric of the building because of poor ventilation. Moving storage to the bothy would allow the pavilion to be used by the public.

Life For Today’s current facilities include portable toilets and makeshift changing rooms in the woods, which the application described as “inadequate and unsatisfactory”. The application said the newly-converted bothy would be an asset both to the business and to the estate.

To view or comment on the application, visit the planning section of Harrogate Borough Council’s website and use reference 22/04111/LB.

The organisation set up to protect Harrogate’s Stray has said a move to make it common land is “not needed”.

The Stray Defence Association said it was approached by the Open Spaces Society for a number of years about the possibility of changing its official status.

However, SDA chairman Judy d’Arcy Thomson told the Stray Ferret the existing protections for the Stray were adequate and she had not been persuaded that common land status would bring any benefit.

She said:

“There really didn’t seem a great deal of point in what they were trying to do. The whole thing about this is that the Stray is common land in all but name.

“Because it belongs to the people of Harrogate, it’s a sledgehammer to crack a walnut job.

“I’m absolutely behind protecting the Stray but there didn’t seem any point in doing this. We were going round and round in circles. It’s very hard to work out what they are trying to achieve.

“I’m sure they are very well-meaning and what they are do throughout the country, registering common land, is great. It’s laudable, but we don’t need it here.”

Read more:

• Bid to protect Harrogate’s Stray with common land status
• Work starts to reseed the Stray as part of £130,000 repairs

The Stray Act 1985 restricts the number of days on which events can be held on the Stray, as well as the amount of space they can use.

In recent years, special permission has been sought from the government to hold additional events, such as the UCI Road World Championships in 2019.

Heavy rain and large crowds during that event led to the grass on West Park Stray being extensively damaged, causing long periods of closure for repairs and a bill of almost £130,000.

The OSS said being made common land would add an “extra layer” of protection and require additional consent to hold similar events in the future. It also said the move would help to clear up discrepancies in maps of the Stray.

Ms d’Arcy-Thompson said she had worked with the late historian Malcolm Neesam, who had reviewed his maps and plans of the Stray over the last few years. He believed the OSS was working from inaccurate and out-of-date maps.

Before his death last year, he wrote:

“I think the Open Spaces Society is simply trying to find something to keep itself occupied.”

The Stray Defence Association has spoken to the Duchy of Lancaster, which owns the land, and Mrs d’Arcy-Thompson said it too was of the view that the change in status was not necessary.

Consultation period

North Yorkshire County Council’s assistant director for highways and transportation, Barrie Mason, said:

“We can confirm we have received an application from the Open Spaces Society to register the Stray in Harrogate as common land. In the first instance, the application will be considered by the commons registration officer to ensure that it has been made correctly and with the relevant supporting documentation.

“If so, then it will be processed in line with our policy. This will include a formal consultation period in accordance with the Commons Act 2006 requiring notices to be posted around The Stray and on the council’s website for a period of at least 42 days.

“At this early stage, we cannot put a timeframe on the determination of the application.”

North Yorkshire Council looks set to increase rents on social housing in Harrogate by 7% from April.

The authority is set to inherit 3,893 social houses when Harrogate Borough Council is abolished in under three months’ time.

Senior councillors agreed to recommend the rent increase at a meeting yesterday.

It will see the average weekly rent in Harrogate increase from £85.22 to £91.18.

Cllr Simon Myers, executive councillor for housing on the council, told councillors that the increase was difficult to propose.

He said:

“I, with a very heavy heart, have to recommend to you all that we increase our rents by the maximum allowed by government this year, which is capped at 7%.”

The number of social homes which North Yorkshire Council will inherit.

Cllr Myers added that the authority needed the income to balance the books of its housing revenue account.

He added that the council also had an ambition to improve its social housing stock in the future.

Cllr Myers said:

“We have a commitment to our tenants and we understand the pressures on them and all residents of North Yorkshire.

“But we have a commitment that is very long term to provide social, fair and decent housing to our residents as a stockholding authority.”

£2 million deficit

The council will inherit a mixture of houses, flats, hostels and shared ownership properties.

According to a council report, the combination of the Harrogate, Richmondshire and Selby housing stock is set to leave the authority with an in-year deficit of £2 million.

As a result, the council has agreed to increase rents by the maximum allowed by government from April 1.

Read more:

• North Yorkshire Council has reserves to ride out inflation, says senior official
• Explained: North Yorkshire Council’s plan for council tax

The proposal also includes a 2% increase on shared ownership property rents, which is in line with the lease agreements at those homes.

In his report, Gary Fielding, corporate director for strategic resources at the council, pointed out that that a third of the rent paid by social housing tenants is covered by housing benefit.

He said:

“The vast majority of HRA income comes from the rent that is charged to tenants. It should be noted that approximately one third of this income is paid for via housing benefit, rather than directly by tenants. 

“In addition, some tenants will be in receipt of Universal Credit, which will include an element designed to cover rental payments, but this cannot be quantified.”

The recommendation to increase social housing rent by 7% will go to the authority’s full council for a final decision.

The Stray Ferret Business Awards will be held on March 9 at the Pavilions of Harrogate. The event will be a celebratory night with prize draw and afterparty.

Richard Flinton, the chief executive of the new North Yorkshire Council is the guest speaker. Early bird ticket prices are available until February 9 and available to buy here. Bring your team, network and have fun. 

Bettys and Taylors of Harrogate has been named specialist retailer of the year at the Food and Travel Reader Awards.

The awards, which were founded in 2012, were held at the Royal Automobile Club in London’s Pall Mall.

Bettys was nominated in the category alongside Berry Bros & Rudd, Cheeses of Muswell Hill, HG Walter, Cockburns of Leith and The Umbrella Project.

Simon Eyles, Bettys managing director, said: 

“Bettys is delighted to have scooped this prestigious award, and we want to say a huge thank you to all the Food & Travel readers and the Bettys customers who voted for us.

“It’s a very proud moment for us to have our shops, whether in our Yorkshire branches or online, honoured by our customers in this way.”

Last call for EU funded workplace support scheme

Mike Sweeting, human resources officer at Aldwark Manor.

A Knaresborough non-profit has made a final call for small businesses to take advantage of a workplace support scheme.

The Thriving at Work programme is led by Better Connect and aims to help firms create an inclusive workplace, in particular for staff who are neurodiverse, disabled, or experiencing mental health challenges.

The support, which is EU funded, is aimed at businesses across the Harrogate district and North Yorkshire.

The programme includes:

• Inclusive workplace support: one-to-one business support to help create an inclusive workplace, covering policies and procedures, recruitment, culture and values, staff training, quality marks and more.
• Diversity training: webinars and training courses relevant to creating inclusive workplaces.
• Workplace support: one-to-one coaching and support for employees who identify as neurodiverse, disabled, or experienced mental health challenges.

Mike Sweeting, human resources officer at Aldwark Manor which undertook the scheme, said:

“We’re very much on a journey of development, looking specifically at retaining our team, attracting the best new talent into the business, and ensuring we cultivate a great working environment where we show commitment to the development of our team.”

As the UK is no longer a member of the European Union, businesses must sign up by March 31, to take advantage of Thriving at Work’s fully funded inclusive workplace support, which will be delivered by June 30, 2023.

For more information, visit the Better Connect website here.

Read more:

• Business breakfast: Finalists revealed for first Stray Ferret Business Awards
• Business Breakfast: Harrogate’s Windsor House opens pilates studio for tenants

Harrogate Borough Council‘s planning committee has approved a sixth housing development in the Kingsley area after a heated debate today.

The committee was split 6-6 on whether to accept 30 new homes at Kingsley Farm. It meant Rebecca Burnett, the chair of the committee, had the casting vote in favour.

It means more than 600 properties will be built in the Kingsley ward, where residents have already expressed exasperation at the scale of development and lack of supporting infrastructure.

Most of today’s debate centred on access to the site even though council case officer Kate Broadbank said the meeting should focus on the general principle of development. Access, she said, would be debated at the later reserved matters application for ironing out the details.

Ms Broadbank said there would be access roads to the development from Kingsley Road and Hawthorn Place. Creating the access road on Kingsley Road would, she said, require the removal of a stone wall and a ‘small number of trees’, which she said would be replaced.

Cllr Chris Aldred speaking today

Cllr Chris Aldred, a Liberal Democrat who represents the area on North Yorkshire County Council, said the new access road on Kingsley Road would go through an orchard and mean there would be five junctions in the space of 150 yards.

He called for the decision to be deferred, adding:

“There’s no planning necessity for this site now. We have enough houses in Harrogate already. We can work on this slowly but surely.”

A local resident, Matt Hodgson, told the committee “access remains crucial at this stage when discussing the suitability of the site”.

‘We have listened’

Speaking on behalf of the applicant Quarters Kingsley Ltd, David Williams said it was a small local developer working alongside the landowner, who has owned the site for 100 years.

Mr Williams said it was a former chicken farm that had become an “overgrown wasteland” that had “no purpose”

David Williams speaking at the meeting

He said the applicants had already agreed to reduce the number of home from 49 to 30, adding:

“We have listened. We are doing everything we can to make a positive contribution to the area.”

Doctors and dentists

Pat Marsh, the Liberal Democrat councillor for Harrogate Hookstone asked if there would be any increased provision for doctors and dentists in the area.

Ms Broadbank said ‘there will be a contribution’ through the section 106 agreement which developers sign to pay for infrastructure associated with their schemes but where it was allocated would be a matter for the NHS.

Read more:

• Council recommends controversial Kingsley Farm homes be approved
• Kingsley residents call for halt to new housing decisions

All six councillors in favour of the scheme were Conservatives. Three Liberal Democrats, two Conservatives and one Independent opposed the recommendation to approve the principle of development on the land.

After the scheme was approved, Cllr Burnett berated Cllr Marsh for saying ‘shameful’.

“Can we have less bickering from the committee? I don’t think we need to hear ‘shameful’ shouted out when we have taken a democratic vote from all members of the committee.

“When things don’t go your way I don’t feel it’s acceptable for you to do that.”

Harrogate Synagogue has received a new holocaust memorial to display for present and future generations.

The building on St Mary’s Walk is one of 150 synagogues, Jewish secondary schools, youth groups and communal organisations in the UK to have been sent legacy boards by the Board of Deputies of British Jews.

The boards, which were distributed as part of Friday’s Holocaust Memorial Day 2023, are intended to serve as a continuing reminder of Nazi atrocities.

Arek Hersh, a survivor of the holocaust and a member of Harrogate Synagogue, said:

“I am delighted that Harrogate shul, together with all synagogues and communal organisations, supports the legacy board where it is prominently displayed in the shul hall.

“It is important that all members and visitors see it clearly so the Holocaust is never forgotten.”

Shul is the Yiddish term for synagogue.

Read more:

• Bid to protect Harrogate’s Stray with common land status
• Harrogate council paying £25,000 a month on hotels and B&Bs for homeless

The boards are being displayed prominently by each recipient as a visible and continuing symbolic reminder of “our responsibility to pass on this legacy from generation to generation” and to observe Holocaust Memorial Day,

Board of deputies president Marie van der Zyl said:

“The holocaust is our greatest tragedy. The legacy board project is crucial to ensure that the memory of the holocaust is observed in every synagogue and communal organisation throughout the country.”

Photo (from left): deputy for Harrogate Hebrew Congregation Alan Sanders, Arek Hersh with his wife Jean, Roma Cohen (vice president/chair of Harrogate Hebrew Congregation) and Bernard Cohen (president of Harrogate Hebrew Congregation) standing in front of the legacy board at Harrogate Synagogue.

A warrant has been issued for the arrest of a suspected cocaine dealer from Harrogate.

Yasin Hussain, 30, of Leadhall Crescent, failed to appear before Harrogate Magistrates Court on November 3, 2022, charged with two counts of possession with intent to supply a class A drug.

He is also wanted by West Yorkshire Police after he failed to appear at court for motoring offences.

North Yorkshire Police has appealed to the public for any information on his whereabouts.

A police statement added:

“Extensive police enquiries are ongoing to trace Hussain in both the Harrogate and Leeds area, including Harehills, Gipton, Roundhay and Armley where he is known to have links.

“Checks are taking place with the Border Force as it is known he travelled outside the UK in recent months before returning.

“Officers are also continuing to liaise with Hussain’s solicitor with a request to hand himself in.

“Anyone with information about Hussain’s whereabouts or possible sightings of him, please make an online report via the North Yorkshire Police website or call 101, option 1, and speak to the force control room.

“If you would prefer to remain anonymous, call Crimestoppers on 0800 555111.

“Please quote reference number 12220195320 when providing details.”

Read more:

• Antique safe stolen from Harrogate
• Harrogate’s former Kimberley Hotel being used for drugs and crime, say police

Mr Renton said Department for Education guidance stated schools should prioritise students taking exams and therefore pupils in years 11 and 13 would attend school as normal and either have lessons when teachers were not striking or undertake private study.

Other schools set for ‘unavoidable impact’

Harrogate Grammar School is part of Red Kite Learning Trust, which also manages Oatlands Junior School, Coppice Valley Primary School, Rossett Acre Primary School, Western Primary School in the Harrogate district.

Richard Sheriff

Red Kite chief executive Richard Sheriff sent a letter alongside Mr Renton’s saying “a very significant number of our teachers” are members of the NEU and “sadly it is unavoidable that this will have an impact on the provision we offer across our schools on the strike days”. He added:

“The impact will vary considerably from school to school, depending on the number of staff who are members of the union concerned and who decide to support the action.

“Red Kite Learning Trust is the employer for all our teachers and staff in schools, and we have received some information from the National Education Union (NEU) about how many members are in each of our schools. This information does not give us the full picture, however, as we do not know which teachers will choose to actually be on strike on the days concerned. Headteachers/principals will therefore have to cope with a high degree of uncertainty, as they plan for the strike days.”

He added:

North Yorkshire Council will have enough reserves to ride out another national event such as soaring inflation, a senior council official has said.

Gary Fielding, corporate director for strategic resources at the authority, said the council has planned for a “one-off use” of its reserves to cover a £30 million shortfall for the upcoming financial year.

The council is facing pressures from inflation, rising cost of utilities and taking on structural deficits from other district councils.

Around £18 million from the districts will be taken on by North Yorkshire Council, plus a further £12 million for an in-year shortfall.

As part of the budget plans, the county council will dip into its reserves to cover the financial blackhole.

Despite the use of reserves, Mr Fielding said he felt the council would still be in a good position to withstand another national event, such as a pandemic or soaring inflation rates.

He said:

“I think we are well placed to ride out the issues in the coming years.

“I would describe these times as unprecedented and that is after two years of covid.”

Part of the council’s shortfall is down to energy costs and pay awards.

Energy bills for North Yorkshire’s current eight councils stood at about £6 million in 2021/22, rising to £15.5 million for the current financial year.

They are predicted to rise to £31 million for the forthcoming financial year from April 1.

Meanwhile, inflationary pressures, including pay awards, previously accounted for an increase of about £19 million a year across the eight North Yorkshire councils.

However, the dramatic rise in inflation to more than 10% a year has seen £66 million having to be allocated to next year’s proposed budget to cope with the increase.

Mr Fielding pointed out that other councils were serving section 114 notices – a measure taken in dire financial circumstances.

Read more:

• Council freezes Ripon parish precept for third year running
• Levelling up council tax charges over two years is ‘best compromise’
• Explained: North Yorkshire Council’s plan for council tax

Thurrock Council, Slough Borough Council and Croydon Council have all issued such notices, which effectively declare the authority as bankrupt and ban any further spending.

However, Mr Fielding said he felt confident the council was not in that position.

He told senior councillors this morning:

“I am confident that we are not that organisation and will not be that organisation.”

‘Heavy heart’ over council tax hike

Senior councillors this morning recommended a 4.99% increase in council tax for the entirety of North Yorkshire.

The proposal, which would see a band D rate of £1,759.96 for the year, will go to councillors at the authority’s full council meeting for a final decision.

Cllr Gareth Dadd, deputy leader of the county council, said it was “with a heavy heart” that the authority had to propose an increase.

He said:

“As we sit here today I can see no alternative to that 4.99% increase.

“Every one per cent that we take off that equates to a loss of funding of £4.1 million year on year.”

The council is proposing the sum in order to meet costs for providing public services across the county.

It has also decided that council tax rates will be harmonised for the next two years – meaning taxpayers will pay the same sum across the county.