Thank you for your interest in this story
To continue reading this article, subscribe to the Stray Ferret for as little as £1 a week
Already a subscriber? Log in here.
12
Aug
Conservationist says Harrogate’s sewerage system can’t cope with scale of housebuilding
For most people after they flush the toilet it’s a case of out of sight, out of mind.
But our waste has to go somewhere, and in Harrogate it’s increasingly ending up in rivers like the Nidd, Crimple and Oak Beck.
Harrogate’s leading conservationist Keith Wilkinson says the town’s creaking Victorian sewerage network can no longer cope with the number of new homes being built.
He warned that the spectre of development and the consequences of pollution are now “very concerning” for wildlife.
Mr Wilkinson, who was awarded the MBE in 2013 for services to conservation, told the Local Democracy Reporting Service that housing developers, North Yorkshire Council and Yorkshire Water are systematically failing to improve infrastructure, which is doing serious harm.
He’s not a lone voice and some local councillors and the Environment Agency have also sounded the alarm about the scale of housebuilding in Harrogate and its impact on the environment.
Harrogate’s sewage was once tipped into becks or onto Killinghall Moor, which is where the Jennyfields estate is today.
A drive to improve public health resulted in the town’s first sewage works in 1900.
However, back then, Harrogate had a population of 25,000.
It’s now more than trebled to 89,000 and it’s argued that improvements to the sewerage network have not kept up with the population growth.
The new Labour government is promising a big increase in housebuilding across the country and Harrogate will not be able to avoid further huge housing schemes being built, particularly on the western side around Harlow Hill and Cardale Park.
This is on top of the thousands of homes that have already been built around Skipton Road, Pennypot Lane and Killinghall.
Mr Wilkinson said the town expanded too fast over the last decade. He said:
We’re part of the golden triangle and it’s an accolade to have a HG1 or HG2 postcode but it went mad.
Yorkshire Water has said it plans to invest £12 million at Harrogate North wastewater treatment works and a further £27 million to improve 12 storm overflows in the town.
But is it too little, too late?
Mr Wilkinson has been involved with the campaign to clean up the River Nidd, where recent testing has revealed levels of E.coli up to 10 times higher than “sufficient” levels. He also said other rivers like the Crimple are heavily polluted.
There was also a troubling sweage pollution incident in 2016 that killed 1,500 fish in Hookstone Beck and eventually led to a record £1 million fine for Yorkshire Water last year.
He added:
Where is all the sewage from the Beckwithshaw side going? I’m not sure I have the answer. The whole thing needs a complete overhaul, infrastructure investment on a massive scale is needed.
North Yorkshire Council is in the early stages of developing its next local plan which will map out where new homes can be built over the next few decades.
It should be the perfect opportunity to tackle the issue of where our sewage goes head-on.
Mr Wilkinson said:
In this country, we put the cart before the horse with infrastructure. We approve housing and hope other things happen afterwards. It’s not good planning.
Yorkshire Water is not a statutory consultee on major planning applications which has been a source of frustration for residents.
The company is allowed to release sewage through storm overflows when the system is at full capacity, such as during heavy rainfall, but it increasingly happens during dry weather too.
Mr Wilkinson is optimistic that public pressure will lead to Yorkshire Water improving the current situation.
He said:
Dereleugation took the brakes off and it became the wild west. Harrogate is an example of how the public has suffered.
A Yorkshire Water spokesperson said:
We work with local planning teams to understand the developments planned for land in their area so we can plan for any expansion required. Where necessary we invest to ensure the network has enough capacity to handle any additional wastewater flows.
While we are not statutory consultees on new developments, we review planning applications and assess the likely impact on our network. We work closely with developers and encourage them to separate wastewater and surface water from rainfall on roads and paved areas to again reduce the flows entering the combined public sewer network.
We encourage all developers to manage surface water in a sustainable and environmentally friendly way, such as by using sustainable urban drainage solutions or by returning the rain back to the environment.
Investment is currently taking place at our wastewater treatment works in Killinghall, Shaw Mills, Darley and Pateley Bridge to make improvements to their performance. We are also investing in pumping stations, sewers and storm overflows as we continue to improve the water environment.
1