Subscribe to trusted local news
In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever. By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.
- Subscription costs less than £1 a week with an annual plan.
Already a subscriber? Log in here.
05
Feb
Council launches legal challenge against government over grant axing
North Yorkshire Council has begun legal proceedings against the government over the removal of the £14.3m rural services delivery grant.
Council leader Carl Les confirmed yesterday (February 4) that a letter before action had been sent ahead of the authority seeking a judicial review of the decision.
The government announced in November that it was axing the £110m fund which helped councils cover the extra costs of delivering services in rural areas.
Cllr Les told members of the authority’s executive committee that the letter had been sent to the government, as well as the county’s MPs.
He said:
The rhetoric that accompanied that decision said there was no evidence that services in rural areas cost more to deliver, that rural areas are more affluent than city areas and that councils just use (the grant) to bolster their reserves when clearly that is not the fact in North Yorkshire.
“That decision in my view is unsound so we have asked Barry Khan (assistant chief executive for legal and democratic services) to write a letter as the first steps of a judicial review.
Mr Khan said the letter had been sent on Friday and the authority would await a response before considering its next step.
The letter challenges the government decision on three points — the consultation process, the rationality of the decision and the impact it would have on the council’s public sector equality duties for the rural population.
Cllr Gareth Dadd, executive member for finance and resources, said that with the government set to conduct a review of local authority funding, it was right that the council gave notice to ministers that it was looking at a legal challenge.
With other rural councils also losing out due to the removal of the grant, Cllr Dadd said North Yorkshire was “the first out of the traps” to take legal steps.
Cllr Simon Myers, executive member for vulture, arts and housing, claimed the criticism of the decision was not the case of a Conservative council attacking a Labour government just for the “sheer political joy of it”.
He added:
This a direct attack on our residents.
“It’s irrational to say that it doesn’t cost more to deliver services across the largest rural area in England — of course it costs more.
North Yorkshire Council says that even with a planned 4.99 per cent increase in council tax, the loss of the grant and an increase in employer national insurance contributions had left the authority with a £5m shortfall which it would need to cover from its reserves.
The Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government has defended the latest local government settlement, saying councils with a significant rural population would receive around five per cent more in their core spending power during the next financial year.
Ministers said the rural services delivery grant did not properly account for rural need and a large number of predominantly rural councils received nothing from it.
0