Subscribe to trusted local news

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever. By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

Subscription costs less than £1 a week with an annual plan.

Already a subscriber? Log in here.

Mar 2023

Last Updated: 26/03/2023

Community

Fears for vulnerable families after changes to Harrogate district children's centres

by Vicky Carr

| 27 Mar, 2023

Concerns have been raised about vulnerable children and families missing out on vital support in the Harrogate district.

Parents and professionals have told the Stray Ferret changes to children's centres, including the health visiting service, have led to a decline in the support available.

Mum Jen Earl said the support on offer after her son was born in April 2020 was a fraction of what it had been following the birth of her daughter in September 2018.

She said the difference is apparent when looking through her children's record books, which showed regular checks at health visitor drop-in sessions for her daughter, but barely anything for her son. She said:

"I really missed that input. I didn't have anywhere to go. You could ring the health visitor and leave a message and sometimes it would be two weeks before someone would phone back. Really, the type of questions you're asking, you need a quick response."

She used to attend a weekly breastfeeding support group in central Harrogate in 2019, where there was "always a friendly face and you could ask questions". She also went to workshops about weaning and baby sleep.

She added:

"It's so sad when I think of all the first-time mums who have missed out.

"It must be so frustrating for the health visitors because they went into their profession to support mums and babies in that initial phase. To not be able to do those basic things like weighing babies must be hard."

Bilton Children's Centre is based on the site of the former Woodfield Primary School

Mum Emily Clough, whose son was born in December 2020, said all her contact with the health visiting service was positive and useful, but she still suffered because of the lack of face-to-face opportunities.

"I felt supported by them directly, although there was no weigh-in, no face-to-face clinics – there was no social space. That's what was missing for me.

"I'm glad I didn't have any real long-standing challenges in breastfeeding or my son didn't have any drops in weight. We didn't have any concerns, but had those clinics been on, I would have taken him to be weighed.

"By default, that would have initiated other conversations.

"When I say I didn't struggle, in hindsight I struggled in terms of being really isolated."

Call for parents to share maternity experiences in Harrogate district

Midwives launch Harrogate district support service with drop-in session for 'covid parents'

One perinatal mental health professional, who asked not to be named, told the Stray Ferret local services were already seeing an impact from the reduction in face-to-face health visiting support.

She said she had worked across North Yorkshire for several years and the Harrogate district had previously had the best mental health support in the county, such as through the Mums in Mind support group.

Since covid, she said, there had been a rise in demand for perinatal mental health services. She believes this is because opportunities to spot problems at an early stage are no longer available.

She said:

"A lot of our referrals came from health visitors and midwives. That has significantly dropped. They're just not out there seeing those women.

"We're seeing people a lot more in crisis now than we ever did before."

She added the impact of the changes had also affected health visitors, who she said were no longer able to carry out their roles as effectively as they wanted. She added:

"It's just complete devastation and absolutely heartbreaking."

'Blended approach'

North Yorkshire County Council, which is responsible for support to families including the health visiting service, said children's centres across the Harrogate district remain open.

Cllr Janet Sanderson, executive member for children and families, said:

“The majority of our children centres are now open and delivering targeted activities to children and their families where a need has been identified. The way we deliver activities has evolved as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic.

“Over the past two years, the Early Help service has redesigned the delivery of activities to support children and their families, moving to a blended approach of virtual and face-to-face activities.

“This has enabled the delivery of countywide virtual activities which families are able to access from their home, reducing the need for the number of premises."

The council has already announced it will consult on the closure of five children's centres across North Yorkshire, including Pateley Bridge, which have not been used since the pandemic. If that closure goes ahead, the facility is likely to be used by St Cuthbert's Primary School, based in the same building.

Cllr Sanderson said the council was working alongside voluntary and community groups to develop activities in their areas. She said the Get Going Grant scheme had been used to support 93 groups in the last year.

Meanwhile, she said NYCC had invested in a programme to support parents with their mental health and it was also being used in schools and early years settings to increase access.

A Grow and Learn project was being run with libraries to deliver activities to support children's early communication, she said, adding:

“As part of this work, we have developed a training programme which is accessible to all services working with children and families, including the voluntary and community sector.

“That enables agencies to access training to support them with their Early Help offer to children and their families."

Ms Sanderson said virtual health visitor drop-in sessions had been available online since last summer instead of face-to-face sessions, while the new model of delivery also included sessions on topics including breastfeeding, weaning and other infant advice.

She also said any families with concerns can call the 0-19 service from Monday to Friday, 8am to 5pm, on 0300 303 0916.

Have you been affected by the changes to children's centres and the health visiting service? Email us or call the newsdesk on 01423 276197.

Subscribe to trusted local news

Fears for vulnerable families after changes to Harrogate district children's centres

Read more:

'Blended approach'