Subscribe to trusted local news

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever. By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

Subscription costs less than £1 a week with an annual plan.

Already a subscriber? Log in here.

Apr 2020

Last Updated: 22/04/2020

'Please don't sit down' signs go up on benches in Valley Gardens

by Vicky Carr

| 22 Apr, 2020

As signs go up telling people not to sit on benches in the Valley Gardens, one resident says he worries about the impact on older people getting their daily exercise. The council, however, says it recognises there are legitimate reasons for people to rest.

Signs have been put up in the Valley Gardens telling people not to sit on benches in order to protect themselves from coronavirus.

They have been placed on benches in the gardens by Harrogate Borough Council, asking people not to rest while taking their daily exercise.

Richard Meyrick, who spotted the first signs going up yesterday, said he was concerned about the impact on elderly people living nearby.

"I am in my 70s and have certain medical conditions which prevent me walking too far without a short sit down before I can carry on," he said.

"There are many other people in my situation and we love our exercise in the gardens. The council's action will have the effect of stopping older people taking exercise if there is nowhere to sit.

"All the benches are in the open air and you can sit at least two metres from anyone on the next bench, so I do not see the problem."

The sign says:

"You are much safer resting at home after exercising. To protect yourself and others from the coronavirus please don't sit down and rest on the benches or in the park. Help keep everyone safe."

Mr Meyrick said he walks daily in the Valley Gardens and has never seen anyone failing to follow the social distancing guidelines. Most of those using benches are older, while younger couples and dog walkers tend not to stop, he said.

"I'm not sure if it's somebody being heavy-handed and not thinking it through," he said. "I spoke to a few older people who also had to sit down. When you get older, you do have to sit more often. I can't see what the problem is."

A spokesman for Harrogate Borough Council said:

“We chose to put up signs rather than – as has happened in other places – tape up the benches and physically prevent people from using them. We recognise there may be a legitimate reason why someone might need sit down for a few minutes, but we have a duty to discourage people from gathering or using our parks and open spaces for anything other than exercise as per the government’s clear instructions.”

However, Mr Meyrick said people were likely to feel self-conscious sitting on a bench with a sign on it, even if there was a legitimate reason. He added:

"The notice says don't sit on this bench or any other place in the park. If you sit on one of those, it's going to be like if you weren't socially distancing. People are going to feel guilty."