Subscribe to trusted local news

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever. By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

Subscription costs less than £1 a week with an annual plan.

Already a subscriber? Log in here.

Nov 2022

Last Updated: 01/11/2022

Environment

Parish councils fear new Harrogate district town will be rushed and poor quality

by John Plummer

| 01 Nov, 2022

Parish councils representing Moor Monkton, Nun Monkton, Tockwith, Whixley, Green Hammerton, Kirk Hammerton, Hunsingore, Great Ribston with Walshford and Cattal issue a joint response to plans for a town the size of Thirsk.

The layout for Maltkiln, which is centred around Cattal Station

Seven neighbouring parish councils have jointly raised concerns about the quality of the proposed new town in the Harrogate district.

Harrogate Borough Council is running a six-week consultation until November 14 on plans to create a new settlement called Maltkiln, which will be roughly the size of Thirsk. Up to 4,000 homes could be built.

The consultation sets out a 30-year vision and policy framework on how the site is designed and developed and proceeds any formal planning application.

Parish councils representing Moor Monkton, Nun Monkton, Tockwith, Whixley, Green Hammerton, Kirk Hammerton, Hunsingore, Great Ribston with Walshford and Cattal met last week to consider a joint response.

A summary of their response describes the documents residents are being urged to comment on as "technical and jargon-heavy".

The summary acknowledges "major development is coming to the area" but adds Harrogate Borough Council's development plan document "doesn’t provide a sound framework for delivering the ‘exemplar’ new settlement that’s required; nor does it address with sufficient care the implications for nearby villages".

There are also concerns about the extent to which a genuine consultation is taking place for the new town, the name for which was chosen by developers Caddick without consultation with residents.

The summary says:

"Residents have raised concerns that the consultation process itself hasn’t been inclusive. Despite its far-reaching implications, there have been no in-person exhibition/public-hall meetings about the development plan document.

"The development plan document documents and response forms themselves are difficult to navigate, potentially preventing many residents from taking part."

Council faces calls to hold in-person Maltkiln consultation events

Ouseburn councillor opens Green Party conference in Harrogate

Alex Smith, a spokesman for the councils, said:

"There are several important areas — the development framework itself, transport, flooding — where the development plan document offers a wish-list, not deliverable policies backed up by evidence."

Mr Smith said the speed at which the development was being considered, five months before Harrogate Borough Council is abolished, had "added to the confusion" and the development plan document felt "premature". He added:

"It's about meeting a political objective and getting outline approval for the Caddick application before the council is disbanded on April 1 — not about making sure that we get the best possible development for the future generations who will live in, and near it."

Concerns about transport, flooding and schools

Arnold Warneken, a Green councillor who represents Ouseburn on North Yorkshire County Council, also attended the parish councils' meeting.

He said many residents had concerns about issues such as transport, flooding and education and "a combined voice" was more powerful. Cllr Warneken added:

"The consultation process has been questioned by residents for lots of reasons wondering why it was so arms-length and not at all easy to understand or comment on by those residents not at ease with planning terminology and also those who struggle with computers and emails

"I think this coalition of councils is showing how a community can come together for the good of the wider community."

Subscribe to trusted local news

Parish councils fear new Harrogate district town will be rushed and poor quality

Read more:

Concerns about transport, flooding and schools