Stray Views is a weekly column giving you the chance to have your say on issues affecting the Harrogate district. It is an opinion column and does not reflect the views of the Stray Ferret. Send your views to letters@thestrayferret.co.uk.
Harrogate is riding roughshod over Knaresborough with this unwanted new pool
Thank you for the report on Ripon's issues with
Brimhams Active. We in Knaresborough understand that
Harrogate Borough Council officers have recommended that Harrogate Borough Council's plans to demolish the pool and build from scratch be approved despite all the carefully prepared plans for more sustainable, more attractive, more appropriate — and cheaper — proposals.
This means Harrogate Borough Council is, as usual, riding roughshod over the views of the residents of another ancient market town.
Knaresborough Civic Society and many others
have objected strongly. Many people are concerned that public land, given to the people of Knaresborough, is being commandeered by the private company Brimhams Active who will then charge inordinately high prices.
The excellent free play area will be built over and may never be replaced, leaving whole year groups of children and families without this valuable resource - possibly forever. About 20 mature trees will be chopped down. The embodied carbon cost of a new build and removal of the current pool would be immense as a pool needs enormous quantities of concrete.
The proposed new build even includes gas heating, which in the context of a climate crisis is an unforgivable gratuitous use of fossil fuels.
Knaresborough wants something to be proud of which gives the right messages, not an inappropriate building tying us in to last century's costly and dangerous habits. A very big question is who will Brimhams Active be accountable to when Harrogate Borough Council vanishes? Who will own the building and the land? Who will profit?
This is not the time to demolish a perfectly good pool. It could remain open whilst work was done to build around and above it to add facilities such as a treetop cafe and fitness suites.
Nobody asked for a new pool; the concept appeared out of the blue, so the question must be asked — who are the real beneficiaries of these expensive and unsustainable plans? The people of Knaresborough are having free access to green spaces stolen from under their noses.
Shan Oakes, Knaresborough
Read more:
Boroughbridge school governors need to rethink
As three-times ex-Mayor and a school governor in Ripon for many years, I am appalled and concerned that
sixth form provision is proposed to be removed from Boroughbridge High School, especially with the present addition of many new houses in the town.
How can this make sense to the governing body when students will have to travel into Knaresborough, increasing the carbon footprint of St James’ School? Surely governors should be wanting to reduce the carbon output by students in Boroughbridge and Knaresborough.
However, the greatest threat is to the young people of the town. Removing the great opportunities for students that sixth form life offers is unforgivable, unacceptable and unbelievable; the governors need to rethink their action.
Michael Stanley, Ripon
Econ boss is right — we need more apprenticeships instead of third-rate degrees
I wholeheartedly agree with
Econ Engineering's
Jonathan Lupton's observations about the need for more apprenticeships.
I could rant on, but shall refrain from so doing, about youngsters almost being conned into enrolling at third-rate universities and emerging with commercially worthless degrees.
Apprenticeships for those with A-levels and similar have always been quite readily available. However, the same cannot be said for those who leave school with no qualifications, either because they are not academically inclined or for a variety of other reasons.
It is these youngsters who desperately need to be able and to have the encouragement to get qualifications through apprenticeships. Unfortunately that window has virtually disappeared in this country. I am sure that is not so in the likes Germany, the Netherlands and many of the eastern European countries.
Richard Goldstein, Harrogate
0