Plans for a £17m leisure centre in Knaresborough have been unanimously approved by councillors in what will mark the town centre’s biggest building project in decades.

Harrogate Borough Council yesterday passed its own plans for the new facility to be built over a play area at Fysche Field before the existing Knaresborough Pool just metres away is demolished to make way for a larger car park and new play equipment.

The new leisure centre will have a six-lane pool and exercise studios, and has been hailed by the council as a “modern and fit-for-purpose” facility for the town’s growing population.

Environmental impact

It could be built by the end of 2023 and will also be powered by air source heat pumps and solar panels.

However, some concerns have been raised over the environmental impact of demolishing a large building to replace it with another.

Bill Rigby, chairman of Knaresborough Civic Society, told today’s planning committee meeting that the project should be scrapped in favour of rival proposals for a major upgrade of the existing pool.

He said:

“Rejecting an extension in favour of a new build frustrates the nation’s and district’s own attempts to meet the challenge of a climate emergency.

“We are at a pivotal moment in our history as a community, nation and citizens of the world.

“The proposal fails to respond appropriately at all of these levels.”

Mr Rigby also criticised a council-run survey on where to build the new leisure centre as “flawed” and added residents were never asked if they believed there was a need for it at all.

‘Low carbon priority’

But Jonathan Dunk, chief development officer at the council, described the 30-year-old Knaresborough Pool as “at the end of its working life” and said more swimming space is needed. He said:

“We need to renew rather than refurbish the existing facility because it is old and there is inadequate water space.

“We also want to upgrade to make the most of the energy performance of the new building.

“We have chosen to invest more money and develop to a higher, excellent standard because addressing low-carbon is a high priority for the council.”

Read more:

• £13 million Knaresborough Leisure Centre plans to go to vote on Monday
• Police still investigating missing Porsches at former Knaresborough car dealership

Today’s vote of approval comes after the council confirmed the project budget had increased from £13million to £17million due to increased material and labour costs, and extra spending on safety equipment.

All nine members of the planning committee voted in favour of the project which was described as a “wise investment” for the town.

Knaresborough mayor councillor Christine Willoughby said:

“I’m very pleased to support this new facility.

“This is the perfect site as I have always felt the pool needs to be in the centre of Knaresborough.

“In a town with a river, it is really important that our children learn to swim.

“We have had too many fatalities in the river over the years.”

Other locations previously considered for the leisure centre included Knaresborough House, Hay-a-Park, Conyngham Hall and a plot of land at Halfpenny Lane.

Alliance Leisure

Today’s decision will now be followed by a cabinet meeting on Wednesday when councillors will be asked to approve a £28million contract for Bristol-based firm Alliance Leisure to build the new leisure centre at Fysche Field and separate plans for the Harrogate Hydro.

The proposals for a two-storey extension of the Hydro were approved in October 2021 and include demolishing the existing entrance and replacing it with a larger cafe and reception area, as well as a new fitness suite.

Meanwhile, the council last week announced that Ripon’s new multi-million-pound swimming pool is finally set to open on Wednesday after months of costly delays.

The project is nine months overdue and £4million over budget, and refurbishment works on the adjoining Ripon Leisure Centre are still underway after the discovery of an underground void prompted the need for an investigation.

Brimhams Active

All 11 council-run leisure venues across the Harrogate district are now being run by Brimhams Active – a council-owned company which launched last year and aims to save around half a million pound a year.

Brimhams Active was hailed as a “new vision for the future” sports and leisure services when it launched last year, although there are now questions over what will happen to the company when the council is replaced by a new North Yorkshire Council in April 2023.

Knaresborough Civic Society has objected to the borough council’s proposals for a new leisure centre saying it isn’t future proof or in-keeping with the town’s heritage.

The chair of Knaresborough Civic Society, Bill Rigby, has said the current plans don’t acknowledge the climate crisis and criticises the council for choosing to tear down a building rather than adapting it.

He said the civic society is unanimous in its opinion that the current building could be re-developed to suit the town’s growing population.

Mr Rigby added that the civic society supports the investment and provision of a new leisure centre but said it was important for the group to ensure it is future proof for the next generation:

“In the present climate, especially following COP26, I don’t think we’ve been strategic with these plans or addressed the environmental impact. Surely we should be rebuilding rather than destroying? In terms of the economics it would be much cheaper too.”

The Civic Society’s concerns

In its official objection response to Harrogate Borough Council in regards to the plans the society said:

• Is there is a recognised need for any expansion of the existing swimming pool. What evidence by way or research or public consultation or survey exists to establish that there is such a need?
• Does the pool need to be expanded from four to six lanes or can the opening hours be increased?
• We are not satisfied that the council has investigated properly the much cheaper and less disruptive alternative of renewing the services within the existing structure which is only 30 years old and has recently been refurbished.
• Concerns over the loss of the safely ensconced playground and the felling of 21 mature trees
• Looks like an industrial warehouse
• We believe that this proposal will also not meet the environmental and climate saving credentials of the Council.

Read more:

• Council accused of ‘trophy investment’ for £9m purchase of Harrogate’s Royal Baths
• Eco-development could be catalyst for green housing in Harrogate district

Alternative plan

The civic society said it had seen a new set of plans produced by local architects on behalf of the community which aim to be sustainable and use the current building as its base.

The alternative plans

One of the people involved in the group putting forward the plans is David Hull who set up the NotOff group to protect Fsyche Field from development.

He said the plans are on behalf of a group of locals to offer an alternative proposal that is “cheaper, greener and far less environmental destructive”.

The society’s plans are being offered to Harrogate Borough Council as an alternative option.

Harrogate and District Green Party has attacked “unforgivable” plans to build Knaresborough’s new leisure centre on a playing field popular with children and dog walkers.

Harrogate Borough Council, which is behind the plans for the new facility to replace the town’s existing swimming pool at Fysche Field, has begun drawing up designs after a survey showed just over 80% of respondents were in support of the site.

But some residents have criticised the consultation process and are mounting a campaign to protect the playing field next to the leisure centre from development.

They said the survey was poorly publicised and failed to attract enough responses – and now the Green Party has also accused the council of being “completely misleading” as it did not disclose the loss of green space during the consultation.

Shan Oakes, the party’s coordinator and former parliamentary candidate, said:

“This was either total incompetence from the council or them being disingenuous.

“The consultation should be null and void because the wording of the questions was completely misleading and only 471 people responded.”

Harrogate Borough Council previously defended the survey saying it was “well publicised” and that the comments submitted “will help shape the future of the facility”.

Read more:

• Plans for Knaresborough pool ‘catastrophic’ for environment
• Knaresborough farmers’ market returns this weekend

A spokesperson also said the amount of green space that could be lost has not yet been determined and would be subject to approval of a planning application.

As part of the consultation held over December and January, the council-owned Knaresborough House, Hay-a-Park and Conyngham Hall were also considered as potential sites for the new leisure centre.

‘Precious green space’

There was also a privately-owned site at Halfpenny Lane, which Shan Oakes said had won the support of the Green Party before it was discounted by the council. She said:

“We were in favour of this site because it is brownfield and in the right location. Fysche Field, however, should not be touched as it is a precious green space used by so many.

“The pandemic has shown that green spaces are so vital for our mental health and keeping people connected – and it is unforgivable that the council would even think about taking this away.

“Their so-called green credentials are actually a greenwash and we will fight these plans every step of the way.”

A council spokesman said:

“Although the existing site in Knaresborough has been recommended, we are still in the early stages and no formal plans have been submitted. Once submitted they will be subject to the normal planning application process.

“The current venue is nearing 30 years old, is operating at capacity, only provides a swimming pool and has a number of on-going maintenance issues which are not resolvable without significant investment.

“Once completed, the new leisure centre will provide energy efficient, state-of-the art facilities that will encourage a healthier and more active lifestyle for our residents and something they can be proud of.”

If the plans are approved, the new leisure centre will include a new 25-metre pool, a 66-station gym and two studio spaces, and could be built by the end of 2023.

Knaresborough residents have begun campaigning to save Fsyche Field when the town’s swimming pool and leisure centre is rebuilt.

The park, next to the leisure centre, is used by local families and sports clubs.

But campaigners fear it will be concreted over under plans by Harrogate Borough Council to rebuild the leisure centre.

Local resident David Hull has set up a website and Facebook page to encourage more people to join his campaign to save Knaresborough’s only recreational green space.

The Facebook group has 36 members, which Mr Hull hopes will increase as more people hear of the plans.

Mr Hull has concerns about the loss of green space and increase in traffic pollution.

He also believes the council hasn’t clearly explained to people the threat to Fsyche Field. Several people he knows were unaware it could be lost.

Mr Hull said he has no issue with the current site being used for further development but is determined to stop any building on the recreational field.

He said:

“Its outrageous what the council are doing to get away with it. Our aim is to protect the green space because once it’s gone it’ll be gone forever.

“We want to get the message out there. It’ll have a catastrophic effect, it’s a great amenity to the town.”

The proposed site plans for the new leisure centre.

Mr Hull questioned the need for a new leisure centre and suggested the money could be better spent on refurbishing the existing pool rather than demolishing it.

He has suggested the council looks at nearby brownfield sites for the development.

He has also been in touch with local councillors of all political parties to put forward his concerns.

Read more:

• HBC has said it is now looking for UK engineers to fix the problems at Knaresborough pools.
• Four major transport schemes hoping to improve Harrogate are up for debate today. 

A total of £23 million is set to be spent on leisure facilities in the district, including the Knaresborough rebuild.

Although only at design stage, the council has confirmed Alliance Leisure Services has been appointed to work on the project.

A council spokesman said:

“We have carried out an options appraisal to evaluate potential sites in Knaresborough.

“Each site was judged against set criteria including; location, physical appearance, access as well as any planning or legal factors that may influence the decision. Based on the work carried out, the existing site has been recommended for the location of the new leisure centre.

“Although the existing site in Knaresborough has been recommended, we are still in the early stages and no formal plans have been submitted.

“The current venue is nearing 30 years old, is operating at capacity, only provides a swimming pool and has a number of ongoing maintenance issues which are not resolvable without significant investment.”

The current site was one of four options put forward by the council. The others included Hay-a-Park and Conyngham Hall.