Council: 17 ‘unacceptable risks’ at Harrogate Town forced us to ban fans

North Yorkshire County Council has revealed 17 “unacceptable risks” led it to ban fans from Harrogate Town’s friendly against Sunderland on Saturday just 24 hours before kick-off.

The risks included an inadequate level of stewarding, the CCTV system not being tested under match conditions and the ground’s control room, which oversees fan safety, not being connected to a phone line or the public address system.

In a statement sent today to the Stray Ferret, Matt O’Neill, assistant director for growth, planning and trading standards at NYCC, said the council sent a trading standards officer to last Wednesday’s friendly against Rotherham after safety concerns were raised.

It said the club submitted a risk assessment and stewarding plan on the morning before the Sunderland fixture that identified seven unacceptable risks. This was reviewed by NYCC officers, who found another 10 risks.

The statement said:

“We therefore concluded that there were 17 areas of unacceptable risk in total.”

The statement added the council was in discussions with the club to overcome the issues before the first home fixture of the new English Football League Division Two season against Rochdale on August 7 but that “the safety of everyone entering the facility must come first”.

Read more:

The Stray Ferret requested an interview with Harrogate Town’s managing director Garry Plant today but was told he was on leave. Nobody else from the club was put forward for an interview.

The club released a statement this afternoon that said it was “working hard behind the scenes to rectify the issues raised”.

It added:

“We would like to reiterate our sincere apologies to those supporters who had planned to attend but could not, through no fault of their own.

“Clearly this is a testing period for the club and we appreciate your continued support as we work through the issues raised.”

Fans have voiced concerns that the club’s opening home game of the new season will be played in front of an empty stadium due to unresolved issues.

Katherine Swinn, speaking on behalf of the Harrogate Town Independent Supporters Club, told the Stray Ferret yesterday that fans had “numerous unanswered questions”.

She said:

“I think the club have dealt with the situation very poorly. The lack of communication is appalling. This situation needs to be addressed urgently and a full and frank statement provided by the club otherwise the speculation will continue.”

Here is the full statement from Matt O’Neill, assistant director for growth, planning and trading standards at NYCC.

“Following safety concerns raised with us, our trading standards officers attended the match held last Wednesday night between Harrogate Town FC and Rotherham United.

“At this point it was clear there were a number of urgent matters to be addressed at the football ground, if the Sunderland match was to go ahead as planned last Saturday.

“The risk assessment and stewarding plan the club subsequently provided on Friday (23 July) morning identified seven unacceptable risks. Our officers reviewed the risk assessment and found that mitigation measures in place for a further ten risks were insufficient and we therefore concluded that there were 17 areas of unacceptable risk in total.

“These included an inadequate level of stewarding and a lack of effective communication between stewards and lack of confirmation about medical support. They also included the fact that the control room where safety of the ground is overseen, was not connected up to the public address system or the fire panels, had no phone line and a CCTV system which had not been tested under match conditions.

“Discussions now continue to see what can be done to find a safe solution looking ahead. The safety of everyone entering the facility must come first.”

“Together with partner agencies in the Safety Advisory Group we pulled out all the stops to try to support the club to deal with a range of safety measures that had to be addressed to enable the match to go ahead.

“Safety standards are put in place to protect the spectators and ensure a safe match by the Sports Ground Safety Association (an executive non-departmental public body, sponsored by the Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport) and, as the public would expect, they must be met.”

Harrogate Town fans fear season opener will be played behind closed doors

Harrogate Town fans are worried the club’s opening home game of the new season will be played in front of an empty stadium.

Fans were barred from a pre-season friendly against Sunderland at the EnviroVent Stadium on Saturday less than 24 hours before kick-off because North Yorkshire County Council said a number of safety issues at the ground “made them uneasy”.

The council said these were not covid-related but were due to medical support, stewarding, and spectator safety.

The club released a statement saying it “sincerely apologised for the inconvenience caused” but has released no further details about why the match could not proceed. It did, however, say it would work with the council’s safety advisory group to address the points raised for future fixtures.

About 800 Sunderland fans had tickets refunded and the cancellation, coupled with the lack of information since, has also upset home fans.

It’s also led to speculation about whether the issues will be resolved before the season-opening match at home to Rochdale on August 7, and whether fans could once again by forced to watch Town on a livestream as they did for most of last season.

Katherine Swinn, speaking on behalf of the Harrogate Town Independent Supporters Club, told the Stray Ferret fans had “numerous unanswered questions”.

Read more:

Ms Swinn said:

“The club’s last minute statement on Friday led to significant speculation, anger, concern and numerous unanswered questions being raised. None of these matters have been addressed by the club. Some welcome clarification was provided by North Yorkshire County Council following their statement over the weekend regarding the safety issues which led to the match having to take place behind closed doors. However, the silence from the club is deafening.

“There has been no communication, clarification or any attempt by the club to address the numerous concerns and unanswered questions that have been raised nor to provide any reassurance that supporters will be able to attend the match against Rochdale. Instead the club have today reminded people that they have until this Friday to renew their season ticket for this season when supporters don’t even know if they will be allowed into the ground for the Rochdale match.

“I think the club have dealt with the situation very poorly. The lack of communication is appalling. This situation needs to be addressed urgently and a full and frank statement provided by the club otherwise the speculation will continue.”

Town are due to host their final pre-season friendly against Doncaster Rovers at the EnviroVent Stadium on Sunday.

A Harrogate Town spokesman said the club was awaiting further information before commenting on future fixtures.

North Yorkshire County Council said it awaited an individual match risk assessment and stewarding plan from the club.

Fans barred from Harrogate Town match vs Sunderland due to safety fears

Harrogate Town’s pre-season friendly against Sunderland today will be played behind closed doors after county council safety officials raised concerns.

Just 24 hours before the match, the club said it received a letter from North Yorkshire County Council‘s safety advisory group informing them of issues which “made them uneasy”. No further details were revealed.

About 800 Sunderland fans were believed to have been due to travel south for the match at the EnviroVent Stadium

There are just two weeks to go until Town’s first match of the season at home to Rochdale.

Read more:

It’s another blow for Town supporters, who last week were denied the chance of watching their side play against Premier League Newcastle United’s first team after a covid outbreak forced Magpies manager Steve Bruce to send an under-23s team instead.

Town said supporters who bought a ticket for the Sunderland game would receive a full refund.

A Harrogate Town statement said:

“At just after 2pm on Friday 23rd July the club received a letter from North Yorkshire County Council safety advisory group who had identified a number of issues that made them uneasy about the match going ahead with a crowd.

“We are working with the SAG to address the points they have raised for future fixtures.

“All supporters who purchased a ticket for the fixture will receive a full refund.

“The fixture will be available to watch live free of charge via Sunderland AFC’s official website.

“Anyone who had already purchased a stream at £10 via live.harrogatetownafc.com will be refunded.

“We sincerely apologise for the inconvenience caused”

A Sunderland AFC statement said:

“SAFC understands that supporters will be extremely disappointed by this news and its last-minute nature, with many fans incurring considerable personal expense to put travel plans in place.

“We share this disappointment and will work closely with HTFC to ensure that all ticket holders receive a full refund as soon as possible.

“Following today’s update stating that supporters would no longer be permitted to attend the fixture, SAFC has taken the decision to stream the fixture on the SAFSee platform free of charge.

Supporters who have already purchased a streaming pass will also receive a full refund.”

County council officials said the club submitted a risk assessment and stewarding plan on Friday morning following safety concerns raised after the Rotherham United game on Wednesday night.

However, the authority said the assessment and plan was “unfortunately not sufficient”. It added that “discussions continue to see what can be done to find a safe solution looking ahead”.

Among the issues that needed to be addressed were medical support, stewarding and spectator safety, according to the council.

Matt O’Neill, assistant director for growth, planning and trading standards at NYCC, said:

“Together with partner agencies in the Safety Advisory Group we have pulled out all the stops to try to support the club to deal with a range of safety measures that had to be addressed to enable the match to go ahead.

“Safety standards are put in place to protect the spectators and ensure a safe match by the Sports Ground Safety Association (an executive non-departmental public body, sponsored by the Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport) and, as the public would expect, they must be met.

“We recognise that this will be disappointing for the fans who were looking forward to the friendly match against Sunderland AFC, especially after such a difficult last season due to covid restrictions. However, the safety of everyone entering the facility must come first.”

Harrogate Town promotion-winning goalkeeper joins Bristol Rovers

Harrogate Town goalkeeper James Belshaw has joined Bristol Rovers on a permanent transfer.

The shot stopper, who won two promotions with Town, held the number one shirt for his entire time at the club since joining from Tamworth in June 2017.

He will now join the fellow League Two club, who are managed by former Manchester City, Newcastle and Burnley midfielder Joey Barton.

Belshaw was part of the historic promotion-winning side from the National League and played in the 3-1 play-off final win over Notts County at Wembley last year.

He was also named in the National League North Team of the Year, National League Team of the Year and was Supporters Club Player of the Year on two occasions.

A spokesperson for Harrogate Town said:

“Off the pitch, Belshaw has played a big part in the local community, inspiring a generation of young goalkeepers through sessions at our Player Development Centre.

“The departing stopper has undoubtedly been a big part in our success in recent years and for that we would like to place on record our sincere thanks for his efforts.”

Read more:

Harrogate Town welcomed keeper Mark Oxley from Southend United at the beginning of July, one of seven new signings announced this summer.

Harrogate Town fan groups locked in bitter dispute over new supporters trust

Two groups of Harrogate Town fans are locked in an increasingly bitter dispute over the launch of a new supporters trust.

Last year Town ascended to the English Football League for the first time in the club’s history and chairman Irving Weaver has ambitions to fill the club’s newly improved Envirovent Stadium on Wetherby Road with 5,000 fans.

But the club’s success and increasing professionalism on the field is being accompanied by growing pains off it.

In recent weeks, a group of Town fans has launched a trust called the Harrogate Town Supporters Trust to give supporters a voice.

Other football league clubs, such as Sheffield Wednesday and Bradford City already have fans trusts, which are democratically run and governed by the Financial Conduct Authority.

However, members of the Harrogate Town Supporters Club, which has been running for several years, believe the trust is an attempt to undermine their work.

Leaflets about the newly-formed trust were circulated to Town fans at Sunday’s pre-season friendly against Newcastle United under-23s at Wetherby Road. This alarmed many members of the supporters club, with some accusing the trust on Facebook of underhand tactics.

There was also anger that the newly-formed trust plans to put on coaches for away games, which supporters club committee member Jordan Ford has organised for many seasons.

However, the chair of the trust has said alternative away travel is needed because some fans’ drunken behaviour deters some families and fans from travelling.

Pain and heartache

Phil Holdsworth is the fan liaison officer at Harrogate Town. It’s a volunteer position aimed at improving relations between the club and fans.

He told the Stray Ferret that the trust, which says it is independent of the club, will help the club appeal to a wider supporter base and attract new supporters from as far afield as Malaysia and Vietnam.

Much of the supporters club’s anger towards the trust is due to a disagreement over when it learned of the trust being set up.

On Monday, the supporters club committee issued a statement saying it had only become aware of the trust’s formation six weeks ago.

However, Mr Holdsworth said he had a meeting with members of the supporters club in November last year when he explained how it could apply to become an affiliate of the FSA , the national body that represents football supporters.

He claims the supporters club decided not to proceed with the idea.

He said:

“I assumed they would consider it but I never heard or saw anything, Why are they not giving their members the full picture?”.

Mr Holdsworth was also advising a different group of fans on how to become a trust, which led to the formation of the new organisation. He said the fallout has led to “aggressive” criticism of him online.

He praised Mr Ford, of the supporters club, for organising away game travel but said many fans “don’t appreciate their drinking habits”.

He added he hoped the two sets of fans’ differences could be resolved:

“Nobody wants this pain and heartache. Animosity will cause division. It’s in everyone’s interests to work together.”

Best interests of the club

Clare Bridge, chair of the newly formed trust, told the Stray Ferret she too hoped the two groups could put aside their differences for the good of the club.

However, she said she would not take her 12-year-old son on the supporters club’s bus due to what she called “drunken behaviour”.

She said:

“Lots of families are being put off. I would never, ever, get on the bus.”

Ms Bridge said members of the trust were approached by Harrogate Town about forming the organisation and a more collective voice would give fans greater influence in how the club is run.

“It’s happening so it would be nice to work together. There’s always a solution.”

Lack of communication

Supporters club committee member Katherine Swinn released a statement on behalf of the committee on Monday that aimed to assuage fears the group would be replaced.

She told the Stray Ferret members were unhappy about a “lack of communication” over the way the trust had been set up.

She said:

“[It was] essentially due to the lack of communication, the way it has been set up and the continued insistence that we were informed in advance prior to the meeting in early June.

“The supporters club was not approached at any stage about becoming a trust either by Phil Holdsworth, the club or anyone else.”

She said there was “room for both” a supporters club and a trust.

“It is common for league clubs to have both trusts and supporters clubs. They are able to exist and run side by side. Ultimately whether it’s a supporters club or trust the main aims are to support the club, look after the fans and also grow the fan base too. There is room for both.”

Ms Swinn said for the past three seasons the club has put on family-friendly coaches alongside its usual coach for many away games. For the upcoming season, this will also include most games in the north of England.

“Our supporters are fully aware that they are representing both the club and the supporters club when travelling to away matches and the committee will act on behaviour which we consider to be inappropriate and/or which may impact on the reputation of the club, or supporters club.”

Harrogate Town declined to comment.

Newcastle to send under-23 team to Harrogate tomorrow after covid outbreak

Newcastle United are to bring an under-23 team to Harrogate tomorrow rather than a first team squad due to covid.

The Premier League side announced the news this afternoon after goalkeeper Karl Darlow tested positive.

Although every other player and staff member within Newcastle’s first team group has returned negative tests, fellow goalkeepers Mark Gillespie and Freddie Woodman have gone into isolation for 10 days after being identified as close contacts.

Consequently Newcastle will send a first team to York tomorrow and an under-23 team to Harrogate to minimise mixing between the groups.

Magpies manager Steve Bruce said:

“I have spoken to Simon Weaver, who was very understanding, and I would like to apologise to any Harrogate supporters who have bought tickets thinking first team players were coming.

“Ultimately, we have to follow the advice from medical professionals and take proactive steps to protect players and we simply can’t mix up the dressing rooms, which was our initial plan.”

The first ever match between Harrogate and the six-times FA Cup winners was the pick of Town’s pre-season friendlies.

Kick off is at 2pm tomorrow  at the EnviroVent Stadium on Wetherby Road.

Read more:

 

Harrogate Town bolsters squad with two more signings

Harrogate Town have signed two more players ahead of their second-ever campaign in League Two.

The former West Ham left-back Lewis Page has joined Simon Weaver’s squad after spending last season at Exeter City in League Two.

Versatile midfielder and former Liverpool youth player Nathan Sheron joins after four years with League One outfit Fleetwood Town.

The 25-year-old Page signed for West Ham aged nine and made his first-team debut in July 2015, playing in a Europa League qualifying round.

He was unable to break into their Premier League team and has since played for Cambridge United, Coventry City and Charlton Athletic.

He said:

“I would say I’m the ‘modern day’ type left-back. Obviously I pride myself on my defending, I try to do that first and foremost but then getting forward is a bonus.

“I like to get forward a lot and put crosses in and try and affect the game by making assists.”

Read more:

Twenty-three-year-old Sheron signed for Liverpool aged seven and spent 10 years in the Anfield club’s famous youth system before joining Fleetwood in 2016.

He said:

“I’m an honest player and I’ll play wherever the manager puts me. I wear my heart on my sleeve and won’t shirk out of a tackle so hopefully I can play as many games as possible and try to kick us up the league.

“It’s an upcoming club so hopefully there’s a lot more to come.”

Weaver had already bolstered his squad with five new signings: Mark Oxley, Rory McArdle, Luke Armstrong, Danilo Orsi and Alex Pattison.

Town welcome Premier League team Newcastle United to the Envirovent Stadium for a pre-season friendly on Sunday.

Harrogate Town manager looks up to ‘principled and honest’ Gareth Southgate

Harrogate Town boss Simon Weaver has paid tribute to Gareth Southgate, who he said has paved the way for football managers to be “principled and honest”.

Weaver told the Stray Ferret that he first met at the England manager, who lives locally, at a gym and they have built up a friendship over the years.

Ahead of the National League play-off final at Wembley last summer, Weaver invited Southgate to give the Town players a motivational team-talk before the biggest game in their history.

Weaver said:

“His emotional intelligence is second to none.

“He’s obviously an outstanding communicator. His values show great honesty.”

The Town boss said that during his own playing career, managers wouldn’t always explain why he was left out of a game, which led to a loss of respect.

In a team full of superstars, he said it is a credit to Southgate’s man-management skills that the players are all firmly behind him, no matter who is chosen for the final 11.

He said:

“There’s no dissent in the squad. The buy-in from his players is second to none.”

But he said it’s a mistake to label Southgate as “just a nice guy”.

“He’s not controversial but has a steely edge.”

Read more:

Weaver said Harrogate should “cherish and be proud” of Southgate, and said that he tries to run Harrogate Town with similar values.

Weaver added:

“He’s the perfect fit for an England manager, no job is too small. I look up to him and I can’t help but admire him.

“He’s paved the way to be principled and not have a big front.”

He also has an amusing anecdote. A couple of years ago, Weaver bumped into Southgate in a clothes shop in Harrogate and they had a long chat. Afterwards, the shop owner nudged the Town boss, not knowing who he was, and asked:

“Was that really Gareth Southgate?”

Harrogate Town reveal ticketing arrangements for first two pre-season matches

Harrogate Town season ticket holders are to be entered into a ballot for tickets to the club’s first pre-season friendlies at home.

Tickets for Town’s games against Premier League outfit Newcastle Untied on July 18 and Championship club Rotherham United on July 21 will be balloted ahead of the games.

Both matches will be held at the EnviroVent Stadium this month and will be held in front of a limited crowd.

Announcing the ticket arrangements, the club said:

“Due to the amount of Harrogate Town seated season ticket holders exceeding the amount of seats available, all seated Harrogate Town season ticket holders as of July 9 will be entered into a ballot for a seat in the family stand, with those unsuccessful offered a seat in an alternative standing area.

“Unfortunately, for these two fixtures only, season ticket holders will not be seated in their chosen seat, each supporter successful in the ballot for a seat will be allocated their seat. Seated season ticket holders will be contacted with the result of the ballot.”

The club added that those season ticket holders not wishing to attend because they cannot sit in a seat will be given a free streaming pass in compensation.

Read more:

A limited number of standing tickets will go on sale from 12pm on Monday July 12 at the club shop on Commercial Street. Tickets will not be available online.

General sale tickets will be will be sold on a first-come first-served basis at £10 for adults, £8 concessions and £2 for under-18s.

The club added:

“The fixture will fall under the same protocols as our last home match with supporters, which includes staggered arrival and departure of supporters and a one way system in place in the stadium.”

Town are set for trips to Huddersfield, Brighouse Town and Darlington as part of their pre-season schedule.

League One club Sunderland are also set for a trip to Wetherby Road on July 24.

Harrogate Town manager Simon Weaver signs new contract

Simon Weaver has signed a new three-year deal to stay on as manager of Harrogate Town.

Me Weaver first took the reins at Wetherby Road in May 2009 when he was appointed player-manager by his chairman father Irving Weaver.

The club has been transformed in the 12 years since. It’s gone from being a Conference North club in the sixth tier of English football to finishing 17th last season in Division Two of the English Football League — the fourth tier.

Weaver, who was born in Doncaster, is currently the longest-serving manager in the professional game in England.

He said:

“This club has been a massive part of my life for for 12 years, so to take it to 15 is fantastic for me personally.

“I’m excited about the challenge ahead and have as much appetite for it now as I did 12 years ago.”

Read more:

Town’s assistant manager Paul Thirwell has also signed a new three-year contract with the club.

Thirwell, who played for Sheffield United and Sunderland, has worked under Weaver since January 2017.

Their close relationship was captured in the BT Sport documentary Proud To Be Town, which chronicled the club’s promotion to League Two in 2019-20.

Weaver added:

“Paul and I are very close, he definitely alleviates pressure on my job with what he brings to the table, he’s a good presence, has a great personality and sense of humour, but overall he is a really good person, which is important to me.”

Town will begin their second-ever campaign in the English Football League with a home tie against Rochdale on August 7.