North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe has resigned as a councillor on Harrogate Borough Council.
The news has not been publicly announced yet. However, the council’s website confirms she is no longer a councillor.
The Stray Ferret was alerted to the news by another councillor and has attempted to contact Ms Metcalfe directly, as well as the Office of the North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner and Harrogate Borough Council for further details. So far only Harrogate Borough Council has replied to clarify there won’t be a by-election.
A spokesman said:
“Under the terms of the Structural Changes Order we are unable to run by-elections to fill vacancies arising after September 30, unless the total number of unfilled vacancies exceeds one third of the whole number of members. Therefore there will not be a by-election for this seat.”
Ms Metcalfe, a Conservative, was elected to the £74,000 commissioner’s role in November last year after her predecessor Philip Allott resigned.
At the time she represented Claro on Harrogate Borough Council and Knaresborough on North Yorkshire County Council.
Read more:
- People waiting up to an hour for 101 calls to be answered, says North Yorkshire Police
- Criminals in North Yorkshire could make written apologies to victims
She did not seek re-election to the county council in May’s local elections but retained her borough council seat. Her departure today comes four months to the day before the borough council is abolished to make way for the new North Yorkshire Council.
Ms Metcalfe has strong local connections: she was born in Ripon and now lives in Aldborough, near Boroughbridge.
She joined the Conservatives in 2014 and has twice stood unsuccessfully for Parliament: first in Doncaster Central and then in Leeds West.
A fire service review she led this year generated controversy because of its decision to reduce the number of fire engines stationed at Harrogate from two to one overnight.
Police plea to call out drink drivers amid increasing Harrogate district incidentsNorth Yorkshire Police is urging people to alert the force to suspected drink drivers amid concern over increasing cases.
The force, along with North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue, today launched its Christmas drink and drug drive campaign.
Called ‘Save a life and call It In’, it encourages people to ring 999 if they suspect someone is behind the wheel under the influence of drink or drugs.
The campaign, which runs until January 1, will also see officers patrolling the county in marked and unmarked police vehicles and carrying out roadside checks.
Superintendent Emma Aldred, head of specialist operations for the force, told the Stray Ferret:
She said:
“We do drink drive campaigns throughout the year, but we do see an increase around the festive period because people come together a lot more and there are office parties, house parties and with the cost of living we are seeing a lot more home drinking.
“We are seeing increased drinking and people thinking they are okay to drive the next morning or that night, which is just not acceptable.”
‘We are seeing an increase’
During last year’s campaign – which ran from December 1 to January 1 – there were 137 people arrested for drink or drug driving in the county.
From the 137 arrests, 120 were men and 17 were women. 72 people of the 137 were charged with an offence. A total of 25 of the arrests were made following a crash.

Tony Peel, group manager at North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service.
Tony Peel, group manager for North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue, also said that the service was now seeing an increase in drink driving incidents across Harrogate and North Yorkshire.
He said:
“We are starting to see a slight increase.
“I think with the messages we did many years ago, it [drink driving] did go down. But it does seem to be growing a little bit and we are seeing an increase.”
Read more:
- Criminals in North Yorkshire could make written apologies to victims
- Harrogate man jailed for spitting on pensioner at train station
The plea to call out drink and drug drivers has been endorsed by actor Mark Charnock, who plays Marlon Dingle in television soap Emmerdale.
Mr Charnock took part in a mock car crash at Harrogate Fire Station this week to demonstrate the impact that drink driving can have on someone.

Mark Charnock was cut from a car as part of a demonstration at Harrogate Fire Station.
The demonstration saw him cut out of a car by fire crews and put onto a stretcher before being lifted to safety.
Mr Charnock said:
“If this was real, if you add in real horror into the mix of what I’ve just been through, I can’t begin to imagine what it would be like.
“You just would not wish it on your worst enemy.”
The campaign against drink and drug driving will run from December 1, 2022, until January 1, 2023.
Death of Harrogate man in his 30s not being treated as suspiciousNorth Yorkshire Police said today it was not treating the death of a Harrogate man in his 30s as suspicious.
Police put up a cordon after they were called by the ambulance service to a flat on East Parade last Thursday evening.
A nearby resident contacted the Stray Ferret today to say other people in the flat were evacuated and put up in hotels while crime scene investigators carried out work.
The person wanted to know why there had been so subsequent police information informing nearby residents about the incident and offering reassurance.
Police said in response to a request for information today:
“At the time of reporting, his death was treated as unexplained, therefore a cordon was put in place to protect the scene while officers carried out a full examination of the property where the death occurred.
“Following a post mortem examination, officers do not believe that there are any suspicious circumstances that led to the man’s death.
“A report will be prepared for the coroner to inform a future inquest into the man’s death.”
Read more:
- People waiting up to an hour for 101 calls to be answered, says North Yorkshire Police
- Man suffers serious head injuries on Harrogate’s Bower Street
Jennyfields closure order: warrant issued for arrest of man
A warrant has been issued for the arrest of a Harrogate man who allegedly breached a closure order on a house in Jennyfields.
The closure order, granted by Harrogate Magistrates Court on November 3, banned anyone except an authorised council officer and one other named person from entering the property for three months.
Harrogate Borough Council said in a statement after the hearing it applied for the order “following concerns about drug use and anti-social behaviour”.
Aaron John Herbert, 49, of Deane Place, Harrogate, was due to appear in court on Thursday charged with entering the premises in contravention of the order.
But he did not appear, prompting magistrates at Harrogate to issue a warrant for his arrest.
North Yorkshire Police said this morning:
“The court warrant is still in place and enquiries are ongoing to locate him.”
Read more:
- Council closes Jennyfields house amid anti-social behaviour concerns
- Harrogate man jailed for three years for ‘savage’ attack
People waiting up to an hour for 101 calls to be answered, says North Yorkshire Police
People are waiting for up to an hour for a 101 call to be answered, a senior North Yorkshire Police officer has said.
Mike Walker, assistant chief constable at the force, told a North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner public accountability meeting that the figure was “not acceptable”.
He said that the force had an average answer time of eight minutes and 47 seconds for October 2022 – four times the national standard.
The target for police force’s across the country is to answer 80% of non-emergency calls within two minutes.
ACC Walker said the long waiting times for 101 was the reason why the force’s abandonment rate was so high. This refers to the number of people giving up.
He said:
“On a daily basis we look at that from a chief officer team and I know there have been people waiting between half an hour and an hour on 101 on some days.
“It’s just not acceptable and this is why we have an abandonment rate of 20%. We should not be having more than 5% on 101.”
Read more:
- Police commissioner: 101 line deluged by ‘neighbours complaining about each other’
- Harrogate district people asked for views on police 101 and 999 calls
ACC Walker told the meeting that Humberside Police had agreed to carry out a peer review of the force’s call handling and help them improve.
He added that the police were keen to improve the call times and return the control room to an “outstanding” rating.

Zoe Metcalfe, Mike Walker and Mabs Hussain, deputy chief constable, at the public accountability meeting.
He said:
“We know how we need to achieve that.
“It’s a question of putting the right plans in place and having the relevant discussions and then, over the next 12 months, it’s a question of getting back to where we need to be by serving the public of North Yorkshire with an outstanding control room.
“That needs to be the aim.”
Zoe Metcalfe, the North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner, said the aim needed to be “a lot quicker than 12 months”, but added she accepted that “these things take time”.
The move comes as concerns over the length of time it takes to answer 101 calls has been a long-running concern across the county.
Ms Metcalfe’s predecessor, Philip Allott, was told by North Yorkshire county councillors last year that the non-emergency line was “not fit for purpose and it hasn’t been fit for purpose for the last eight years” and that “the phone just doesn’t get answered”.
Police find missing man with Harrogate linksNorth Yorkshire Police has confirmed that a missing man has been found following an appeal.
Officers said they were “extremely concerned” for the welfare of the 36-year-old.
A police statement said the man was found safe and well.
Read more:
- Owners of Harrogate trophy store retire after 40 years
- Panto legend Tim Stedman brings Christmas magic to Harrogate again
Motorcyclist seriously injured in Harrogate district crash
A motorcyclist was taken to hospital with serious injuries following a collision in the Harrogate district this morning.
North Yorkshire Police attended a two-vehicle collision involving a car and a motorbike on the A59 at Moor Monkton at 5.49am.
According to police, the motorbike was travelling westbound along the road and the car — a white VW — was travelling in the opposite direction when they collided.
Further details of the injuries, or the man’s name, have not been released.
The A59, which is the main road linking Harrogate and York, was closed between Station Road to York Road and Maston Lane to York Road.
A police statement said:
“If you witnessed the incident, have dashcam footage or any other information which could help our investigation, please email: Richard.harrison@northyorkshire.police.uk or call 101, select option 2 and ask for TC Smith.
“Please quote reference 12220208147.”
Read more:
- Police close A59 at Kirk Hammerton after serious crash
- Concern over lack of secondary school at new Harrogate district town
Police close A59 at Kirk Hammerton after serious crash
The A59 at Kirk Hammerton is closed in both directions due to serious crash.
North Yorkshire Police said the road is closed between Station Road to York Road and Maston Lane to York Road.
A police statement added:
“Motorists are advised to find an alternative route if travelling between Harrogate and York.”
We will update this story as we get more information.
Missing Knaresborough man found after police appealA missing Knaresborough man has been found after a police appeal.
The 68-year-old was last seen on Tuesday (November 22) leaving his home.
North Yorkshire Police described him as of slim build, 5 ft 6, with long grey hair which is balding on top.
A police statement issued this morning confirmed he was found following the appeal.
Read more:
- ‘Harrogate firefighters being used as guinea pigs’, says union
- Harrogate man jailed for spitting on pensioner at train station
Criminals in North Yorkshire could make written apologies to victims
Criminals could be asked to make written apologies to victims under new plans for policing in North Yorkshire.
North Yorkshire Police Fire and Crime Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe is consulting on a community remedy document.
Each local policing body must have a community remedy document for its area that is informed by consultation.
The document includes options for dealing with less serious crime and anti-social behaviour.
The options being considered in North Yorkshire include asking criminals to make verbal or written apologies or to sign acceptable behaviour contracts in which they pledge to change their behaviour.
Victims of crime, such as street drinking, littering, noise, animal problems, vehicle nuisance or trespass, will be able to discuss the finalised community remedy options with a police officer and provide their preferred course of action for the officer to consider.
Ms Metcalfe today opened a consultation on plans jointly drawn up with North Yorkshire Police.
The options people are asked to comment on are:
- Restorative Justice: bringing together criminals and victims in a safe and supported way.
- Verbal or written apology to victims.
- Signing acceptable behaviour contracts in which offenders pledge to change their behaviour by agreeing to particular conditions or actions e.g. participating in an educational programme or agreeing not to go to a particular area.
- A referral to a local rehabilitative, educational or diversionary activity, to support an improvement in behaviour: via a community-based support scheme.
- Personal/community reparation: e.g. repairing or paying for the damage caused.
- Mediation to support the resolution of disputes.
Read more:
- ‘Harrogate firefighters being used as guinea pigs’, says union
- Harrogate man jailed for spitting on pensioner at train station
The community remedy process aims to support victims by giving them reassurance that their offender is remorseful. The aim is to promote public confidence in the out-of-court disposal process.
This is a method for avoiding court proceedings and criminal charges when an offender is known and admits the offence.
Causes ‘misery’
Ms Metcalfe said:
“Anti-social behavioural problems can cause misery in communities, and I want members of the public to feel empowered by the community remedy, in that they have a say in the best way to prevent re-offending and feel reassured by the actions taken by the police.
“Please complete the short survey to inform my decision on the final options.”
Lisa Winward, Chief Constable of North Yorkshire Police, said:
“The community remedy will provide victims of low level crime and anti-social behaviour with a greater say in how an offender is held to account for their actions.
“We know that crimes and behaviour of this kind can take their toll on individuals and communities and I welcome the commissioner’s survey to better understand the menu of remedial options that communities feel best fit the crime.”
To take part in the seven-week survey, which closes on January 10, click here.