A watchdog has urged North Yorkshire’s police commissioner to delay the appointment of a new chief constable for up to 15 months, partly to ensure the top police officer sees eye-to-eye with an incoming elected mayor.
All but four members of North Yorkshire and York’s police, fire and crime panel voted to recommend to commissioner Zoe Metcalfe that she postpones finding a successor to chief constable Lisa Winward, who announced last month she would retire in March next year.
A meeting of the panel at City of York Council heard Ms Winward’s retirement had come at a particularly inopportune time as she would be leaving the key role just weeks before a mayor, who would set policing priorities, was expected to be elected to an incoming combined authority.
Panel members heard while the commissioner had decided to launch the recruitment process, with a likely appointment date in April, if the process was launched after the expected mayoral election in May, a new chief constable may not be appointed until 2025.
Ms Metcalfe told the meeting she had been independently advised to launch the recruitment as soon as practically possible by a string of national bodies and top officials, including the chiefs of the police inspectorate and the college of policing as well as Unison.
She said:
“I am not satisfied that deferring the decision to the incoming mayor, which would incur inevitable delay, for many months, and even extending until 2025, is the right decision for the public, delivery of service and North Yorkshire Police.”
Read more:
- North Yorkshire chief constable announces retirement
- Police commissioner Zoe Metcalfe rejects appointing interim chief constable
Following concerns that uncertainty over who the incoming mayor would be could deter some candidates from applying to be chief constable, she added the role of leading the force was an “immensely exciting prospect” for any police leader.
She underlined that if the process was delayed until after the election the deputy chief constable would be asked to step up for “a very prolonged period of time”.
She said her experience of working with chief constables was that they were “very professional people” who would go out of their way to make a working relationship with the new mayor and deliver the mayor’s priorities.
Panel member Martin Walker, a former judge, backed the commissioner’s decision, saying one of the main criteria for a chief constable was to be “independent and strong”.
He said:
“If two people at the top of the most difficult, important and complex jobs can’t get on, and it has to depend on personalities, I think that’s wrong and frankly it wouldn’t be fit to do the job.
“In my own experience, throughout my career, I have had to work with people I don’t like, and I’m sure some didn’t like me, but it’s necessary to do that in life, and in my view you have to get on with it.”
However, several panel members said the relationship between the mayor and chief constable was vital and they wanted to see the priorities of the incoming mayor part of the process for the selection of a new chief constable.
The meeting the commissioner repeatedly pressed to pause the recruitment process until after a mayor is elected.
Cllr Lindsay Burr, who represents Malton, said it would be an incorrect decision for the public to appoint a chief constable when the force’s strategic direction had not been set by the incoming mayor.
Huby councillor and former police officer Malcolm Taylor said while moving ahead with recruiting a chief constable might be a good decision in the short-term, the appointment was a long-term role.
Police link Scotton collision to Knaresborough car theftNorth Yorkshire Police believe a collision in Scotton could be linked to a recent car theft in Knaresborough.
Emergency services, including North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue, were called to the incident, which happened on Market Flat Lane in Scotton at 6.17pm yesterday.
Fire crews found a 53-reg blue Land Rover Freelander on its roof on arrival.
A police spokesperson told the Stray Ferret:
“The vehicle had overturned and two young men ran off into a nearby field, off Scotton Way.
“Despite ground searched and assistance from a police airplane, they have not yet been located.”
The force does not believe the men suffered serious injuries.
It added an investigation into the theft of the Land Rover Freelander in Knaresborough, which happened on Wednesday, October 11, has been linked to the collision.
The car is believed to have been stolen between 2pm and 6pm that day.
A spokesperson added:
“Witnesses or anyone with dash-cam or doorbell footage are asked to contact North Yorkshire Police on 101, select option 4, and speak to the Force Control Room.”
You can also call Crimestoppers anonymously on 0800 555 111. Quote reference 12230193555 when providing details.
Read more:
- Land Rover found on its roof after Knaresborough collision
- Harrogate road to be closed for another six months
Audi stolen from driveway in Ripon
A car has been stolen from the driveway of a property in Ripon.
North Yorkshire Police said the incident happened on Clotherholme Park, which is off Lark Lane, between midnight and 3.30 am this morning (October 10).
The rear door of the house was damaged and the suspect removed a set of keys.
A white Audi A5 five-door hatchback with the registration FX69 UCG was then stolen from the driveway of the property.
Officers have asked the public to keep an eye out for the stolen vehicle and appealed for any CCTV or doorbell footage that may help the investigation.
A police statement added:
“Anyone with information that could assist the investigation should email Sam.Clarke2@northyorkshire.police.uk .You can also call North Yorkshire Police on 101 and ask for Sam Clarke.
“If you wish to remain anonymous, you can pass information to Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.
“Please quote the North Yorkshire Police reference number 12230192125 when passing information.”
Read more:
- Vandal attack on Ripon home injures occupants
- North Yorkshire fire service to charge businesses for false alarm calls
Balaclava-clad burglars target homes in Harrogate
Police are seeking three men wearing balaclavas who attempted to break into a house in Harrogate.
According to North Yorkshire Police, the would-be burglars were disturbed when they entered a home on Azerley Grove in the Jennyfields area.
The incident happened between midnight and 3am last Saturday (October 7).
The force today appealed for witnesses and information. It said in a statement:
“On the same night, three men were seen on ring doorbell footage approaching a second property nearby.
“One of the men was described as wearing a striped body warmer over a long-sleeved top, he was wearing dark joggers and dark trainers.
“A second man was described as wearing a tracksuit with reflective stripes on the lower legs. All three men were wearing balaclavas.”
The statement urged anyone with information or doorbell footage to email ruby.rutter@northyorkshire.police.uk or call North Yorkshire Police on 101 and ask for Ruby Rutter.
If you wish to remain anonymous, you can pass information to Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.
Quote reference number 12230190164.
Read more:
- Harrogate woman among 16 housemates on Big Brother
- Police commissioner Zoe Metcalfe rejects appointing interim chief constable
Firefighters tackle car fire on A1(M)
Firefighters from Ripon, Masham and Knaresborough used breathing apparatus to tackle a major car fire on the A1(M) today.
Fire engines were called to the southbound carriageway at the junction 49 slip road at 7.24am this morning.
North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service‘s incident report said:
“Crews located the Audi that was well alight and extinguished it using one hose reel jet and two breathing apparatus.
“Crews dampened down and made the vehicle safe before leaving the incident in the hands of the highways agency.”
North Yorkshire Police later posted on social media that “the fire is now out and occupants uninjured”.
Read more:
- Harrogate firefighters rescue man dangling headfirst from ladder
- Washing up liquid frees dog with trapped head in Knaresborough
Nine rapes reported at Harrogate Army Foundation College in 13 months
Nine allegations of rape at Harrogate’s Army Foundation College have been reported to police in the last 13 months.
The figures were revealed in a Freedom of Information response from North Yorkshire Police.
According to the data, nine rapes, two incidents of voyeurism and two sexual assaults were reported to civilian police between July 2022 and August 2023.
No details have been given as to whether the incidents involved recruits or staff at the college.
It comes after the college on Penny Pot Lane, which trains junior soldiers aged 16 and 17, was hit by allegations of abuse and bullying in 2021.
However, ministers defended the organisation and said it had a “much improved climate”.
Baroness Goldie, a Ministry of Defence minister, told the House of Lords in May this year that the college had taken steps to improve and that this was reflected by an Ofsted report in 2021.
However, the new figures raise questions over further allegations of sexual assault and abuse.
Jim Wyke, of the Child Rights International Network, which campaigns for the raising of the military age, said the government should look again at the recruitment age.
He said:
“Ministers must look seriously at making the transition to an all-adult armed forces, recruiting for the armed forces at 18 is the settled consensus in most of the world.”
In response to the figure, a British Army spokesperson said:
“The army is committed to rooting out all forms of inappropriate behaviour and we have a zero-tolerance policy on sexual offences – any personnel convicted of a sexual offence will be dismissed.
“We have very strong safeguarding mechanisms at AFC(H) to ensure junior soldiers have the right support structures. This includes multiple methods of accessing welfare support, including confidential support lines.
“It would be inappropriate to comment on investigations which may be ongoing”
Read more:
- ‘Improved climate’ at Harrogate Army Foundation College after abuse allegations, says minister
- Harrogate Army Foundation College instructor demoted for punching teenage soldiers
- Former Harrogate Army Foundation College instructor sentenced for sex assault
Police locate wanted Ripon man
North Yorkshire Police has found a wanted Ripon man who went missing.
The 23-year-old was released on licence on May 19 this year but the Probation Service has since reported “poor behaviour”.
North Yorkshire Police released a wanted appeal on Friday, but have since located the suspect.
Read more:
- Police release CCTV image after Ripon restaurant attempted burglary
- Police close central Harrogate street after ‘serious sexual assault’ on woman
Police identify man after Ripon restaurant attempted burglary
Police have identified a man they wish to speak to in connection with an attempted burglary at a Ripon restaurant.
The incident happened at Prima Pizzeria on Kirkgate at 11.55pm on Friday, August 18.
Officers said a man tried to gain entry to the rear of the restaurant.
North Yorkshire Police released a CCTV image in connection with the incident and have since identified a man.
A police statement added:
“Anyone with any information is asked to call North Yorkshire Police on 101, select option 2, and ask for the ‘York Initial Enquiry Team’ quoting 12230155915.
“If you wish to remain anonymous, you can pass information to Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.
“Please quote reference number 12230155915 when passing on information.”
Read more:
- Police close central Harrogate street after ‘serious sexual assault’ on woman
- North Yorkshire fire service to charge businesses for false alarm calls
Two injured after stone thrown through Ripon house window
Police have appealed for information after a large stone was thrown through the window of a property in Ripon.
The stone not only smashed the window, but the shards of glass also injured two homeowners who were sitting in their living room at the time.
The incident happened on Redshaw Close at around 12.05am on Friday, September 1.
A North Yorkshire Police statement added:
“Officers are asking people to get in touch if they are aware of anyone who was in the area at the time, have any suggestions of who the suspects may be, or have any CCTV showing suspicious behaviour in the area at the time of the incident.
“Anyone with any information is asked to email adam.deacon2@northyorkshire.police.uk or call North Yorkshire Police on 101, select option 2 and ask for PC Adam Deacon.
“If you wish to remain anonymous, you can pass information to Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.
“Please quote reference number 12230164661 when passing on information.”
Read more:
- Police close central Harrogate street after ‘serious sexual assault’ on woman
- North Yorkshire fire service to charge businesses for false alarm calls
Police close central Harrogate street after ‘serious sexual assault’ on woman
North Yorkshire Police has said it has closed part of Harrogate town centre in response to a report of a serious sexual assault on a woman.
Areas of James Street, Petergate and Market Place have been cordoned off to “allow officers to carry out a full and thorough investigation”, the force said in a statement this afternoon.
Four police officers were stationed at the various points along Petergate at lunchtime as a scene guard to preserve any possible evidence.

Petergate today
The little used route at the rear of James Street is lined with commercial waste bins.
The statement added:
“Enquiries are ongoing to establish the circumstances around the incident.
“Residents and local businesses may notice an increased police presence in the area, as officers continue to gather evidence.”
Read more:
- Police cordon off Harrogate town centre street
- Plan to install electric vehicle charging bays at Harrogate M&S approved