Calvin Robinson Chief Reporter, Author at The Stray Ferret

Unions seek talks on future of council leisure staff

The trade union Unison is seeking urgent talks on the future of Harrogate Borough Council leisure and sports centre staff when venues close this week.

Leisure centres and gyms across the district will shut on Thursday following Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s announcement of a second lockdown in England.

Unison’s local government branch has asked to meet senior managers at the council to discuss the future of those affected.

Union officials said they will be seeking clarity on the futures of staff in sport, leisure and parks, as well as on whether the civic centre should remain open to visitors.

Many council staff, including leisure employees, were redeployed to other services during the spring lockdown to deal with extra demand.

David Houlgate, branch secretary at Unison Harrogate, said council staff had ‘gone the extra mile’ during the pandemic and there was a need to know what would happen to them. He said:

“We have worked tirelessly with the council through the pandemic and we remain hopeful that, provided appropriate health and safety protocols are maintained and followed, HBC will continue to deliver much needed services and support to residents and businesses in the district.”

A spokesperson for Harrogate Borough Council said:

“We are currently having discussions regarding staffing arrangements following the latest government restrictions.”

‘Upset and cynicism’ over October redundancies says Harrogate lawyer

A Harrogate employment lawyer says people who lost their jobs on the last day of October are upset and cynical.

Richard Port, principal solicitor at Boardside Ltd in Harrogate, said he was aware of cases where firms had put restructure plans in place for October 31, so will have lost staff on the same day the Prime Minister announced another lockdown and an extension to furlough.

The furlough scheme will see the government pay for 80% of employee salaries up to £2,500 a month. However, employers will have to cover pension and national insurance contributions.

The scheme was supposed to end on October 31, but now is going to end in early December.

Richard Port, Boardside Legal

Mr Port said some businesses will have met the announcement with surprise.

He said employees could return to their employer to ask for their jobs back, but most businesses have already made restructures due to the end of furlough.

Mr Port said:

“I think people are just disappointed. What they can do is go back to their employer and ask if they can take them back on.

“But I do not think many employers will want to do it.”

He added that the virus was taking its toll on all business.

“It is perfectly viable businesses that are shutting because of this. People are struggling to get their heads around it.

“The classic example is the pub. That is a part of our culture. It is a part of the British way of life and it is going.”

MPs watch: Free school meals, food safety and lockdowns

Every month the Stray Ferret tries to find out what our local MPs have been up to in their constituencies and in the House of Commons.

October saw a key vote on the government’s Agriculture Bill and a motion on free school meals following a high-profile campaign by Manchester United footballer Marcus Rashford.

We asked Harrogate & Knaresborough MP Andrew Jones, Ripon MP Julian Smith, and Selby and Ainsty MP Nigel Adams if they would like to highlight anything in particular that they have been doing this month, but we did not receive a response from any of them.

Here is what we know after analysing their online presence.

Andrew Jones, Harrogate and Knaresborough MP.

In Harrogate and Knaresborough, here is what we found on Mr Jones:

On October 5, Mr Jones voted with the government on the second reading of the Covert Human Intelligence Sources (Criminal Conduct) Bill. The bill looks to provide the power for covert intelligence sources to commit a criminal offence in their duty if necessary, according to the government website.
At Prime Minister’s Questions on October 7, Mr Jones urged Boris Johnson to give a support package to the conference sector. Jones said the the exhibition industry was “really important in Harrogate and Knaresborough”. However, the Prime Minister did not commit to any firm support.
On October 12, Mr Jones voted against an amendment to the Agriculture Bill which would have forced any future trade deal to meet UK food safety and animal welfare requirements. The vote came after demonstrators gathered outside his office in Harrogate urging him and other MPs to agree the amendment.
Mr Jones posted a plea on his website for people to wear a face mask when travelling on buses run by the Harrogate Bus Company. It was his only post throughout October.
On October 20, Mr Jones asked Secretary of State, Matt Hancock, whether a blanket national lockdown was wrong. Mr Hancock agreed that it was.
Mr Jones voted against an opposition motion to extend the provision of £15-a-week school meal vouchers throughout the October half term through to the Easter 2021 holidays. Following a backlash, Mr Jones responded in the local press and in a local Conservative news bulletin email. The email, which the Stray Ferret has seen, said: “I know that many of you will have seen the coverage about free school meals during the holidays in the news lately. I hope that people who know me, or who have been helped by me, would realise that I would not vote to increase child hunger or ensure children starve.”
Mr Jones’s Twitter account now been set to “retweets only”.

Julian Smith, MP for Ripon and Skipton.

In Ripon, here is what we found on Mr Smith:

Mr Smith voted in line with the government on the second reading of the Covert Human Intelligence Sources (Criminal Conduct) Bill on October 5.
Mr Smith posted a response on his website from Harrogate Borough Council on concerns over transport on October 16. It was his only post on the site throughout the month.
Mr Smith tweeted 11 times in October. He published two Facebook posts, one of which was a response from North Yorkshire CCG to the proposed 1,300-home Ripon Barracks scheme. Last night Mr Smith tweeted his support for the county council’s solution to care home visits.
On October 12, Mr Smith voted against the amendment to the Agriculture Bill.
Mr Smith spoke just twice in the House of Commons in October. His last contribution was on October 12 when he urged the Prime Minister to come up with “creative solutions” for loved ones to see relatives in care homes.
Mr Smith voted against the opposition motion on free school meals on October 21.

Nigel Adams, MP for Selby and Ainsty which includes rural Harrogate.

In rural south Harrogate, he is what we found on Mr Adams:

On October 5, Mr Adams tweeted that as Minister of State at the Foreign Office he spoke with Indonesia Deputy Foreign Minister, Mahendra Siregar, about how the two countries could work more closely together.
Mr Adams has tweeted 21 times in October.
Mr Adams voted against the amendment to the Agriculture Bill. In a post on his website, he defended his decision. He said: “Several people have been in touch who appear to have been misled into thinking that Tuesday’s vote on the Agriculture Bill was somehow a vote against our high food standards. This is not the case. In fact, the amendment to the bill which was defeated was well meaning but I believe unnecessary as well as having some negative unintended consequences.”
On October 15, Mr Adams tweeted that the UK would continue to support the Rohingya people who have “faced systemic brutality” and been forced to leave their homes.
Since the start of the month, Mr Adams has posted five times on his website. Posts include further funding for his constituency and coronavirus tier advice.
Mr Adams appeared in the House of Commons seven times in October to answer questions and make statements on such topics as Hong Kong National Security Law and the South China Sea.
Mr Adams voted against the opposition motion on free school meals on October 21.

A further 53 cases of coronavirus confirmed in Harrogate district

A further 53 cases of coronavirus have been confirmed in the Harrogate district, according to Public Health England figures.

It takes the total number of cases up to 2,300 since the start of the pandemic.

Meanwhile, the district’s seven-day case rate up to October 27 has dropped to 239 per 100,000 people. However this remains above the national average of 225.

Currently, 16 patients who have tested positive for coronavirus are being treated at Harrogate District Hospital, according to figures from the hospital trust.

Since the start of the pandemic, 219 covid patients have been treated and discharged, including 14 in the last week, while 86 people have died after testing positive for the virus.

North Yorkshire is now the only county in the region which has not been moved up to a higher local lockdown tier.

From Monday, West Yorkshire and Leeds will be moved into tier three.

However, Richard Webb, director of adult care at North Yorkshire County Council, warned on Wednesday that the county could enter tier two before the end of the week.

Harrogate district set to border tier three Leeds

The Harrogate district faces bordering a tier three area with the highest covid restrictions from next week.

Leeds, along with the rest of West Yorkshire, will enter the highest tier on Monday after cases in areas such as Bradford stand at 485 per 100,000 people.

It means that in Leeds betting shops, casinos and pubs which do not serve meals will close. Mixing of households will also be banned both indoors and outdoors.

But, across the border, pubs will remain open until 10am and people will be able to continue to meet indoors and outdoors while abiding by the rule of six.

North Yorkshire has avoided being moved into a tier two lockdown, despite only having a marginally lower infection rate than some areas which face tougher restrictions.

The county has a case rate of 174 per 100,000 population, according to latest Public Health England data. But North Lincolnshire has a rate of 194 and will enter tier two from Saturday.

Meanwhile, the Harrogate district currently has a seven-day case rate of 242, which is higher than the national average.

East Riding of Yorkshire and Hull will also enter “high risk” restrictions, leaving North Yorkshire surrounded by higher tier areas.

Dr Lincoln Sargeant, director of public health at the county council, said last week that the county was in discussions with the wider county over what tier it should be in.

He said there was a desire to “simplify” and although the county’s infection rate was low compared with its neighbours, it was still influenced by what goes on in surrounding areas.

All areas involved in those discussions are now either in or due to go into a higher tier, apart from North Yorkshire.

But, Richard Webb, director of adult care at the county council, yesterday warned that the county could be in tier two before the end of the week.

He told a North Yorkshire Local Resilience Forum, which is a partnership of emergency agencies, briefing:

“The situation in North Yorkshire is now hanging by a thread. We are currently in tier one but that is really on a knife edge.

“We may even be in a situation at the end of this week where we move into tier two restrictions. But we are hoping that we can prevent that.

“We want to stay in tier one. It is better for livelihoods and for economic wellbeing. Today we are asking people to act now to save lives more than ever.”

The discussions over what tier the county should be in has also raised concern from local MPs.

Kevin Hollinrake, Thirsk and Malton MP, has previously urged the government to look at a district approach to local restrictions.

He told the Stray Ferret it was only fair on businesses to impose tighter measures when there was an “absolute need”.

Harrogate Town FA Cup tie to be broadcast on BT Sport

Harrogate Town’s FA Cup first round tie against non-league Skelmersdale United will be broadcast live on BT Sport.

The fixture against Skelmersdale, who play in the North West Counties League Premier Division, is expected to earn Town £32,500 as part of the Football Association’s live broadcast fee.

The winner of the tie will also receive £16,972 from the FA prize fund, with the losing side receiving £5,657.

Town will host the tie at the EnviroVent Stadium on Wetherby Road on Friday November 6, at 7.45pm.

Skelmersdale United reached the first round for the first time since 1971 last weekend after defeating Stafford Rangers 4-1.

The Lancashire club is also the lowest ranked side left in this year’s FA Cup.

Harrogate district’s coronavirus rate rises above national average

The Harrogate district’s seven-day coronavirus rate has risen above the England average, according to figures released today.

The district now has an infection rate of 242 per 100,000 people compared with a national average of 225. The figures are for the seven-day period to October 26

It comes as a further 58 coronavirus cases have been confirmed in the district today.

It takes the total amount of cases since the start of the pandemic up to 2,247, according to Public Health England data.

Meanwhile, Harrogate District Hospital has reported another death from a patient who tested positive for coronavirus. It is the third death reported in eight days.

According to NHS England figures, it takes the total number of deaths at the hospital to 87.

Yesterday, Richard Webb, director of adult care at North Yorkshire County Council, warned that the county could enter tier two restrictions by the end of the week.

Mr Webb told a briefing of North Yorkshire Resilience Forum, which is a partnership of agencies that tackle emergencies, that the situation in the county was “hanging by a thread” due to a rise in infections.

Harrogate councillors were ‘legally obliged’ to reconsider Flaxby site, High Court told

Harrogate Borough Council did not fulfil its legal obligation to fully consider Flaxby as a reasonable alternative to Green Hammerton as the site of a major new settlement, the High Court was told today.

Christopher Katkowski QC, representing Flaxby Park Ltd, made the claim on the third and final day of a judicial review between the developer and the council.

A judgement will be handed down at a later date.

Flaxby claims the council’s decision to choose Green Hammerton for 3,000 homes was based on a flawed process.

Mr Katkowski said the developer’s claim was “straightforward and simple” — that councillors “at some point” should have considered the Flaxby site after council officers assessed it a second time.

Instead the matter was dealt with by council officers.

Mr Katkowski told the court:

“Members were legally obliged to consider Flaxby as a broad location and reasonable alternative to Green Hammerton as a broad location.

“They never did at the bookends or at any point in between.”

Mr Katkowski said the developer accepted that councillors “could not do the work” of the assessment, but added that what mattered was “what you do with the work when it is done”.

The court also heard that the planning inspector’s report, which councillors considered before they adopted the district’s local plan, was “not a substitute” for the second assessment.

Mr Katkowski said councillors should have had the second assessment in front of them and that the report was not a substitute “as a matter of law”.

The council claims it acted lawfully in the decision-making process.

The council’s defence made submissions yesterday that there was no legal reason for officers to return the second assessment of the two sites to councillors.

Paul Brown QC, representing the council, told the court that officers had delegated powers, which covered work such as assessments and modifications to the plan.

He said they were not “legally required” to check further with councillors after carrying out the work.

Mr Justice Holgate closed the judicial review hearing, which was held remotely due to coronavirus, this afternoon and will now consider his verdict.

Harrogate council acted lawfully in Green Hammerton case, High Court told

Harrogate Borough Council officers acted lawfully when they chose to pick Green Hammerton over Flaxby for its local plan, London’s High Court was told today.

Paul Brown QC, representing the authority at the judicial review, outlined the council’s defence to claimants Flaxby Park Ltd on the second day of the hearing.

Flaxby claimed yesterday the council made insufficient comparisons between the two sites, that further assessments were not brought back before councillors and questioned the viability of the site.

But Mr Brown told the court there was no legal reason for officers to return a further assessment of the two sites to councillors.

He said officers had already been delegated powers, which covered assessments and modifications to the plan, and they were not “legally required” to check further with councillors after carrying out the work.

Mr Brown said:

“It is patently not a matter which members would have been competent to carry out themselves.

“In a world where officers had delegated authority to agree modifications, it would be perverse to check with members before deciding that no modification [to the local plan] was required.”

‘Entirely lawful’

Mr Brown said the council’s decision not to assess a “broad location” for Flaxby before the local plan was submitted for examination was “an entirely lawful one to take”.

The council ultimately carried out the further assessment after the planning inspector said the move would be “sensible” and not that it was legally required, Mr Brown added.

He said the assessment was then given to the inspector and the inspector’s final report, which included the additional work, was considered by councillors before the local plan was adopted.

The court also heard that there was “no unequal treatment” between Flaxby and Green Hammerton and that the two were considered by officers throughout the process.

Flaxby limitations

Mr Brown said the “like for like” comparison was completed and limitations of the Flaxby site had been made clear since July 2017.

Addressing the clam that the planning inspector’s conclusion on viability was “perverse”, Mr Brown said the judgement was a “matter for the inspector”.

The court also heard that the council looked at the viability of both sites and each developer was spoken to and “treated on a like for like basis”.

Christopher Katkowski QC, representing Flaxby Park Ltd, will respond to the council’s defence tomorrow.

The hearing is expected to conclude tomorrow.

£100,000 Skipton Road traffic light scheme delayed due to Nightingale

A £100,000 scheme to replace traffic lights on Skipton Road has been delayed until next year due to Harrogate’s Nightingale Hospital.

North Yorkshire County Council was expected to refurbish Skipton Road’s junctions with Kings Road and Bilton Lane this year.

It would have included introducing a larger island at the Kings Road junction and installing new traffic lights at both junctions.

However, the scheme will now be delayed until the next financial year as the areas are deemed to be too close to the town’s Nightingale Hospital.

Melisa Burnham, highways area manager at the county council, said:

“The two sites for the scheme are very close to the Nightingale Hospital. We have not been able to progress the works due to the importance of Skipton Road at the early stages of the lockdown.

“Where possible we must protect the key route around the hospital, particularly where closures are required. As a key route to the town centre and the Nightingale we will ensure works are delivered and managed effectively through temporary lights, avoiding closures where possible.

“Design work has since re-started. Whilst we are in a position to progress, we will be mindful of the current coronavirus situation and the potential use of the Nightingale Hospital and plan accordingly.”

The area has had weeks of disruption since the summer, with first Northern Gas Networks and then CityFibre using temporary lights while they carried out work.

News of the delay to junction upgrades comes after the government announced that the Nightingale Hospital in Harrogate has been placed on standby amid a second wave of infections.

However, Lord Newby, a House of Lords peer who lives in Ripon, told the Stray Ferret last week that the hospital “simply does not have the staff available to allow it to operate safely”.

Read More:

Read more:

Read more:

Read more:

Read more:

Read more:

Read more:

Read more:

Read more:

‘Entirely lawful’

Flaxby limitations

Read more: