Knaresborough solicitor died in fatal fire caused by candle, inquest finds

A house fire which led to the death of a Knaresborough solicitor is likely to have been caused by a candle, an inquest heard today.

Lynda Delf Greenwood died at the scene of the fire which destroyed her home in Brearton in April this year.

The inquest heard both police and fire officers conclude that a candle on a coffee table in the living room was thought to have been the origin of the fire.

The fire took hold thanks to wood and other materials near the open fire, which was not lit.

Fire investigator Tony Walker told the inquest:

“It did surprise me a little just how quickly it had spread to the upstairs bedroom which was so badly affected by the fire that it [collapsed] down into the living room.

“When I was speaking to [Mrs Greenwood’s daughter] Camilla, I was informed Lynda kept a large amount of fire lighters and kindling by the side of the fire which may have been feeding the fire.”

Earlier in the week, the court heard, Mrs Greenwood had had an operation on her foot and was wearing a “boot” for support.

However, on the day of the fire, Saturday, April 2, she appeared well and uninhibited by the boot. Camilla had gone shopping and to have beauty treatments in Knaresborough with her mother.

They returned to the house in Brearton where Mrs Greenwood, who was 67, had cooked dinner. Camilla left just after 8pm, having made plans to see her mother the following day for a family event.

Dog barking

The inquest heard Mrs Greenwood then spoke to her sister-in-law, Samantha Nattress, over the phone just after 8.30pm. Mrs Nattress told the hearing there was nothing unusual about the phone call, other than one of Mrs Greenwood’s five dogs barking in the background on two occasions during the 45-minute call.

The phone call ended just after 9.20pm when Mrs Greenwood said she was going to bed.

Neighbours noticed the fire just after 10pm and called the fire service, as well as rushing to the scene to help. Three men went to the conservatory door and rescued the dogs, while also calling into the house for Mrs Greenwood.

Read more:

The inquest heard firefighters arrived just a few minutes later. Police and paramedics also attended.

Mrs Greenwood was found lying in the hallway behind the door to the kitchen. She was taken outside into the garden where first firefighters and then paramedics attempted to resuscitate her, but without success.

The Brearton house destroyed in the fatal fire

The Brearton house destroyed in the fatal fire.

Giving evidence at the inquest, DS Louise Pegg said she felt it was likely Mrs Greenwood, having discovered the fire, had been trying to get to the dogs’ room on the other side of the kitchen.

She added:

“I’m led to believe there was quite a lot of furniture in [the house]… Once the fire had taken hold, there was material that was combustible.

“Camilla told me that it’s rare for her mother to use a candle, but on that occasion she had lit a candle.”

Mr Walker said he had also concluded the dogs were in the area next to the conservatory where they were usually kept and that he believed two battery-operated smoke alarms were not working. He added:

“If Lynda had come out of her bedroom door when she first detected that smell of smoke, by that time there would have been a lot of product combustion in that part of the hallway. There will have been a lot of smoke.”

‘Loveable fruitcake’

In statements read out by North Yorkshire area coroner Catherine Cundy, friends and neighbours described Mrs Greenwood as “bubbly” and that she “would help anyone out with anything”. The court heard she was an active member of the community and in the village church and one neighbour said she was “a lovable fruitcake”.

Mrs Greenwood ran her own solicitors’ practice in Knaresborough and, in October 2021, invited neighbour Leighton Williams to join her as a partner in the firm, which he did.

Her daughter Camilla had moved back home after university in December 2020, but left the following year. Mrs Greenwood’s parents had both lived in an annexe next to the house but had died in 2021.

Camilla described her mother as “one of a kind” and “fun to be around” in a statement read to the inquest. She said she was “extremely capable”, “high-functioning” and “organised”. While her mother could seem “a little forgetful” sometimes, Camilla said this was only over minor matters and she loved to organise family occasions.

The court heard a post-mortem examination found evidence of Mrs Greenwood’s prescription medication in her blood, as well as some alcohol, which could have been enough to make her disorientated or cause blurred vision.

There was evidence of toxic levels of carbon monoxide inhalation, the court heard.

Ms Cundy recorded a verdict of accidental death in the fire, most likely caused by the candle.

Harrogate district firefighters tackle four ‘significant incidents’ overnight

Harrogate district firefighters tackled four “significant incidents” in the space of just over an hour last night.

Two fire engines from Harrogate were mobilised, along with appliances from Knaresborough, Ripon, Boroughbridge and Summerbridge.

The number of overnight fire engines at Harrogate is due to be reduced from two to one under plans by North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Zoe Metcalfe.

Firstly, crews from Harrogate and Knaresborough were called to a fire in the basement of a pub at Bond End, Knaresborough at 2.24am.

North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service‘s incident log said:

“This was caused by spontaneous combustion of warm laundry in a basket and caused fire damage to the laundry only, there was smoke damage to the entire property.

“Crews used four breathing apparatus, one hose reel jet, a thermal imaging camera and a positive pressure ventilation fan to extinguish the fire.”

Because Harrogate and Knaresborough firefighters were still dealing with this, crews from Ripon and Boroughbridge had to be drafted in at 2.58pm to a house fire on St Leonard’s Road in Harrogate caused by an electric heater which was too close to combustible materials.

One man had got out of the property by the time they arrived thanks to the smoke alarm going off. The incident log said:

“Crews used four breathing apparatus, one hose reel jet, thermal imaging camera and a backpack sprayer to extinguish the fire which was caused by an electric heater too close to combustible materials.”

Read more:

The firefighters’ night was far from over.

At 3.11am, firefighters from Harrogate and Summerbridge used hydraulic cutting equipment to extract a man from his car following a single vehicle crash on the B6161 at Beckwithshaw.

Then at 3.38am, an officer and a crew from Knaresborough attended a single vehicle crash on the B6161 at Leathley. A man, believed to be drunk, had broken his nose and was out of the vehicle where he was left in the hands of police.

A Harrogate Fire Station spokesperson said:

“Fire crews in the Harrogate district last night had four significant incidents all at the same time.

“Resources were stretched but able to assist in all incidents.”

The spokesperson said “smoke alarms really do save lives” and the fire  caused by the electric heater “is not unique”. They added:

“Firefighters nationwide are warning of the increased risk of fire due to unsafe use of electric heaters as people try to keep down costs during the winter.”

Safety advice from Electrical Safety First if you have an electric heater

 

Firefighters called to sauna fire at Rudding spa

Firefighters using breathing apparatus were called to reports of a fire in a sauna at Rudding Park spa last night.

Crews from Harrogate, Boroughbridge and Knaresborough were summoned to the incident in Follifoot at sixteen minutes past midnight.

North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service‘s incident log says:

“Crews used four breathing apparatus, two thermal imaging cameras, one hose reel and small tools to deal with the incident.

“The fire was caused by an electrical fault.”

The hotel’s managing director, Peter Banks, said the fire started after the spa had closed and was spotted by a night cleaner, who quickly raised the alarm – even before the smoke alarms had been activated.

The sauna has a system which releases nitrogen as soon as a fire is detected, taking the oxygen out of the room. Mr Banks said:

“By the time the fire service, arrived, the fire was pretty much out. The system worked exactly as it should have and it’s business as usual today.”

Read more:

 

Starbeck’s former Harper’s could be turned into housing

The former McColl’s store ravaged by fire in Starbeck could be turned into housing.

Built on High Street as a Harper’s grocery, the building was later used as a McColl’s but closed and was derelict when fire struck in 2018.

Since then, the building has frequently been described as an eyesore, although it was brightened this year when volunteers painted it in the colours of the Ukrainian flag.

An agent for the owners of the building said today there are plans for a “residential-led development”.

Pete Gleave, from Zerum Consulting, told the Stray Ferret:

“Our client is looking to progress proposals with the local planning authority and has entered into pre-application discussions with planning officers.

“This will be a residential-led development and we will shortly be commencing work on a formal planning application.

“Our client recognises the importance of bringing the site forward for redevelopment and we will now look to do so in a timely manner.”

Mr Gleave would not reveal who owned the building. He said he was “unable to pass on client details without their approval”.

Read more:

Andrew Hart, founder of Starbeck Community Group and owner of Starbeck Post Office, said the building was “just rotting away” and urgently needed attention. He added:

“Anything is better than nothing — it can’t stay as it is. The building is dangerous. We know it has asbestos problems inside and is an eyesore.

“But I’ll be disappointed if they don’t put some kind of retail function in on the ground floor.

“If we can get a prestigious restaurant, bar or shop in there then we can get other businesses in. There can be housing upstairs.”

In February, Harrogate Borough Council granted an application by Leeds-based developer Bates & Hemingborough to demolish the building.

The plans had been put on hold in December after the council asked for safety documents, which were later provided, addressing how the demolition would impact the adjacent St Andrew’s Church.

Fire crews tackle blaze at Scotton caravan storage site

Fire fighters were called to a major blaze at a caravan storage site in Scotton last night.

Crews from Knaresborough, Boroughbridge, Harrogate and Ripon responded to the fire on Market Flat Lane.

An incident response unit from Malton was also called to the blaze.

Local resident Ed Marshall captured the below video from the fire, which happened at around 7.30pm.

North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service said in an incident log that multiple vehicles were affected by the blaze.

The service added:

“Crews used hose reel jets and breathing apparatus to extinguish the fire which had affected multiple vehicles.

“The cause of this fire is to be confirmed.”

Read more:

 

Firefighters called to Ripon launderette blaze

Two fire crews from Ripon and one from Boroughbridge rushed to Ripon city centre last night following reports of smoke in a launderette.

After being summoned at about 7.20pm, they extinguished a fire that had spread to a number of commercial washers and dryers.

Firefighters used breathing apparatus and a thermal imaging camera to tackle the blaze.

North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service’s incident log said:

“Crews then ventilated the heavily smoked logged building and gave advice to the owner.

“The cause of the fire was accidental.”

Read more:

 

Firefighters rescue man from blaze in Ripon city centre flat

A man was rescued from a flat that caught fire above a Ripon restaurant today.

Ripon firefighters were called to the first flor flat on High Skellgate in the city centre at 2.59pm this afternoon.

North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service‘s incident log said:

“Crews rescued a male occupant inside the flat.

“He was left in the care of ambulance with smoke inhalation and burns.”

The incident log added that fire damaged the kitchen and the rest of the flat suffered heat and smoke damage.

Firefighters wore breathing apparatus to tackle the blaze.

Read more:

 

North Yorkshire fire commissioner says she would still consider cuts even with ‘millions in the bank’

North Yorkshire’s police, fire and crime commissioner has said she would still consider proposed changes to Harrogate’s fire crews “even if the service had millions of pounds in the bank”.

Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe is due to announce her decision on the plans to cut the number of night-time fire engines to just one on Thursday.

She has argued that the changes would allow Harrogate fire station to have two better-equipped fire engines during the day when emergencies are more likely to occur.

Commissioner Metcalfe has also said the proposals – which are part of a new risk and resource model – would allow for investment in fire prevention.

Asked at a council meeting last night whether she would still consider the plans if the fire service was better funded, commissioner Metcalfe said she “would still be doing this” and that she was “very assured” residents will be “kept safe”.

She said:

“We are always looking at different ways to get additional money into the fire service.

“We have this juxtaposition where North Yorkshire Police is what I would call well funded, but the fire service has just only got a balanced budget.

“As far as I am concerned about the risk and resource modelling, I would still be doing this even if we had a lot of money in the bank.”

Currently, Harrogate fire station has one fire engine which can respond to all emergencies and a smaller “tactical response” vehicle that both operate around the clock.

Under the proposals put forward by the North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service, the smaller vehicle would be replaced by a larger fire engine, but it would only be crewed during the day.

The plans have drawn criticism from North Yorkshire’s Fire Brigades Union which said the changes along with similar proposals for Scarborough and Huntington would leave the county with a “second-rate emergency response service that will put lives at risk”.

Commissioner Metcalfe has repeatedly insisted that the proposals have been based on “extensive” risk assessments which look at when and where emergencies are most likely to occur.

She also said the changes would allow for improvements in other areas including the fire service’s on-call model which means only five out of 38 fire stations are currently crewed 24 hours a day.

These are Acomb, Harrogate, Huntington, Scarborough and York fire stations.

Commissioner Metcalfe told last night’s meeting: “It is really important to realise that our community risk profile makes sure that we identify where the risks are and that the right amount of resources are in place.

“It is also absolutely right that we invest in prevention and protection, as well as our on-call model which desperately needs attention.”

New North Yorkshire deputy chief fire officer appointed

Conservative Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe has appointed Mat Walker as the new deputy chief fire officer of North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service.

Mr Walker, a 43-year-old father-of-three who has been in the role on an interim basis since June, will receive a salary of £95,294 plus an operational allowance.

He joined the fire and rescue service in 2003 in South Yorkshire before moving to a national role where he was involved in the response to major incidents including east coast flooding and the Salisbury Novichok attacks.

He has since worked in the West Yorkshire service, most recently as an area manager responsible for service assurance and improvement.

Mr Walker was appointed after three candidates were interviewed by an independent panel.

Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe said:

“I am delighted to be able to appoint Mat into this permanent role. He faced a strong challenge from an excellent field of candidates but I’m confident he’s the right person to help lead North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service on its continuing transformation.

“This is also an exciting time to be joining the service as we begin to put in place our refreshed plans on how to keep the people of North Yorkshire safe, and feeling safe over the next two years.”

Read more

Mr Walker takes up the role at a time when unions have raised concerns over cuts worth around £8m a year.

At Harrogate fire station, it means the number of night-time fire engines will be reduced to just one.

At a meeting this month, it was revealed North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service’s fire engine availability was classed as being at a “critical” level for 10% of the time during May this year.

This level refers to the service having fewer than 32 staffed engines and other appliances available across North Yorkshire. Commissioner Metcalfe described availability as “incredibly concerning”.

Man admits setting fire to historic Knaresborough pub

A 45-year-old man has pleaded guilty to setting fire to a Knaresborough pub last year.

Stephen Pearson, of Pinhoe Road in Exeter, was charged with arson at Blind Jack’s pub on Market Place in the town on August 21 last year.

He pleaded guilty when he appeared before York Crown Court this morning.

Pearson’s defence counsel told the court that he had “a number of difficulties” over the years and was currently seeing a clinical psychologist on a regular basis.

Read more:

The defence requested that the case be adjourned for a pre-sentence report to be prepared.

Judge Simon Hickey adjourned sentencing Pearson until November 18.

He told him that he must “realise the consequences that may follow” when he appears before court again.

Blind Jack's on Market Place, Knaresborough.

Blind Jack’s on Market Place, Knaresborough.

The pub was damaged in the blaze at around 4am on the morning of August 21, 2021.

Owners Christian and Alice Ogley were away at the time of the fire and nobody was injured.

The Grade II listed pub is named after Knaresborough’s John Metcalf, the first professional road builder to emerge in the Industrial Revolution.