A controversial plan to cut the number of night-time fire engines in Harrogate to just one is set to be decided by the county’s police, fire and crime commissioner this month.
Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe is assessing feedback from a consultation and is expected to meet with her executive board for a decision in September.
She has continually insisted that the North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue service would “continue to provide an immediate emergency response” under the plan as emergencies are less likely to occur during the night.
Yet union officials and councillors remain concerned about the proposal which has been described as “putting money before lives”.
The plan is part of the fire service’s new risk and resource model, and a three-month public consultation ended in August.
According to the commissioner’s website, a consultation summary report will be presented to the executive board for a decision before the final risk and resource model is published.
If approved, it will pave the way for a new strategy on how the fire service will deploy its staff and equipment over the next three years.
Read more:
- Knaresborough man sentenced to 13 years in prison for manslaughter
- North Yorkshire Police to send officers to Queen’s funeral
There are similar proposals for fire stations in Scarborough and Huntington which commissioner Metcalfe said along with the Harrogate plans would save over £1.5 million a year to allow for investment in fire prevention
She also insisted the proposals are not cost-cutting measures and have been based on “extensive risk assessment”.
However, concerns remain over public safety and the amount of government funding that the fire service receives.
The North Yorkshire Fire Brigades Union previously said the fire service’s finances have left it “struggling to buy the basics” and that around £25 million is needed to replace out-of-date buildings, vehicles and equipment.
Union secretary Steve Howley also said the risk and resource model plans would leave the county with a “second-rate emergency response service that will put lives at risk”.
He said:
Warning as fire reignites in Stainburn Forest five days after being put out“A decade of under investment in the fire and rescue service has dovetailed with an increase in response times both locally and nationally,
“The police, fire and crime commissioner needs to fight for the correct funding from government, not simply mask underfunding by slashing services.”
Firefighters have issued a warning about the dangers of fires in overgrown areas as a fire reignited five days after being put out.
Crews from North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service were called to Stainburn Forest near Beckwithshaw last Saturday, where a campfire had spread to surrounding undergrowth and trees, causing damage to an area covering 20m by 20m.
Five days later, on Thursday morning, they were called back to the same spot, where the fire had reignited and spread to a further 20m sq of undergrowth.
Posting on Facebook, a spokesperson for Knaresborough Fire Station said:
“The reignition was caused by hidden residual heat in the undergrowth.
“The images just show how dry the undergrowth is and how deep the compacted forest bed goes – perfect conditions for hidden fire spread…
“All this fire damage was caused by one campfire on dry forest ground! This incident could have been a lot worse as fire would have easily spread to the surrounding trees if it was a windy day.”
Photo by Knaresborough Fire Station
Two tanks of water were used to soak the area and prevent any further fire, while crews cut away the smouldering edges of the site with shovels.
The spokesperson said crews were able to locate the fire precisely because the person who called it in gave a location using the What3Words app. They urged people to download the free app in case they ever need to use it in an emergency.
Read more:
- Fire crews and police attend tanker incident in Harrogate
- Harrogate firefighters called to midnight hay fire
Fire service availability ‘incredibly concerning’ says North Yorkshire commissioner
North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Zoë Metcalfe has called issues with fire crew availability in the county “incredibly concerning”.
North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service’s fire engine availability was classed as being at a “critical” level for 10% of the time during May this year.
That status refers to the service having fewer than 32 staffed engines and other appliances available across North Yorkshire.
The fire service said that “ongoing challenges” were affecting firefighter availability in the county.
The statistics were presented during the monthly public accountability meeting chaired by the Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner.
After the high in May, the period of time spent at the critical level decreased to 4% in June.
Ms Metcalfe said that the situation reaffirmed the need for the fire service’s risk and resource model consultation.
Read more
- Last chance to comment on proposed Harrogate Fire Station changes
- Councillors have ‘major concerns’ about plans to reduce Harrogate fire engines
The consultation, which closed last month, proposed upgrading Harrogate’s 24-hour tactical response vehicle to a full fire engine, but only during the day.
Harrogate Fire Station is currently one of only of five in North Yorkshire to have staff on a 24-hour basis.
Elsewhere in North Yorkshire, the commissioner proposed moving some stations from full-time operation to being ‘on-call’.
That is where firefighters principally work in other jobs but respond to incidents when needed.
Ms Metcalfe said:
“That’s why… the fire service invests in the on-call model and that the service uses its resources in the very best way in the future.”

Zoe Metcalfe, North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner.
“Our availability is inverted to our demand”
The fire service’s director of assurance, area manager James Manning, told the meeting that the current method of employing staff on-call had led to some issues.
He said:
“Our availability is inverted to our demand.”
The data showed that fire crew availability was higher in the evenings and overnight but lower during the daytime when fewer firefighters were able to be on-call.
Roughly around double the number of incidents happen in the daytime compared to overnight.
Mr Manning added that May also saw “slightly higher than normal” levels of leave and sickness but that the service was working on becoming more flexible in its staffing arrangements.
Harrogate firefighters called to midnight hay fireFirefighters from Harrogate dealt with a hay stack fire shortly after midnight today.
The crew were summoned to Little Ribston, near Knaresborough, at six minutes past midnight and requested assistance from a second fire engine.
According to North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service‘s incident log, firefighters used one hose reel jet to dampen down the fire and set up a water relay.
About half an hour earlier, Knaresborough firefighters were called to reports of a fire on Harrogate Road, near Mother Shipton’s cave.
The incident log said:
“Crew located an unattended bonfire. They used knapsack sprayers to dampen down the surrounding area.”
Read more:
- Rail strike: No trains through Harrogate and Knaresborough as walkout begins
- 170-home plan ‘not righ’ for Knaresborough, says town councillor
A61 reopens between Ripley and Ripon after Land Rover fire
The A61 has reopened between Ripley and Ripon after a Land Rover caught fire.
Harrogate fire station tweeted about the incident just before 4pm today.
It added:
“The fire has been extinguished but road remains closed due to fuel spillage.”
North Yorkshire Police tweeted shortly after 5pm that the road had reopened.
Thank you for your patience – the A61 south of Ripon has now re-opened in both directions. https://t.co/xdaLIyE7Dg
— North Yorkshire Police (@NYorksPolice) August 12, 2022
It had earlier warned that the surface was unsafe.
Anyone travelling north on the A61 towards Ripon is asked to come off on Moor Road into Bishop Monkton, then follow Knaresborough Road into Ripon.
The A61 is closed in both directions and is likely to remain so for some time, so please plan your journeys accordingly.
(2/2)
— North Yorkshire Police (@NYorksPolice) August 12, 2022
Buses were also affected.
https://twitter.com/harrogatebus/status/1558109060712595456
Read more:
- Firefighters deal with blaze in planter outside shopping centre
- Firefighters tackle field fire in Aldborough
Firefighters tackle field fire in Aldborough
Fire crews were called to a bale and field on fire in Aldborough yesterday.
Pictures released by North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue show crews tackling the blaze at 11.49am.
Fire crews from Knaresborough, Ripon, Wetherby and the water bowser from Tadcaster stopped the spread of the fire and extinguished the baler.
The fire spread from the baler to the stubble field measuring approximately 10 acres, according to the service’s fire log.
Firefighters have urged people to be vigilant during the soaring temperatures this week to prevent the spread of fires near farmland.

Firefighters tackling the field fire in Aldborough. Picture: Knaresborough Fire Station.
This includes discarding of cigarettes properly, not using disposable barbecues near crops, checking straw and hay bales which can overheat and keeping farm machinery in good working order.
Last month, Harrogate firefighters tackled five field fires during the hottest day of the year.
Crews were called to battle blazes at Forest Lane in Harrogate and Marton-cum-Grafton among others.
Read more:
- Drone captures scale of Ripon field fire
- Harrogate firefighters battle extreme heat as five fields go up in flames
Firefighters called to blaze at factory in Birstwith
Firefighters were called to Birstwith this morning when a drying plant in a food factory went up in flames.
Crews from Ripon and Knaresborough went to Kerry Ingredients shortly before 7am this morning.
They used breathing apparatus and hose reel jets to tackle the fire.
A spokeswoman for North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service said:
“There was damage to the drying equipment and pipework. The cause of the fire is not confirmed.”
Firefighters left the site by 9.18am.
Read more:
- Councillors have ‘major concerns’ about plans to reduce Harrogate fire engines
- Business group calls for more Harrogate town centre police
Firefighters called to Harrogate’s Victoria Shopping Centre
Harrogate’s Victoria Shopping Centre closed this afternoon after a reported fire.
The centre shut at about 3pm and staff and shoppers were evacuated as firefighters were summoned to the scene.
Eyewitness Paul Ivison, from Harrogate, said people were told there had been a small electrical fire in one of the stores, believed to be New Look, but no major damage had occurred.
“Three fire engines arrived but there was no smoke seen.
“About 100 people were outside when all the tenants and shoppers had been evacuated. The whole centre and exterior units were closed.
“Everyone was very calm.”
The shopping centre reopened at about 3.30pm.
We will update this article when more information is available.

Pic: Paul Ivison

Pic: Paul Ivison
Fire has destroyed a workshop in the Harrogate district this evening.
Firefighters from Ripon and Harrogate were called to the blaze at Bishop Monkton, which is five miles south of Ripon.
Tony Walker, station manager for York, Selby and Tadcaster tweeted about the incident tonight.
He added:
“Investigation is underway to determine the cause. No injuries reported.”
Crews from Ripon & Harrogate have just dealt with workshop fire in the village of Bishop Monkton. Investigation is underway to determine the cause. No injuries reported. @theyorkmix @BBCYork pic.twitter.com/sEdEZgc2VH
— Tony Walker (@sierra18NY) July 12, 2022
Read more:
- Firefighter photos reveal extent of Harrogate district field fire
- Six baby hedgehogs in Ripon rescued from bonfire at last minute
Firefighter photos reveal extent of Harrogate district field fire
Photos released by Harrogate firefighters have revealed the extent of yesterday’s field fire near Ripon.
The blaze, which occurred just after 4pm at Hutton Bank, Sharow, was one of two crop fires in the district as the heatwave hits.
North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service‘s incident log says:
“Ripon and Harrogate crews attended reports of a field of standing crops on fire.
“They requested a further four appliances due to the 300m fire front. Crews worked with the farmer to extinguish the fire. Incident has been scaled down now.”


Minutes later crews from York, Northallerton and Colburn attended a large field fire measuring approx 100 metres at Dishforth.
They used pitchforks and beaters and a hose reel to extinguish the flames.
Read more:
- Six baby hedgehogs in Ripon rescued from bonfire at last minute
- North Yorkshire fire service has adequate funding, says minister