The NHS has insisted the Harrogate Nightingale hospital is able to take patients despite concerns it lacks the capacity to do so.
Many people are wondering why the building remains on standby at a time when the new mutant strain of covid has sent infections soaring and put tremendous strain on hospitals.
A record 53,000 people were confirmed to have covid yesterday and hospital admissions have surpassed the peak of the first wave.
The Health Service Journal even reported yesterday there were plans to transfer patients from overloaded London hospitals to Yorkshire.
But the Harrogate Nightingale, which was set up at the town’s convention centre at breakneck speed in spring for covid patients in Yorkshire and the Humber, has yet to treat a single person with coronavirus. It has been used for CT scans.
Ripon peer Lord Newby, the Liberal Democrats leader in the House of Lords, has said the Nightingale “simply does not have the staff available to allow it to operate safely”.
Conservative MP John Redwood has called for ministers to explain why they are not using the Nightingales.
Read more:
- Looking back: Extraordinary effort to build a Nightingale hospital in Harrogate
- Harrogate Nightingale remains ‘on standby’ amid new covid strain
The NHS has repeatedly declined to issue more than a brief statement in response to questions from the Stray Ferret about the Nightingale or requests for interviews.
It did so again yesterday when we asked if there were still plans to use the hospital, particularly in light of reports that the London Nightingale was being dismantled.
A spokesperson for the NHS in the north east and Yorkshire said:
“The Nightingale hospitals in the north east and Yorkshire has been running a clinical imaging service since June with more than 3,000 patients receiving a diagnostic test or CT scan, and can take patients if required.”
Looking back: Clap for carers and scrubbing up for key workers
As 2020 draws to a close, the Stray Ferret looks at the news stories that stood out among a year of extraordinary events.
Today, we remember all the ways in which our district’s key workers were shown appreciation, beginning with the weekly Clap for Carers.
As many of us stayed at home to avoid catching or spreading coronavirus, determined key workers continued to put themselves on the front line. Showing their appreciation, people across the Harrogate district took to their doorsteps each week to Clap for Carers – and they didn’t stop there.
The Clap For Carers lasted for 10 weeks and, as well as individual households, saw the hospital and care homes become focal points for the community’s appreciation of key workers.
One of the biggest campaigns to support the NHS in the Harrogate district was started by maths teacher Fran Taylor.
At first planning to sew a couple of sets of scrubs for Harrogate District Hospital, Fran soon found herself coordinating hundreds of volunteers, thousands of metres of fabric – and donations running into thousands of pounds.
With a supporting team helping her to organise sending out patterns and fabric, collecting completed scrubs and delivering them to where they were most needed, Fran managed to deliver an astonishing 4,000 sets of scrubs – on top of looking after her two young children and teaching her St John Fisher students remotely.
They were sent to staff across the hospital who would not normally wear scrubs but needed clothing that was easy to wash as soon as they got home from a shift. Requests from other NHS and care providers also came in, and were fulfilled by the dedicated team.
It wasn’t just scrubs that were in demand, however: in April, other vital PPE supplies were hard to access and appeals were put out by the hospital and North Yorkshire County Council.
Straight away, the community stepped up to help. Among them was the technology department at Harrogate Grammar School, which turned its talents to rolling out visors for key workers. Ashville College was also creating visors and scrubs after donating 200 pairs of goggles from its technology cupboards.
Dancing in the street
Meanwhile, local residents showed their support from home with displays of bright rainbows in their windows.
And the community spirit didn’t stop there.
For three months from late March, the country was placed under national lockdown, with residents largely confined to their homes and their movements restricted.
That did not stop people in the Harrogate district from looking out for each other, though – including finding inventive ways to keep up spirits in the face of adversity.
For residents in Harrogate’s Mount Gardens, music was lifting the spirits every week. Derry Jones, best known for playing the piano for diners at Bettys, took his accordion to the pavement as wife Jovita sang, and the neighbours were out and dancing.
Just a few streets away, 22-year-old Lucy Crocker was using her musical talents to give a concert for her neighbours each Friday.
Playing the viola, she took requests for songs as well as performing some classical tunes she already knew. Her efforts were appreciated by the rest of the residents of Mallinson Oval, who enjoyed getting outside to see each other and chat from a distance every week.
And on Spring Grove, residents came outside daily to take part in Mel Milnes’ exercise classes.
People across the Harrogate district formed groups with their neighbours to ensure nobody went without what they needed. Though keeping them apart physically, the pandemic brought communities together like nothing before.
Doubts about future of 2021 Great Yorkshire ShowThe future of next year’s Great Yorkshire Show is uncertain as the Harrogate venue that hosts the event begins a huge mass vaccination project.
The NHS began the programme on Tuesday at the showground. It is expected to last several months, which raises questions about the viability of the 2021 show, which is provisionally scheduled for July 13 to 15.
Heather Parry, managing director at Yorkshire Event Centre, told the Stray Ferret is is “looking at all the options at the moment” for the 2021 event.
Ms Parry said:
“It’s a changing picture. It’s obviously a big event with lots of people so whether we do it the same way or a different way, we are keen to do something if we can.
“We don’t know how many months we’re in this for. We would like to run a Great Yorkshire Show, absolutely, whether it’s the same or different, we don’t know. We are doing lots of planning.”
Read more:
Ms Parry said none of the contingency plans involved moving the event, which has been held at the Great Yorkshire Showground since 1951, to a different site.
The show was cancelled in 2020 due to coronavirus. A virtual event took place instead with three days of video footage.
Ms Parry added that at least 200 other events have been cancelled this year at the Yorkshire Event Centre and the Pavillions of Harrogate venue, which is also on the showground, due to the pandemic.
Harrogate people urged to be patient when booking GPs amid delaysThe NHS is urging people in the Harrogate district to be patient when booking GP appointments amid concerns some patients’ anger is boiling over at delays.
Health leaders issued the plea today, saying a combination of exceptional demand and staff being affected by normal winter sickness and covid was causing strain.
NHS North Yorkshire Clinical Commissioning Group and NHS Vale of York CCG, which buy health services for the county, acknowledging ‘the wait to speak to a member of a surgery’s reception team in some areas may be a little longer than normal’ and asking people to show ‘patience and kindness’ in the run-up to Christmas.
Dr Charles Parker, NHS North Yorkshire CCG clinical chair, said:
“We recognise how frustrating it can be to be in a call queue but surgery staff are doing their very best in challenging circumstances.
“GP practices have been asked to vaccinate the 50-64 year olds against the flu, to give the covid vaccine, to work in constrained ways to keep patients and staff safe and to do this with higher numbers of staff off work, isolating or ill.
“This is a lot to cope with at the same time. They absolutely do not deserve to be shouted at and abused.”
Read more:
- North Yorkshire GPs begin delivering covid vaccine
- Yorkshire Showground prepares for vaccination programme
Dr Parker added people should not ring GP practices asking about the covid vaccine but instead wait for notification. He added:
“This will help keep the phone lines clear and help practices cope with providing prompt care.”
Local pharmacies can also help with minor ailments, such as coughs, colds, sore throats, tummy trouble and aches and pains.
Patients can also get non-emergency medical advice at all hours by using the NHS 111 service online or over the phone.
Harrogate council billing NHS over £100,000 a month for NightingaleHarrogate Borough Council is continuing to bill the NHS over £100,000 a month for gas, electricity and water at Harrogate’s Nightingale hospital.
Set up at the council-owned Harrogate Convention Centre in April at a cost of £27m, the Nightingale has so far not treated a single covid patient.
The council does not charge the NHS rent for the building. However, figures from Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust show the venue, which opened in the early 1980s, incurs significant costs for utilities.
The payments for utilities have been ongoing throughout the year and were previously reported by the Stray Ferret in August.
The most recent published figures are below:
August: £144,583
September: £161,518
October: £124,449.
The NHS’ contract with the council to run the Nightingale is due to end in March 2021.
A council spokesman said:
“Any costs relating to the use of utilities at the convention centre are calculated on standard metered usage. These costs are then passed onto the client throughout the term of the contract.”
Read more:
The Stray Ferret has requested interviews with the NHS about the Harrogate Nightingale on numerous occasions but so far has not received one.
Last month, Lord Newby, the Liberal Democrats leader in the House of Lords, said the time had come to let the council take back control of the building.
The first event listed on the convention centre’s website is the Assemblies of God conference from May 6-8.
Hospitality businesses that rely on trade from the convention centre have suffered this year from its closure.
The Stray Ferret reported earlier this month that the Kimberley Hotel on King’s Road has permanently closed.
‘Time to hand Harrogate Nightingale back to council’One of the Harrogate district’s most senior politicians has said the time has come to accept the Harrogate Nightingale hospital will never be used for covid and handed back.
Lord Newby, the Liberal Democrats leader in the House of Lords, said the NHS should let Harrogate District Council take back control of the building.
Lord Newby spoke to the Stray Ferret after receiving what he described as “non answers” to a series of questions he submitted to the government about staffing and bed capacity at the Nightingales in Harrogate, Sunderland and Manchester.
He asked how many nurses were required and was told by the Conservative peer Lord Bethell that “each Nightingale team has been developing a clinical model that can be scaled up as and when additional capacity is required in the region”.
Lord Newby said last month he doubted the Harrogate Nightingale had the staff to fully open and has now said:
“The only conclusions which one can draw are that the NHS has no firm plans to staff up the Harrogate Nightingale.
“If it were ever to be used for covid patients, it would obviously have to be staffed by existing staff now working in regional hospitals – all of which are already stretched – and cannot easily release doctors and nurses..
“I do not therefore believe that the facility in Harrogate will ever be used for covid and that the government should now accept this reality and hand the site back to the council.”
‘Flawed concept’
The government has described the Nightingales as “insurance policies”. But with the peak of the second wave of the pandemic believed to have passed, and a vaccine on its way, the chances of them being used have receded.
Lord Newby said the concept of using the Nightingale was “flawed from the start”. He added:
“The government should instead have looked at ways in which it could have freed up facilities in existing NHS facilities to allow for greater intake of covid patients, if this had been required.”
Read more:
- Exclusive: Harrogate Nightingale hospital ‘unable to open safely’
- Yvette Cooper MP: ‘no spare staff for Harrogate Nightingale’
The Stray Ferret has requested interviews with the NHS about the Harrogate Nightingale, which was set up to treat covid patients in Yorkshire and the Humber, on numerous occasions but so far has not received one.
A spokesperson for the hospital said in a statement:
“The NHS Nightingale Yorkshire and the Humber is getting ready to care for patients should it be needed and has been operating a clinical imaging service since June to support local trusts in delivering diagnostic and surveillance CT scans, with more than 3,000 patients having now been seen at the clinic.”
Lord Newby replied:
Yvette Cooper MP: ‘no spare staff for Harrogate Nightingale’“‘Getting ready’ is very different from ‘being ready’. The fact they’ve got a scanner there is irrelevant. The are plenty of other sites in Yorkshire where they could have put this.”
A senior Yorkshire MP has fuelled fears the Harrogate Nightingale hospital does not have the staff to open for covid patients.
Yvette Cooper, Labour MP for Normanton, Pontefract and Castleford, told a covid debate in Parliament on Wednesday that Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust currently has over 280 covid patients — 70% more than in April.
Ms Cooper said the trust had to cope with fewer staff than in April, adding:
“It cannot use the Harrogate Nightingale, because there are no spare staff to send there.”
She added she was worried about the pressure on NHS staff and urged Health Secretary Matt Hancock to “work urgently with Yorkshire hospitals to get them more support and more staff in place over the next couple of weeks, when the pressure is likely to be greatest”.
Read more:
- Harrogate Nightingale ‘could open with five days notice’
- Exclusive: Harrogate Nightingale hospital ‘unable to open safely’
Mr Hancock responded:
“We are working with hospitals across Yorkshire and across the whole country to try to make sure that we have the most capacity available.
“It is true that the numbers going into hospitals across Yorkshire continue to be far too high, and there is an awful lot of work we need to do, but the most important thing is that we get this virus under control in order to bring that number of admissions down.”
Last month Lord Newby, the Ripon-based Liberal Democrat leader in the House of Lords, expressed similar concerns to Ms Cooper when he said the Harrogate Nightingale “simply does not have the staff available to allow it to operate safely”.
No patients so far
The Harrogate Nightingale has not treated a single covid patient so far.
The Stray Ferret asked NHS England whether Ms Cooper’s claim was correct and, with covid rates in the region soaring, whether there were any plans to finally open the hospital.
A spokesperson for NHS Nightingale Hospital Yorkshire and the Humber, which is the full title of the Harrogate Nightingale, replied:
Harrogate district urged to show support for volunteers and NHS“The NHS Nightingale Hospital Yorkshire and the Humber is a valuable resource to support the local area and remains on standby, ready to quickly step up based on expert clinical advice, if needed.
“As part of comprehensive activation plans, a model that can be scaled up as and when additional capacity is required in the region has been developed. This ensures that the right skill mix of staff will be available from NHS trusts in the region.”
People in the Harrogate district are being asked to thank the NHS and local volunteers in contrasting ways this weekend.
Harrogate and District Community Action is encouraging people to raise a glass this evening to volunteers who continue to work during the pandemic.
HADCA, which had to cancel its annual Volunteering Oscars awards because of covid, is asking people to raise their glass or mug at 7pm and then post images of themselves saying ‘cheers’ on social media, tagging the Volunteering Oscars on Twitter using #nevermoreneeded.
The Volunteering Oscars celebrates volunteers in the district who help the elderly, children or terminally ill, or whose efforts ensure venues such as museums stay open.
John Fox, chair of HADCA, said:
“We clapped hands for the NHS – why don’t we all lift a glass to say thanks to all the volunteers across the Harrogate district for what they’ve done?”
Read more:
- A group committed to offering meals to those in need is to continue its efforts into the colder months.
- A Knaresborough carer called on local photographers to bring the outside in for care home residents.

Jonathan Sanderson and his two children practising their howls.
A Harrogate businessman has come up with an altogether different way to celebrate the NHS in a fun way that also appeals to children at Halloween.
Jonathan Sanderson, managing director of IT recruitment company Corecom Consulting, is asking people to Howl for Heroes on their doorsteps at 7pm on Saturday.
Mr Sanderson said:
Harrogate Nightingale ‘could open with five days notice’“My children, along with so many others, are disappointed that the traditional evening of our local community in Harrogate coming together trick or treating will not be able to happen due to covid.
“Howl for Heroes is a socially distanced, fun and noisy alternative to coming together on the evening and recognising the hard work of the NHS who are continuing to support those suffering with the illness.”
The Harrogate Nightingale hospital will be ready to take patients at five days notice by the end of the week, according to its medical director.
Dr Yvette Oade said it was “hard to predict” when the hospital, which was set-up at a cost of £27m to cater for covid patients in Yorkshire and the Humber, might be needed.
But she said people should be “very concerned” because the infection rate was rising rapidly across the region and hospital admissions were increasing.
The government said last week the Harrogate Nightingale was being put on standby.
Speaking on BBC Look North last night, Dr Oade described the hospital as “an insurance policy” that would be required if hospitals in the region reached maximum capacity. She added:
“You only draw on your insurance policies when things have not worked to plan.
“Right now the hospital isn’t needed, our colleagues are doing a great job around the region.
“People should be very concerned. Infection rates in Yorkshire and the Humber are one of the highest in the country. We’ve seen hospital admissions rising quickly.
“By the end of this week we will be ready to open to patients if given five days notice.
“Right now the hospital isn’t needed. It’s hard for me to predict when this hospital might be needed. The important thing is if we are needed then we will be ready.”
Read more:
- Exclusive: Harrogate Nightingale hospital unable to open safely
- Harrogate Nightingale hospital put on standby
Last week Lord Newby, the Ripon-based Liberal Democrat leader in the House of Lords suggested the hospital might not be able to open fully because it “simply does not have the staff available to allow it to operate safely”.
Asked about staffing, Dr Oade said the Harrogate Nightingale would need staff from other NHS organisations.
She added:
Art event will raise money for Harrogate hospital charity“If we get to the stage where we need the Nightingale hospitals it’s likely that because our acute trust will be so full that some of those procedures that they are currently doing will need to be halted.”
Local artist Jos Haigh will sell her work at a preview event to raise money for Harrogate Hospital & Community Charity.
The event, at the Cedar Court Hotel in Harrogate on November 27, will showcase Ms Haigh’s vibrant wildlife art while also generating funds for the charity.
One hundred percent of the sale prices will go to the charity, which funds specialist equipment, training and services at Harrogate District Hospital outside what the NHS provides.
The charity recently funded colouring and art materials for patients at the hospital during the pandemic.
People who attend the preview event will have the opportunity to meet Ms Haigh, who lives in Harrogate and exhibits all over the country, as well as enjoy mince pies and mulled wine.
Christmas gifts and the charity’s newly launched 2021 calendar will also be on sale.
Ms Haigh told the Stray Ferret her works of art had been in a gallery in York for three weeks but lockdown had restricted viewings so she decided to donate them to the charity. She added:
“I chose to donate these paintings after the extremely tough year HDFT has had dealing with a global pandemic as well as the usual challenges that healthcare brings.
“I wanted to say a rainbow thank you to my local NHS trust for all it has done and continues to do.”
Read more:
- StrayArt with Johnny Messum: The significance of bronze
- Harrogate Hospital releases charity calendar
Sammy Lambert, business development, charity and volunteer manager at HHCC, said:
“We are so grateful for this incredible donation of paintings from Jos. They are beautiful and will brighten up people’s homes, even more so in the knowledge that they are supporting their local NHS.”
The preview evening is free to attend but tickets must but pre-booked. To get one, email hdft.hhcc@nhs.net.
If you can’t make the evening, Ms Haigh’s paintings are available to view and purchase here.