Harrogate Convention Centre investment ‘obscene’, says Mayor of Ripon

The Mayor of Ripon has denounced a £46.8 million investment in Harrogate Convention Centre as a waste of money which will not benefit people elsewhere in the district.

It comes as senior councillors on the borough council will decide on Wednesday whether to spend £1 million to develop plans for the upgrade and spend £155,000 over three years to appoint a project manager.

A confidential cabinet report leaked to the Stray Ferret warns the HCC “will not survive” unless councillors approve a £46.8 million project, which includes full renovation of the venue.

Read more:

But, the decision has raised concern among those in the wider district who feel that the investment is centred on what economic benefit can be increased in Harrogate and not in the surrounding areas.

Eamon Parkin, mayor of Ripon 2019-20

Cllr Eamon Parkin, Mayor of Ripon.

Cllr Eamon Parkin, independent mayor of Ripon, said the city and its residents will not benefit from the investment. He added that few visit the convention centre.

Cllr Parkin said:

“It’s an obscene amount of money.

“We never benefit from it here in Ripon. In my opinion, there is never anything worth going to.

“My background is in entertainment and a building like that should be attracting big names, but there is never anything on. I think it is shambolic.”

He added that the HCC suffered from better events and entertainment being held at Leeds Arena.

Meanwhile, opposition Liberal Democrat councillors said years of underinvestment has damaged the HCC and council officials need to “bite the bullet” and invest in the venue.

Pat Marsh, leader of the Lib Dems and board member at the HCC, said the future of the centre was a stark decision between spending money on the centre and walking away from it.

Despite the coronavirus pandemic, Cllr Marsh said people will still want to meet at events in person and attend conferences which the HCC needed to be prepared for.

But, she added that any move to spend money on the centre needed to be value for money for taxpayers.

Cllr Marsh said:

“It is a stark decision between investing in the centre or selling it and walking away.

“It is valuable to the local economy. We have to bite the bullet and unless someone can come forward with another way, I cannot see any other way than investing for our people.

“What we need to do is make sure that there is value for money. We have got to make sure that this investment is key for the taxpayer.”

Harrogate Borough Council was approached for comment to respond to the concerns of those in the wider district, but did not respond.

However, the authority has always maintained that the venue has a benefit to the district and that the renovation will help to improve the economy.

Cllr Graham Swift, cabinet member for economic development, said last week:

“Harrogate Convention Centre makes such an important contribution to the district’s economy.

“It is central to the viability of many hundreds of businesses and our recent experience of lockdown shows just what a positive difference it makes locally.

“Redeveloping the centre will make it a much more flexible space that can attract a broader customer base and will have the potential to substantially increase its economic contribution.

“It will also enable us to create a unique facility we can all be proud of which also attracts new events to Harrogate, the district and North Yorkshire.

“I hope my fellow councillors will support this initial investment that will enable us to get the ball rolling on design and construction plans.”

£60m or £35m: What is the value of Harrogate Convention Centre to the district?

For the past decade, Harrogate Borough Council has publicly sold the HCC as having an economic benefit to the town of around £60m.   

Yet at a full council meeting in December last year that figure dropped to a value of £35 million.   

This week councillors will take a step towards taking one of the biggest financial decisions in recent decades – £47 million worth of investment of taxpayers’ money in the HCC in an effort to make it profitable.  

The question is – what is the real value of the HCC to the local economy?

Read more:

The £60 million figure has been included in almost all local authority reports, including its annual report in 2019.   

That figure has been based upon annual economic impact summaries carried out by the council and includes a range of assumptions, such as average visitor numbers, how much each individual spends and length of stay.   

An example of an economic impact summary used to assess the value of the HCC in 2016/17.

In its annual report in 2019, the council said: 

“We are responding to the challenges of the changing nature of the conference industry by redeveloping the Harrogate Convention Centre site.  

“The facility contributes around £55 million a year to the local economy and has an important role to play in the district.” 

That was until December that year when council leader, Richard Cooper, was quoted at a full council meeting as saying the HCC is worth £35 million to the town.

Minutes from the meeting said: 

“The leader reported on the performance for the last year and advised that the Visit Britain methodology was now being used to calculate the economic impact for the district. 

“The number of conferences and exhibitions had remained the same and using the new methodology it was estimated that the HCC would drive approximately £35 million of economic impact for 2019/20.”   

It brings into question how the council had previously reached a figure almost double that and whether it felt some pressure to justify continued investment.

And is that value just to Harrogate alone? There are those outside the town who argue that a huge amount of public money is spent on a centre that does not bring significant economic benefit to the wider district.

Convention Centre losses  

In the last 12 financial years, the centre has reported a loss on eight occasions and seen its income drop from £7 million in 2008 to £4 million 10 years later.

As a subsidised economic driver for the town, the HCC relies on taxpayer money to be able to operate the way it does.  

According to the council’s own statement of accounts, in the years where the HCC made a loss the total cost to the public purse was £5,793,606.

Harrogate Convention Centre will have 500 beds when it opens as a Nightingale hospital

Harrogate Convention Centre.

Meanwhile, council papers leaked to The Stray Ferret show that it reported a £710,000 cost for 2019/20.  

Explaining the loss, the report said:  

“This is largely attributed to the increasingly ageing facilities which are of a poorer quality and scale than HCC’s growing number of competitors (many of which have also been redeveloping in recent years).   

“This in turn has led to a loss of market share and a fall in the number and scale of events.” 

It paints a picture of an operating model that requires radical change in order to better serve its customers.  

Years of indecision  

Four years and four consultants on, the HCC and its future remains uncertain.  

2016 –  The Right Solution published a report into the future of the centre and listed recommendations including an arms length company. Paid £32,572.

2018 – IPW Consultancy is brought in to review market analysis of conferences and exhibition centres and 

2018 – Property advisor Cushman and Wakefield was appointed by the council to come up with a business case for the site. Paid £137,550.

2018 – Group Ginger was also appointed to develop a masterplan of the redevelopment. 

But a further £40,000 was granted in November 2019 to commission a consultant to look into a different option for the site following a change in leadership at the HCC.

The borough council appointed Cushman and Wakefield as the consultants for the plan. 

The report said: 

“The HCC redevelopment project poses significant commercial, reputational and financial risks to the council and in order that we are able to make sound recommendations for investment decisions, we are now seeking to commission further specialist advice to test and compare how the alternative, client-led option performs against the status quo position and the original project objectives.” 

Now again in 2020 the borough council looks set to spend £1 million, most of which will be borrowed, to consult further on one set of design proposals.

Is there a different vision? 

The decision going to the council offers only one vision – to keep the site as a convention centre. The only question put to councillors is how much money they want to spend on refurbishing it.

Could there be a different vision for the site that could provide a sustainable economic driver for Harrogate? That is not on the table.

The borough council it seems has put all of our eggs in one basket in the hope the centre will finally start to make a profit and bring more income to Harrogate.

Read more:

 

No coronavirus deaths at Harrogate Hospital for nine days

Latest NHS England figures show that no coronavirus deaths have been reported at Harrogate District Hospital for nine days.

It means the death toll at the hospital remains at 82. The last reported death was on July 15.

Read more: 

Meanwhile, face coverings became mandatory in shops and supermarkets today.

The new guidelines state that coverings will be mandatory when buying takeaway food and drink but can be removed when seated at a table. 

Failure to wear a face covering could result in a £100 fine, however North Yorkshire Police said this would be a “last resort”.

Harrogate District Hospital reports no further coronavirus deaths

Latest figures from NHS England show no further coronavirus deaths have been reported at Harrogate District Hospital in the last 24 hours.

It means the total number of deaths from coronavirus at the hospital remains at 82.

Meanwhile, nationally, a further 10 deaths from patients who tested positive for the virus have died in hospital.

Read more: 

Of that number, one patient died in the North East and Yorkshire.

NHS England said the patients were aged between 50 and 97 years old and all had known underlying health conditions.

It takes the national death toll from coronavirus up to 29,212.

Harrogate Leeds United fans prepare for Premier League

After 16 years outside English football’s top flight, Leeds United fans in Harrogate are preparing for a return to the Premier League and a first piece of silverware in 28 years.

The Whites confirmed promotion last Friday after an Emile Smith Rowe goal in the 86th minute for Huddersfield Town defeated West Bromwich Albion 2-1.

Less than 24 hours later, United clinched the title without kicking a ball as third-placed Brentford lost to Stoke City.

For Lai Lam, branch member and publicity officer at Harrogate and District Leeds United Supporters group, the moment on Friday night was special.

“I got loads of messages about going down to Elland Road but I’m trying to be responsible so stayed away.

“I saw the footage of the ones who did though, then saw the team on the steps of the East Stand on Facebook. It was brilliant.”

The supporters group, which was formerly Knaresborough branch until 1996, has around 150 paid members and usually follows the club home and away.

Read more: 

Miss Lam, a season ticket holder for 30 years, joined the branch for the 1995/96 season and saw United relegated to the Championship at Bolton in 2004. She said:

“Most of us realised we were going down but we didn’t realise it was only the start of the rot that took us even lower.”

After a play-off final defeat to Watford in 2006, United dropped into the third tier for the first time in the club’s history the following season.

https://twitter.com/LUFC/status/1284470294263083008

Promotion back to the second division in 2010 was a ray of hope in dark times. But the appointment of Marcelo Bielsa as head coach in 2018 proved to be the catalyst for a return to the Premier League.

Now, Miss Lam and fellow branch members are itching to get back into the ground to see the team for the first time since March. She said:

“We play some of the best football I’ve have seen in years. I’m looking forward to seeing how Bielsa’s ways work in the Premier League. 

“The man is a genius. He’s completely transformed football in two short years.

“When we can get into the grounds it’ll be great to see the atmosphere that our fans generate.”

Before that though, there is a small matter of lifting the Championship trophy, which United will be presented with following the Charlton game tonight.

Amid the pandemic, football fans have been forced to watch their teams away from the stadiums. Instead, Miss Lam will celebrate the Whites’ first piece of silverware since 1992 at home with friends. 

“It has ruined what should have been a fantastic end to the season. This is the first year the players and the club have been so approachable and we could really have enjoyed it with them.

“But we’re promoted with the best points tally for ages.”

No further coronavirus care home or hospital deaths in Harrogate

Harrogate District Hospital has reported no further coronavirus deaths and no new care home deaths have been recorded, according to latest figures.

Data from NHS England showed no patients who tested positive for coronavirus were reported to have died at the hospital in the last 24 hours.

The death toll from Covid at the hospital remains at 82.

Read more:

Nationally, a further 15 people have died in England’s hospitals after testing positive for coronavirus. It takes the death toll in the nation’s hospitals to 29,202.

NHS England said the patients were aged between 46 and 90. Five patients, aged between 46 and 84, had no known underlying health conditions.

Office for National Statistics data, published today, showed no further deaths in care homes due to coronavirus in the Harrogate district from 3 July to 10 July

It means the number of people who have died in care homes remains at 104.

Councillors appointed onto parish council with just one member

Two borough councillors have been appointed onto Green Hammerton Parish Council after the authority was left with only one member and unable to conduct business.

Calls for four new parish councillors went out in April when the number of members shrunk to three.

Following the resignations of Councillor Jackson in June and Councillor Knight in July, membership was further reduced to one.

An election would normally have been held to fill the vacancies. However, the coronavirus pandemic has forced elections to be postponed until May 2021.

Read more:

This left the parish council with just one member and unable to conduct its business properly.

Harrogate Borough Council agreed yesterday to appoint district councillor Ann Myatt and county councillor Andrew Paraskos onto the council for a maximum of three months.

The authority will now be quorate, meaning it can co-opt new councillors to fill the remaining vacant seats and continue to operate.

Had they not been co-opted, HBC’s alternative proposal was to dissolve the parish council, which has an electorate of 677 people,

A report before HBC’s General Purposes Committee said there was interest in the remaining vacancies.

It said:

“The parish clerk has advised that there are currently several applicants that would like to be considered for co-option into the vacant seats. This can be actioned once Cllr Myatt and Cllr Paraskos are appointed to the council.”

Police call for Harrogate pub’s licence to be revoked

North Yorkshire Police has called for a Harrogate pub’s licence to be removed after it came under fire for breaching lockdown rules.

The Coach and Horses was told by Harrogate Borough Council that its licence was under review after people gathered outside the pub on West Park drinking which breached coronavirus guidelines.

The pub was issued a prohibition notice by the council on May 31 for “repeatedly breaking the rules”. Officials said around 75 customers were in the area drinking at one point.

People outside the Coach and Horses back in May.

People gathered outside the Coach and Horses back in May.

Now, police have called for the pub to be stripped of its licence in the interests of public safety.

Councillors on the borough council’s licensing committee will decide on the future of the pub’s licence on Wednesday.

Read more:

In a letter to the council’s licensing committee, Jackie Allen, police licensing officer, said the Coach and Horses did not comply with coronavirus regulations.

It said:

“It is believed that if the premises are allowed to retain a premise licence this will have an adverse effect on the local community…

“It is the view of North Yorkshire Police that the premises licence should be revoked and would respectfully direct members to Section 17 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 ‘it shall be the duty of each authority to which the section applies to do all it reasonably can to prevent crime and disorder in its area.’”

The force said it received 14 separate reports from members of the public between May 30 and June 2 over customers drinking from open containers outside. Police say this also breaches the pub’s licence.

 

No further coronavirus deaths at Harrogate hospital

No coronavirus deaths have been reported today at Harrogate District Hospital, according to the latest NHS England figures.

It comes after a further death was reported yesterday, taking the death toll at the hospital to 82.

Nationally, a further six people who tested positive for coronavirus have died in England’s hospitals.

Read more:

Of that number, one was reported in the North East and Yorkshire region.

NHS England said those who died were aged between 74 and 98 and had known underlying health conditions.

It means the death toll in the nation’s hospitals has increased to 29,187.

County council faces £126m coronavirus cost over three years

North Yorkshire County Council has estimated that responding to coronavirus could cost the authority £126 million over the next three years.

Cllr Gareth Dadd, cabinet member for finance at the county council, is expected to tell councillors at a full council meeting that uncertainty still remained around future costs but that the authority is “well placed” to deal with it.

It comes as the council is anticipating a deficit of £73 million by the end of this financial year, which reduces to £39 million after government funding is taken into account.

Council officials have already said that the authority can avoid bankruptcy and would not need to issue a section 114 notice – which bans any further spending in dire financial circumstances.

Read more:

But, Cllr Dadd will tell councillors next week that it is “extremely likely” that there will be legacy costs as a result of the pandemic.

He will say:

“Many uncertainties remain in estimating future years but it is extremely likely that there will be legacy costs which last well into the next three years and initial estimates suggest that we may have a £126 million hit on the council’s finances over that period. 

“It will not be possible to bridge this by use of reserves alone so we are going to have to await developments from the governments’ Spending Review and, in parallel, we will need to prepare plans for how we respond to different scenarios with varying degrees of funding shortfall.”

Meanwhile, local authorities across the country have warned that without support many will be forced to issue bankruptcy notices.

The Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government announced a further £500 million package of funding earlier this month to support council spending pressures.

Funding allocations have yet to be revealed, but the scheme is expected to reimburse authorities for lost income and allow council tax and business rates deficits to be paid over three years instead of one.